Battle over where body of Richard III should be reburied is rejoined with Bradford solicitor to the fore

Battle over where body of Richard III should be reburied is rejoined with Bradford solicitor to the fore

Battle over where body of Richard III should be reburied is rejoined with Bradford solicitor to the fore

First published in News Bradford Telegraph and Argus: Photograph of the Author by , Aire/Worth Valley Reporter

A Bradford solicitor is battling in London to bring King Richard III's remains back to Yorkshire after his undignified resting place was discovered beneath a Leicester car park.

The fight to bury the bones of last Yorkist monarch in the county has reached the crunch point with a two-day judicial review at London's High Court due to end today.

Three judges are reviewing earlier decisions which permitted the exhumation and reinterring of the monarch's remains in Leicester.

Legal expert Matthew Howarth, of Bradford law firm Gordons, is representing a group of the king's collateral descendants – dubbed the Plantagenet Alliance Ltd – which wants the verdict favouring Leicester overturned and the remains reinterred at York Minster.

The hearing is considering the Alliance’s challenge to processes surrounding the Ministry of Justice’s decision to grant a licence under the Burial Act to the University of Leicester, which authorised it to remove the king’s remains from beneath a Leicester City Council car park in autumn 2012 and reinter them.

The university later announced it intended the reburial would take place in Leicester Cathedral. Yesterday the alliance called on Justice Secretary Chris Grayling to help determine where the remains should be reburied.

In the unprecedented legal clash, the alliance asked judges to rule that Mr Grayling is under a legal duty to set up a wide-ranging public consultation exercise to decide the question.

The group’s counsel Gerard Clarke told London's High Court the alliance would be satisfied by whatever answer that produced.

Mr Clarke told Lady Justice Hallett, Mr Justice Ouseley and Mr Justice Haddon-Cave that the Queen was "silent" on the question of the last resting place of her 14th great-grand uncle.

Leicester Cathedral wanted the remains while York Minster itself was "neutral".

Mr Clarke argued the Justice Secretary had a duty to set up public consultations to include the Crown, and groups including English Heritage, relevant churches, other public bodies "and those who claim a family relationship with the late king".

When Lady Justice Hallett queried whether the right to be consulted applied to "each of the king's ten million collateral descendants” said to be living, Mr Clarke conceded “that would be silly” and said it only applied to those “who may have views”.

The proceedings have been described as “the (legal) Wars of the Roses part two”.

Mr Howarth, the partner and judicial review expert at Gordons representing the alliance, said ahead of the hearing: “Quite why our opponents have declined the obviously sensible option of independent adjudication, preferring to incur substantial legal costs – including for the taxpayer – and tie up considerable court time, is inexplicable.

“Although many people are astonished we've got this far, we'll go to the hearing with every confidence in our position, intending to state our case clearly and believing there's every chance the licence will be quashed.

"If that happens, the odds about the king eventually being laid to rest in York will shorten dramatically."

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:22pm Thu 13 Mar 14

alive and awake says...

"Richard of York" enough said.
"Richard of York" enough said. alive and awake
  • Score: 7

2:51am Fri 14 Mar 14

collos25 says...

I really like most people have little interest where this skeleton is buried.
I really like most people have little interest where this skeleton is buried. collos25
  • Score: -8

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree