Why shops selling illegal cigarettes often avoid prosecution

Counterfeit cigarettes recently seized by Trading Standards <i>(Image: West Yorkshire Trading Standards)</i>
Counterfeit cigarettes recently seized by Trading Standards (Image: West Yorkshire Trading Standards)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

SHOP owners who sell counterfeit cigarettes often avoid prosecution because Trading Standards don’t have the budget to fund the court cases.

At a recent meeting of Bradford Council’s Licensing Panel, members were told that the organisation cannot afford to prosecute every retailer who sells illegal goods because of strained funds.

Instead the organisation has to look at measures such as seizing goods to deter rogue retailers.

'We don't have the resources'

The panel had been holding a licence review into 263 Allerton Road, known as Fresh Market, and were told the business had been caught selling illegal cigarettes on four occasions in six months.

Councillor Martin Love (Green, Shipley) asked if there had been any prosecutions relating to the case – considering the amount of times illegal cigarettes were found.

Jason Bethell from West Yorkshire Trading Standards said: “We don’t have the resources.

“We can only really prosecute the biggest seizures.

“We have to fund any prosecutions through private prosecutions, and we only have a limited budget to do that.

“We’ve had some cases where defendants and lawyers have dragged it on for several years and we have to spend thousands on barrister’s bills.”

He said in some cases defendants have sold their shops by the time the case comes to court, and are unemployed.

This means that after lengthy court cases, defendants can sometimes end up with a fine of as little as £120.

Mr Bethell said: “Other times there are questions over ownership – that is a typical ploy to avoid prosecution.”

Lack of powers

Members were told that Trading Standards often goes down other means to punish the owners of these businesses.

These include seizures of the goods, which are often worth tens of thousands of pounds, and revoking their alcohol licence.

However, even if an alcohol licence is revoked, there are no powers to prevent the shop from continuing to sell legal tobacco products.

The panel voted to revoke the shop’s licence, but Cllr Love raised the same issue at a meeting of Bradford Council’s Corporate Scrutiny Committee the following day.

At that meeting Andy Robson from West Yorkshire Joint Services was giving an update on the work of Trading Standards.

'We have to take a different approach'

Cllr Love said he had been told Trading Standards did not have the funds to carry out many prosecutions, adding: “Given the amount of money the Government is losing in duty due to these illegal cigarettes it seems very short sighted to not fund the service better.”

Mr Robson said: “I would agree with you.

“We have to take a different approach – we try to remove products from those retailers to hit them financially.

“That can be a lot more significant than a £120 fine. It is having an impact.

“In some cases we can close a business for three months. Acts like this have far more of an impact on people involved in this illegal activity.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos