A ROW over the merits of Shipley's impressionist Christmas tree has spread to local councillors who are joining the debate.

Yesterday, the Telegraph & Argus reported how local MP Philip Davies had damned the metal conical erection as an "artificial monstrosity" which is an embarrassment to Shipley and should be replaced with a traditional tree by Bradford Council.

But Windhill councillor Susan Hinchcliffe, the executive member for culture and events with the Council's ruling Labour group, today hit back at Mr Davies' comments - pointing out that the modernist structure had been in place for some time.

"I'm sorry Mr Davies has such a strong and sudden aversion to the tree," Cllr Hinchcliffe said.

"Shipley Town Centre Partnership first commissioned it in 2008 and it's been used every year since.

"The tree and the other illuminations in the town were created and are still maintained by ISG, a successful local social business who predominantly employ people with disabilities and manufacture quality Christmas lights not just for Bradford, but also for other towns and cities all over the country," Cllr Hinchcliffe said.

"To be honest, I find it frustrating that in a week where we've had to announce another £35 million of Government cuts on Bradford district, Mr Davies shows more concern for the Christmas tree than making sure we get a fairer deal from Westminster."

Shipley councillor and Green Party leader Martin Love said he said he had an alternative idea."I would much prefer it if they planted a living tree and had it there permanently rather than cut one down just for Christmas.

"We have suggested this, as then a proper tree could just be decorated with lights every year."

Fellow Green Party councillor for Shipley Kevin Warnes agreed: "The council could create a special tree pit with a tree which would cost nothing after the initial outlay and then it could be decorated and used in other events through the year.

"One thing with the current 'tree' is the horrible metal crash barriers around it, which could surely be replaced with something more festive," Cllr Warnes said.

Shipley indoor market manager Heidi McKenna said customers seemed to be split down the middle over the tree.

"My view is at a time of cutting everything back, they have bought the tree, it's cost effective and works as a festive symbol, plus they can recycle it every year.

"There's plenty of other things going on in Shipley this Christmas, and also places where money needs to be spent," Mrs McKenna said.