Reform UK responds to criticism over Worth Valley by-election

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

REFORM UK has hit back at claims they were "disrespectful" and wasted taxpayers' money.

A controversial by-election was held in Keighley last Friday - which saw Conservative Paul Golding elected as District Councillor for Worth Valley - a scenic part of the Bradford district renowned worldwide as Bronte Country.

The controversy surrounding the by-election, initiated by Reform, centres around the fact that the vote was held not long after the death of Conservative Councillor Russell Brown, who had had represented the ward for 15 years, at an estimated cost to the taxpayer of £35,000.

What's more, the seat will soon be contested again in the all-out elections in May, so the elected representative will only be in office for a matter of weeks.

Candidates and residents alike have criticised Reform's decision to hold the by-election on the basis that it was unnecessary, costly to the taxpayer and "disrespectful".

Reform has hit back, stating that 'democracy is not negotiable, no ifs, no buts' - with the Party's defeated candidate adding that Councillor Brown was a friend and colleague with whom he had "enjoyed many a conversation over a drink" after town council meetings.

Keen to gauge reaction

Keen to gauge reaction, the Telegraph & Argus has spoken to candidates and residents alike after the by-election at Victoria Hall, Keighley Leisure Centre.

Inside the leisure centre. (Image: T&A)

We were very angry

Sabine Ebert-Forbes is a Worth Valley resident who also stood as an Independent candidate in Friday's by-election.

“When we heard that Reform were wanting to have the by-election we were very angry because of the cost," she said.

“The money could be better spent for the elderly, for vulnerable people.

“I also found it a very sad thing because Mr Russell was very much respected in the Worth Valley."

No opportunity to grieve

“People weren’t given the opportunity to grieve and then move on," Ms Ebert-Forbes said.

“And the other thing that struck me as rather bad and strange is there is a local election scheduled for May.

“I can’t see sense in holding this election for these reasons.

“I think it’s horrible to hold a by-election so soon after Mr Russell’s passing."

The new District Councillor Paul Golding. (Image: Worth Valley Conservatives)

Response from the Green candidate

Josie McMaster ran as a Green Party candidate. She told the T&A she was new to the world of running for public office, but felt the by-election was "unnecessary."

“It’s just a big waste of public money for a result that’s only likely to last for a very short amount of time," said Ms McMaster.

“It could all have been done in May, it’s unnecessary.

“The ward is very well-supported by two active councillors, both do good work, there was no need for this by-election."

'They've cost taxpayers £35,000'

“I think it was probably that Reform wanted to test the waters just to see how divisive they could be and in the process, they’ve cost the taxpayer £35,000," the candidate said.

“Andrew Judson put up a social media post saying calling the by-election doesn’t cost anything, it only costs if you contest it. That’s not democracy, that’s dictatorship.”

“To put something like that is quite denigrating to the electorate.

“Some people could say it’s self-serving.”

The main thing is for Reform to loose

Peter Kates, Labour candidate, echoed the thoughts of his fellow candidates: “The main thing we’re looking for in the Worth Valley is for Reform to lose.

“That’s the good thing [that they lost].

“I sincerely think that it’s crass, it’s a waste of taxpayer’s money and ultimately a waste of everyone’s time including theirs [Reform UK].

“It serves them right to loose," he added.

“It’s a shame we’re wasting council taxpayer’s money on effectively an opinion poll for Reform UK.

“What Reform UK are interested in is trying to get headlines, and just trying any opening they can and I think their fingers have got caught in a mouse trap.

“As I say they’ve shamelessly promoted themselves at the public’s expense, and they’re about to feel the consequences of that.

Victoria Hall, Keighley Leisure Centre. (Image: T&A)

I was terribly sorry to hear of Russell’s passing

“I was terribly sorry to hear of Russell’s passing," Mr Kates said.

"He was always very brilliant to talk to, and it’s a terrible disrespect to him and his legacy to have what is ultimately a very expensive opinion poll done when there was absolutely no need for it.

“What the area needs is someone who will be visible, accessible, and stand up for the Worth Valley.”

A sadly very cynical Reform Party

Conservative Councillor Rebecca Poulsen described Reform UK as "cynical".

“This by-election was called by a sadly very cynical Reform Party following the sad death of Cllr Russell Brown just before Christmas," the Cllr told the T&A.

“We’re literally five weeks from starting the local election period so whoever is elected will then be back up for election in five weeks.

“It’s anticipated this will cost between £30,000 to £35,000 just to hold an election for five weeks.

“And the message from Worth Valley voters we’ve spoken to is it’s a complete waste of money.”

The perspective from a Worth Valley resident

Worth Valley residents were also in attendance at the event.

Andrew Knight is one of those residents - and a former Special Constable at West Yorkshire Police.

No longer affiliated with any political party, he considers himself "politically homeless", but not without strong political feeling.

“I’m a former Labour Party member, I’m now politically homeless," he said.

“Russell Brown was a good man, he deserved to see out his term after he died."

There’s nothing less British

“There’s nothing less British in my opinion than what they’ve done," he said.

“What disrespect, what a waste of money for something that’s going to be re-done in a couple of months.

“I’m very angry and I think all of us should be very angry with Reform.

“I wish Paul Golding all the best but the Conservatives need to sort out their own house.

“My own view is I’m very, very angry with Reform.

“What a stupid farce for someone’s ego.”

Response from Reform's Andrew Judson

The T&A approached Andrew Judson, the Reform UK candidate and Chair of the Ilkley and Keighley branch at the event.

He told the T&A he was unable to comment but later provided the following statement.

"Democracy is not negotiable, no ifs, no buts.

"With regard to the sad death of Cllr Russell Brown and the comments that I personally have been disrespectful, I say this.

"For my part at least, Russell was a friend and colleague, we worked alongside each other on Keighley Town Council on which we both sat, and we worked together for three years on the Keighley Neighbourhood development plan and enjoyed many a conversation over a drink afterwards.

"I had and still have the highest respect for Russell."

Mr Judson also claimed that the by-election cost residents just £1.60 per person: "£1.60 per person is a small price to pay for democracy," he added.

This claim has been refuted by Worth Valley Ward Councillor Rebecca Poulsen.

She responded: “Reform can try to play with the numbers, but it is around £35,000 of taxpayer’s money that they have wasted. 

"Mr Judson is clearly sensitive that he called an election expecting to win and the people of the Worth Valley have shown him they have no time for his brand of petty politics.  

"The Worth Valley ward is represented by a strong local team who have a track record of working day in day out for our area, and I’d like to thank every resident who has supported us to represent them.”

The Council confirmed that though it's too early to provide the costs of the by-election, as costs are covered retrospectively, the estimate was around £35,000.

However this cannot be confirmed until all invoices have been paid.

The T&A will provide an exact figure on the cost of the by-election as soon as this is made publicly available.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos