Soft goals leave Bradford City too much ground to make up

31 Alan Connell evades an Exeter tackle as he impresses on his first league start since December 31 Alan Connell evades an Exeter tackle as he impresses on his first league start since December

Exeter 4, City 1

Not for the first time, Gary Jones traipsed away from St James Park with a scowl.

“I hate coming here,” he muttered. “We always get beat by four. Rochdale got done here 4-0 last year when we got relegated and now this one.”

In truth, the final scoreline in no way reflected the manner of the game. Some more open-minded Exeter fans in front of the press box even admitted their side were a bit fortunate to take another three-point step towards promotion.

But you could understand how the City skipper felt. He had done more than anybody to try to right the ship after two woefully soft goals in the first half destroyed any immediate plans of closing the gap to the play-offs.

City had given it a good go in the final 45 minutes, driven on by the sweat and toil of Jones and the pace and dancing feet of a rejuvenated Kyel Reid.

But ultimately a first defeat since Wembley has effectively consigned the Bantams among the mid-table also-rans. The distance to the top seven is now ten points – a fairly decisive margin, barring a late spurt of the 1996 variety.

It’s not just Jones with bitter memories of this particular corner of Devon. For City, it felt like a depressing episode of déjà vu.

Four years ago, the Stuart McCall promotion bandwagon was derailed when a freak wind-assisted cross drifted over Rhys Evans from the touchline.

On Saturday, Evans was sitting on the home bench watching Matt Duke suffer similar indignities.

Ex again marked the spot where City’s hopes of finally scrambling out of League Two were effectively buried for at least another 12 months.

A pre-match storm of Noah’s Ark proportions transformed the pitch into a heavy, unpredictable field strewn with patches of surface water. The accompanying swirling wind just added to the problems for both keepers.

Duke’s embarrassment soon followed when he was caught out by Exeter’s first corner. Left back Craig Woodman drifted the ball on the gust and the keeper could only finger it on to the back post and in.

Exeter’s second hardly made for better viewing. With half-time in sight – and the home side offering no threat since that early gift – Jake Gosling’s looping cross flicked off Nathan Doyle to deceive Duke and allow loan midfielder Lawson D’Ath to mark his debut with a close-range header.

Phil Parkinson’s team line-up – and set-up – had been well received with the City fans. Alan Connell, who has become their cause celebre over recent weeks, got his chance as the boss tweaked the system.

Making his first league start since December, Connell’s return meant a reappearance for the diamond with instructions to play off the power of James Hanson and Garry Thompson.

But Parkinson had not factored in the weather and the sudden deterioration of the playing surface; best laid plans and all that.

The City chief said: “The pitch looked great when we came. But then there was the torrential downpour and it didn’t really suit his type of play.

“Alan’s more of a technical player but it became more about turning the opposition round. But he did okay, he showed some good touches and deserved to stay on the pitch because he had a go.”

Connell converted to a more conventional striker when Parkinson threw on his two wingers at the break. Thompson and Doyle were sacrificed for Reid and Zavon Hines and City were ordered to push up the pitch.

Having sat too deep before, the back four now played a higher line and the team moved further into home territory as a result.

Admittedly Exeter hardly had reason to chase the game with a two-goal cushion. Their stylish gaffer Paul Tisdale, bedecked head-to-toe in the latest Ted Baker designer gear, looked a composed figure on the touchline.

Facing a side who had kept seven clean sheets in their last nine outings, Parkinson was predictably far more animated outside the adjoining dugout.

But he was pleased with what he saw – especially from Reid, who finally cast off the shackles that have been holding him back to look like the winger we all know can terrify any defence in this division.

Exeter resorted to triple-teaming him but that did not stop a steady supply of crosses that were begging to be finished.

With Hines trying to do the same on the right, admittedly with mixed success, City were having that “right go” that their manager had promised.

Hanson could have had two as one effort was bundled off the line and another stretching volley flew over with keeper Artur Krysiak a spectator.

Eventually the pressure brought a reward, with Reid following Woodman’s lead with a goal direct from a corner – though the decisive touch came off the head of the Exeter defender at the near post.

But City’s comeback ambitions were halted in their tracks within four minutes as the impressive Scot Bennett blasted past Duke from 25 yards.

A fourth Exeter goal, from a three-on-three break as John O’Flynn tapped in after Duke had parried from Mark Molesley, added some unnecessary gloss on the result.

So it was defeat in his 100th City game in charge for Parkinson and a growing sense of realism that the top seven is disappearing over the hill.

Parkinson said: “We made changes and you always take responsibility as the manager when it doesn’t work. But I honestly don’t believe it was the system or the personnel.

“I just don’t think we played with enough drive or determination in that first half in difficult conditions. You’ve got to accept it’s a battle first and foremost.

“If we’d been prepared to stand up and be counted then it would have given us a great chance because we were loads better in the second half. We had them on the rack.”

One point from the double-header in Devon was at least three below par. The task is looking too great as the list of remaining games hits single figures.

With Exeter’s own bid for an instant return to League One continuing to gather momentum, at least it may spare the Bantams a trip back there next season.

Not that it will have been any consolation for Jones and Co during their latest dissatisfying journey back up the M5.

Attendance: 4,199

Comments(9)

dannbradfc says...
9:03am Mon 18 Mar 13

Personally i don't see why we needed to change the system to accomodate Connell. It was a huge game and to be changing things as radically as we did wasn't idea; imo. All we need to do was play 442 but with more emphasis on getting forward and the wingers driving to the bye-line. This way Connell could still have played but doesn't need the pace as the ball comes back. hanson needs this type of ball also.

Yes the pitch is small but so's ours. Anyway it might calm some of the clamour for connell a little. he probably deserved a chance, at least in front of the ineffective Gray but i'd have liked to have seen him as one of two strikers.

I've said in the past umpteen times about Duke and the high ball. he's a liability and Jonny mac is so much better for the team in these situations eg corners and set-pieces....

pudseykid says...
9:19am Mon 18 Mar 13

1. J Mc should have played 2) thompson should have been on the wing, not up front. 3) doyle off at half time with atkinson remaining-what sort of stupidity is this? 4) wells on with 7 minutes to go with the score of 4-1, lunacy. 5) I work part-time. So another load of cash to watch my team being embarrassed. I actually feel more sorry for the faithful who travelled the 300+ miles, i travelled 70 (1 way). We deserve better than this...Are the directors and the "faithful" really sure that this current management team can deliver? the league position says no..we DO NOT want to be having this discussion next season when we cant get into the play offs...other clubs with much less money have managed to be up there, so why cant we..to me, PP has failed-his squad, his failure.

dannbradfc says...
9:56am Mon 18 Mar 13

pudseykid wrote:
1. J Mc should have played 2) thompson should have been on the wing, not up front. 3) doyle off at half time with atkinson remaining-what sort of stupidity is this? 4) wells on with 7 minutes to go with the score of 4-1, lunacy. 5) I work part-time. So another load of cash to watch my team being embarrassed. I actually feel more sorry for the faithful who travelled the 300+ miles, i travelled 70 (1 way). We deserve better than this...Are the directors and the "faithful" really sure that this current management team can deliver? the league position says no..we DO NOT want to be having this discussion next season when we cant get into the play offs...other clubs with much less money have managed to be up there, so why cant we..to me, PP has failed-his squad, his failure.
It does seem that others over-achieve whilst we annually under-achieve based on resoureces available.....

bcfc1903 says...
10:17am Mon 18 Mar 13

I said a good 18 months ago that BCFC should have signed Oscar Janson, Akinfenwa would also have been a great signing in January. It would also be great to get some Jewish input onto the BCFC board of directors. CTID

Rambo says...
10:24am Mon 18 Mar 13

We should probably just bulldoze Valley Parade, build a 5,000 capacity stadium with mis-matched stands, outside toilets and corrugated iron roofs, while on the pitch employ a team of cloggers who are experts in gamesmanship, anti-football and spoiling tactics. We should also limit our own support at away games to 200.

Hell, thats halfway to being successful in this league.

Seriously our tactics haven't changed since Xmas - over reliance on set peices (we've beaten the opposition for corners in every game since Villa at Vp and scored once in the league from them, on Saturday), and the fact our attack often seems to be get the ball out wide or long ball forward to Hanson. We were sussed out a while
ago and are paying the price.

i miss stallard & murray says...
12:51pm Mon 18 Mar 13

A quote from parky, "I just don’t think we played with enough drive or determination in that first half in difficult conditions. You’ve got to accept it’s a battle first and foremost".. should this not be part of PP's remit as a manager, motivating his team?

I hope it is only a short term contract as he does deserve another shot for the Capital Cup run, but I am afraid his tactics and recent league form worry me and if this continues next season we will not make any progress next year. Please prove me wrong Parky.....
How many managers would get a contract extension following the league results in 2013? Please do not extend the contract so we have to pay another manager off for his failure to achieve despite being backed by the board....

Prisoner Cell Block A says...
2:41pm Mon 18 Mar 13

Duke :(

We can't hope to throw 2 in and then go on and win a match.

We can't hope to compete with any team when the keeper remains rooted to his line and if and when he does stray he is worse than me.

This isn't knee jerk, this is hard cold fact and something I have said all season long.

Majority of goals in this division come from set pieces and crosses, what is Duke's weakest part of his game? Crosses.

Anyway, our failure to score in open play is as much at fault, the reliance on scoring from set plays has as much to do with our position and the fact most teams can now combat this.

Cityman23 says...
3:49pm Mon 18 Mar 13

bcfc1903 wrote:
I said a good 18 months ago that BCFC should have signed Oscar Janson, Akinfenwa would also have been a great signing in January. It would also be great to get some Jewish input onto the BCFC board of directors. CTID
"...would also be great to get some Jewish input onto the BCFC board.."

I am not sure I follow the 'meaning' of this comment, but if there are places on the 'B of D', I feel there should should be more 'supporter representation' there.

In Germany, many teams have a greater share of 'supporter control. FC United of Manchester was set up in this manner, and indeed Swanea, recent League Cup victors over City, are set up like this.

The future would be much better, far brighter if football was taken out of the hands of 'sugar daddies'-many of whom use clubs like a 'toy or a 'cash cow' when it come to the successful ones. Too many English clubs are owned by foreign 'investors', with no real background or connection with the clubs they now dominate.

Some may bring 'success' which, whilst it lasts will receive the uncritical thanks of fans, but it is not a 'healthy' set up. Some demand the unacceptable as at Cardiff where colours, badge etc are being 'dumped'/exchanged on a whim. Others change a ground NAME of significance for cash!

I am NOT criticising 'ML' or 'JR' specifically here and acknowledge they have played a crucial role in City's recent 'health' but the RIGHT approach is surely for responsibility to be more widely SHARED OUT between supporters.

This 'model' has been shown to work well in Germany- where match day prices even for top matces are low and supporter numbers are high. Many also believe the German top division to now be the best in Europe.

Some English clubs are following this 'model' and I for one would like to see it flourish throughout British football.

propasupporter says...
4:33pm Mon 18 Mar 13

I seriously question the validity of some people who regularly spout off their opinions on this site and who profess to be supporters of Bradford City, We have just enjoyed arguably our most productive season in recent times, Phil Parkinson is one of the most highly regarded Managers in the Football league, and he wants to stay at Bradford! Brilliant, fantastic news Rome was not built in a day neither will the team that takes us on to higher and better things, I am confident that despite our recent drop in league form, we will succeed in what must be our most important objective "promotion' please stop knocking the team and the management, leave that to the L**ds and Hudders boys. Get behind the team and trust, after all its part of being a Bradford Supporter.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree