Live blog: Plymouth v Bantams (From Bradford Telegraph and Argus)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting TANEWS to 80360, or email
Live blog: Plymouth v Bantams
Updated 9:45pm Tuesday 12th March 2013 in Sport
By Simon Parker, Bradford City Reporter
This live event has finished
Latest
- Team news
- Regular updates
- Twitter reaction
- Report
9:45pm
PLYMOUTH 0 CITY 0
Frustrated City were held to a third draw on the bounce at relegation-haunted Plymouth.
Garry Thompson had their best chance with an early one-on-one but was denied by Jake Cole's outstretched leg.
Thompson also clipped the top of the bar while Plymouth's best player, on-loan Crystal Palace winger Jason Banton hit the post.
City pushed for a goal late on but could not find a breakthrough, Kyel Reid seeing his shot parried and James Hanson's rebound being deflected narrowly wide.
But the draw moves them no nearer the top seven.
9:42pm
Mayhem in City box as McArdle panicky clearance falls short of Duke. Keeper is bundled over as he tries to catch and two Argyle players look to force it in but McHugh's there.
Mad finish to game but it's 0-0.
9:41pm
Connell shot blocked on edge of box.
9:39pm
But ref blows for foul against Hanson.
9:39pm
Reid cross turned over bar by Bhasera under pressure from Atkinson. Chance for City from corner.
9:39pm
Reid held back by Blanchard but ref instead points for goal kick. Winger felt he was fouled and it looked it.
9:37pm
Connell tries a chip but easy for keeper.
9:35pm
Six added minutes to play.
9:33pm
Here come City again but Reid is crowded out in penalty area.
9:32pm
Two Plymouth subs. Debutant Bryan makes way for Harvey and Cowan-Hall replaces Gurrieri.
9:31pm
Come on City! You need to turn these chances into a goal otherwise we won't make the play offs!!! #bcafc
— @marktownson 12 March 2013
9:28pm
Now it's Connell with a chance but the shot is saved low down.
9:27pm
Reid shot saved by Cole and Hanson's follow-up is deflected agonisingly wide.
9:26pm
Miskick by Cox to Thompson, whose shot hits the top of the bar. That was his final touch as on comes Connell.
9:23pm
Second City sub, Atkinson for Hines.
9:22pm
Inviting cross from Banton is too strong for Gurrieri at the back post as McHugh covers.
9:21pm
15 mins to go plus hefty amount of stoppage time. City need a goal from somewhere.
9:19pm
Plymouth free-kick 30 yards out but smashed well wide by Wotton.
9:17pm
Another delay as Bhasera gets treatment. Could be a fair bit of stoppage time again.
9:14pm
Sub for Plymouth as Reid replaced by Chadwick.
9:14pm
Another good corner from Doyle but it beats everyone in the packed six-yard box.
9:14pm
Doyle free-kick headed over the bar by Bhasera for a City corner.
9:13pm
Blanchard is booked for the foul and hurt himself doing it.
9:12pm
Gray subbed by Hanson. Ironic cheer from some in the away end.
9:12pm
City thought they had a penalty as Reid is brought down right on edge of box. But free-kick awarded yard outside.
9:11pm
Awkward dipping shot from Banton and Duke does well to hold it on the floor.
9:10pm
Ravenhill booked after one foul too many. Just had a lecture from ref warning no more.
9:08pm
Scrappy spell as Reuben Reid and Bryan have shots charged down in the City box.
9:06pm
City shout for handball as Gray shot hits Wotton but ref is unimpressed.
9:05pm
Corner for City and the 174 followers make some noise. It's a good one from Doyle but McHugh heads wide.
9:03pm
Banton, Plymouth's best player by far, has another shot through Darby's legs but Duke saves low down.
9:00pm
Corner for Plymouth but offside flag stops their momentum.
8:57pm
Banton tries shot from tight angle and hits outside of post.
8:56pm
Crowd is 5,609 with 174 from City.
8:53pm
Gray chests back for Doyle but it's another shot well wide.
8:51pm
City kick off second half. No changes for other side.
8:49pm
45 min to turn a draw into a win and pull 7 points behind Exeter with 2 games in hand and a trip to them on Sat #bcafc
— @BaconBantam 12 March 2013
8:34pm
Half-time 0-0
8:34pm
McHugh comes running in to meet it but his radar is awry.
8:34pm
Corner for City right on half-time.
8:33pm
Plymouth press think Branston was fortunate not to see red. It was very late.
8:32pm
Yellow card for the ex-City man.
8:31pm
Branson gone right through Thompson from behind.
8:30pm
Darby up and under cleared to edge of box where McHugh smashes volley into orbit.
8:30pm
Thompson not happy with Branston's aggressive approach.
8:27pm
City free-kick 30 yards out. Reid curls over the wall but it's a comfortable save for Cole.
8:26pm
Thompson cuts inside from Reid pass but Cox makes sliding block to deny him shot in box.
8:24pm
Miscommunication at back for Plymouth as Branston hooks ball out of Cole's hands.
8:20pm
Bloopy header from Gray is caught on line by Cole.
8:17pm
With Accrington losing 1-0, Plymouth are off the bottom as it stands.
8:16pm
Gurrieri has room to line up 25 yard shot but it's well over the bar.
8:15pm
Davies gets a whack in the chops in penalty area but nothing given.
8:15pm
City fans making themselves heard for the first time.
8:11pm
Banton cuts back to Gurrieri whose shot is cleared in front of line by McHugh. City under some pressure.
8:10pm
Poor pass from Thompson intercepted by Banton whose shot is parried by Duke.
8:08pm
Another Plymouth corner. Banton beginning to get on the ball and cause a threat.
8:05pm
#bcafc big shout to the Royal Naval Bantams! Let's show the Janners what we are all about.
— @socialsuccess71 12 March 2013
8:03pm
Been told that Chris Waddle is in the crowd tonight.
8:02pm
Duke flaps Bryan's kick away rather unconvincingly but cross back into the box is a poor one.
8:01pm
Corner for Plymouth.
7:59pm
Kyel Reid drills free-kick low but it is poor and well wide.
7:58pm
Handball outside the box gives City free-kick in good position.
7:55pm
Gray heads over bar from City corner.
7:54pm
Long ball over top springs Plymouth offside trap to leave Thompson clear on goal. Great chance to open scoring but Cole pushes shot behind.
7:53pm
Reid cross is turned over by Gurrieri who had nipped in at City near post.
7:45pm
Judge the team at full time #bcafc
— @dan_yeadon 12 March 2013
7:45pm
baffled by the continued team changes, surely pick your best team on the night, feels like pre-season? #bcafc hope I am wrong
— @monkeyista 12 March 2013
7:43pm
Brass band music greets the arrival of the teams.
7:42pm
Plymouth beat Barnet in last home game but have not won back to back at Home Park in the league all season.
7:38pm
Very low away following tonight #bcafc
— @Jason_Mckeown 12 March 2013
7:35pm
Referee Andy Davies (not to be confused with Andrew Davies...) has awarded ten penalties in 19 games.
7:34pm
Andy Gray's inclusion over Alan Connell has raised eyebrows among fans. The veteran striker is still waiting to open his account for his second spell with City - tonight would be a good place to start.
7:32pm
Think Parky's got 90mins to prove everybody wrong! #bcafc #tinkerman
— @Albertstan 12 March 2013
7:32pm
#bcafc Fingers crossed for tonight! Not convinced by Gray yet but I'll happily be proved wrong! #CTID
— @DaveFirth1982 12 March 2013
7:29pm
Not the happiest hunting ground for City - won only once in the last 12 visits to Home Park. Remember August 1994? Hammered Argyle 5-1 with a Paul Jewell hat-trick.
7:18pm
If we win tonight Saturdays game against Exeter will be a massive 6 pointer #bcafc
— @Adam_Ellis1986 12 March 2013
7:17pm
Well, the #bcafc line up for tonight boggles the mind...in particular Gray chosen over Connell. Still, in Parky we trust!
— @bantamsbanter 12 March 2013
7:10pm
Big night for City. Another draw no good at this stage of season. #bcafc
— @BantamsCraig 12 March 2013
7:10pm
Paul Wotton making his 468th appearance for Plymouth.
7:06pm
Plymouth handed an immediate debut to Bristol City midfielder Joe Bryan who only signed on loan this afternoon.
Guy Branston also lined up at centre half - the third time he had faced City this season with a third different team.
PLYMOUTH: Cole, Blanchard, Wotton, Branston, Bhasera, Gurrieri, Cox, Hourihane, Bryan, Reid, Banton. Subs: Berry, Cowan-Hall, Young, Chadwick, Murray, Harvey, Chenoweth.
6:53pm
Welcome from Home Park where Phil Parkinson has made six changes to his City side.
Matt Duke returns in goal and Andrew Davies is back at centre half for Michael Nelson.
Parkinson has named both wingers in midfield with Gary Jones given a breather in the centre as Nathan Doyle partners Ricky Ravenhill.
And both strikers have changed - but there is no Alan Connell, whose last-gasp penalty saved a point against Aldershot on Saturday. Instead Andy Gray is paired with Garry Thompson.
CITY: Duke, Darby, McArdle, Davies, McHugh, Hines, Doyle, Ravenhill, Reid, Thompson, Gray. Subs: Hanson, Atkinson, Wells, Jones, Nelson, Connell, McLaughlin.
Comments(49)
KnightMcCall
says...
7:08pm Tue 12 Mar 13
No Wells, Hanson or Connell? Bizarre! I hope that this works PP 'cos we need points right now. Really thought Connell would get a start tonight alongside Thompson or Hanson. There is rotation and their is madness!! Hines and Reid need stormers for this to work.
Come on City!!
KnightMcCall
says...
7:10pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Wrose bantam
says...
7:13pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Wrose bantam
says...
7:18pm Tue 12 Mar 13
With Gray upfront and Tommo, I am not not sure we have pace to upset the centre backs.
I hope I am wrong.
Victor Clayton
says...
7:20pm Tue 12 Mar 13
KnightMcCall wrote:His kicking was shocking Saturday. Well poor anyway.
To be honest; I don't understand Jonny Mac getting dropped either. 1 goal in three games?
lawsonio123
says...
7:34pm Tue 12 Mar 13
COLATS
says...
7:36pm Tue 12 Mar 13
KnightMcCall wrote:Cos duke is the better of the two?
To be honest; I don't understand Jonny Mac getting dropped either. 1 goal in three games?
KnightMcCall
says...
7:38pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Victor Clayton wrote:Fair point Victor; it was poor.
KnightMcCall wrote:His kicking was shocking Saturday. Well poor anyway.
To be honest; I don't understand Jonny Mac getting dropped either. 1 goal in three games?
I would still love to see the data that PP sees on fitness etc that has led to this team being selected. Approx 42 goals sat on the bench and approx 16 in the starting line-up?
KnightMcCall
says...
7:39pm Tue 12 Mar 13
COLATS wrote:Interesting; but I don't agree.
KnightMcCall wrote:Cos duke is the better of the two?
To be honest; I don't understand Jonny Mac getting dropped either. 1 goal in three games?
Tickertex
says...
7:40pm Tue 12 Mar 13
7:20pm Tue 12 Mar 13
KnightMcCall wrote:
To be honest; I don't understand Jonny Mac getting dropped either. 1 goal in three games?
His kicking was shocking Saturday. Well poor anyway.
That goes for the out field players too. It was hoof ball by all for 70 minutes.
KnightMcCall
says...
7:42pm Tue 12 Mar 13
lawsonio123 wrote:It must be difficult for players to establish playing relationships with each other when there is so little consistency. I share you "wish" though; otherwise he season is ebbing away and I will be thoroughly miserable all week.
Chopping and Changing all the time does not seem good.Maybe Mr Parkinson feels he has not as yet found his best formation. What ever the situation he is the Manager and will live or die by results so lets wish him luck and hope all ends well COME ON CITY
Bradford1903
says...
7:46pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Let's do all we can to win these games and not die wondering.
Crags
says...
9:23pm Tue 12 Mar 13
cullboy
says...
9:27pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Plastic Bantam
says...
9:43pm Tue 12 Mar 13
macca1969
says...
9:46pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Peter Beagrie Is Mint
says...
9:48pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Where is the much promised attacking, after the final speech. What utter tripe! 15 cup finals? You can say that again!
tingleyb
says...
9:49pm Tue 12 Mar 13
mikey1979
says...
9:49pm Tue 12 Mar 13
DingDangDoo!!!
says...
9:50pm Tue 12 Mar 13
spleen ventor
says...
9:52pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Another season in this god awful league beckons.
i miss stallard & murray
says...
9:53pm Tue 12 Mar 13
bahamianbantam
says...
9:53pm Tue 12 Mar 13
However whatever combination he plays (Connell excepted) nothing works - seems like we could be playing until Saturday before we score.
Thought attacking team but just no goals from anywhere.
Wait till Saturday - I would play 3-5-2 - McArdle, Davies, McHugh - Hines, Atkinson, Jones, Doyle, Reid - Connell, Thompson
doneBD4
says...
9:54pm Tue 12 Mar 13
League form is truly shocking and would have had other managers sacked by now. The cup run has kept him in the job.
The season started so well too.
Such a shame. And a waste!
bantam59
says...
9:59pm Tue 12 Mar 13
JUST DISGUSTING CRAP
PLAY OFFS !!!!!! NO CHANCE ON VIS EARTH
LaCe78
says...
10:00pm Tue 12 Mar 13
pudseykid
says...
10:01pm Tue 12 Mar 13
Plastic Bantam wrote:I recall b4 the CUP FINAL that the directors at CITY said they would be HAPPY with L2 next season...So, now that they have got their wish, is MR P the man to spend whatever money IS available and bring in the men who can do the job of getting this club promoted. It isnt on THIS Season..unless we start winning and others FALL miserably, this season is a failure...to those who went 2nite and spent good money, I am sorry, i only live 100 miles away. based on what has been written prior to my comment, it has been a wasted nite, Plymouth are bottom and we couldnt WIN...how much money does the manager need to spend in order to get a squad that can get out of this league...Personally, i would have preferred promotion to a wembley trip, i went and cheered and yelled, for nothing...and tonite its been the same
CRAP... PREDICTABLE...... LEAGUE 2 FOOTBALL NEXT YEAR
Hove edge bantam
says...
10:06pm Tue 12 Mar 13
As a fan for over 40years this happens season after season a good start to keep fans interested and purchase season tickets for next year Then rest of season fizzles out to a mediocre mid table finish IF we are lucky
spleen ventor
says...
10:09pm Tue 12 Mar 13
bantam59
says...
10:10pm Tue 12 Mar 13
ITS GONE TO THERE HEADS THAT THEY ARE WANTED BY OTHER CLUBS
YOU CAN BOTH DREAM ON & ON & ON & ON AND ON COS IT AINT GUNNA HAPPEN
LaCe78
says...
10:20pm Tue 12 Mar 13
bantam59
says...
10:23pm Tue 12 Mar 13
LaCe78 wrote:adkins in !!! WE CAN WISH
I'm thoroughly disgusted. Gray is done and ill complain about him for the rest of the season. Counter productive or not, he's beyond poor and Connell will walk at the end of the season when with game time he could have got us into the play offs! It's completely stupid pig headed behaviour from PP and I hope he doesn't sign an extension with management like this! Adkins in!!!
Cyprus Bantam
says...
10:30pm Tue 12 Mar 13
LaCe78
says...
10:30pm Tue 12 Mar 13
bantam59 wrote:Why is it we always seem to get the nearly men in charge who seem to miss the most obvious issues and display blatant pig headedness which is detrimental to the team! Christ I'd have Steve Evans or Ronnie Moore over Parky right now, at least they are ruthless and create ruthless teams instead of toothless mid table teams with loads of potential! Sick of hearing about this sleeping giant!!!!
LaCe78 wrote:adkins in !!! WE CAN WISH
I'm thoroughly disgusted. Gray is done and ill complain about him for the rest of the season. Counter productive or not, he's beyond poor and Connell will walk at the end of the season when with game time he could have got us into the play offs! It's completely stupid pig headed behaviour from PP and I hope he doesn't sign an extension with management like this! Adkins in!!!
Victor Clayton
says...
10:32pm Tue 12 Mar 13
bantam59 wrote:I know,and it was a FACT that he wasn't going to start for city ever and ever again! Or the next game, whichever comes first.
wat did divvy parky start with gray for!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!! what a load of rubbish
Crags
says...
10:39pm Tue 12 Mar 13
elroberto
says...
10:48pm Tue 12 Mar 13
then reality happens, D&R Aldershot and now P.Argyle. All these games should have been won easily. Instead we have to endure 80 mins of dross before he brings on Connell.If it wasnt for the cup run this guy would be out of a job!
fatbloke
says...
10:56pm Tue 12 Mar 13
tinytoonster
says...
11:03pm Tue 12 Mar 13
i said all this ages ago.
too negative and one dimensional.
Bradford Ranger
says...
11:31pm Tue 12 Mar 13
The cup run we had was out of this world, and the harsh reality is that it has come at the cost of a serious promotion push.
We had this at the end of last season where Syers couldn't get a start, and Parky was right... Now Syers is banished into non-league football and doing sh1te... Oh hang on...
Wells should have started tonight. He'd have a field day against Branston for pace, even if he is having a bad spell. Keep Parky in, more class signings over the summer and automatic if not champions next year. Premier League in 4 seasons time. Champions league winners in 6.
Bradford1903
says...
12:27am Wed 13 Mar 13
In our position we need to take more risks to win games, but Parky seems unable to veer from his naturally conservative default setting.
Really don't understand bringing on Atkinson, as it's a sub you would make when you are trying to see out a game. If Hines was tiring just switch Thompson to the right, or even try Wells there for the last 10 mins.
The only positive was that Exeter also drew, so we've got to go and win there or it's season definitely over.
Bullcity
says...
4:38am Wed 13 Mar 13
It is a must win now at Exeter and then onwards .I think we will do well next season & finish in the top 3 of Div 2 .Give PP a further chance he will strengthen the squad in the summer and then we will see a diffference
tyker2
says...
5:50am Wed 13 Mar 13
terrible result against the bottom team. GRAY IS SIMPLY NOT UP TO THE JOB AND AS NOT BEEN FOR A LONG TIME. A NEW MANAGER WILL SEE IT AND WE WILL HAVE ANOTHER COMPO BILL TO GET RID OF HIM.
he then brings on a holding midfield player as his first sub and brings on strikers with a few minutes to go. Honestly what can a player do in a couple of minutes or was it a time wasting exercise or did he really think he cold nick a 1-0? I have had reservations for a while now about Parky and feel he is a real Walter Mitty character defending away goalless draws when it is clear that we were awful against a bottom team.
Wy have those top scoreres on the bench and take them on such a journey as this. THE BOARD WILL BE LESS THAN IMPRESSED WITH RECENT RESULTS AND I WOULD SERIOUSLY ASK THEM TO RECONSIDER OPENING OR EXTENDING CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS
Birky_Neil
says...
6:44am Wed 13 Mar 13
bahamianbantam wrote:Maybe worth a try playing that formation. Although it might leave us bare at the back.
Whilst I could be negative. Our cup final is Saturday. Six pointer.
However whatever combination he plays (Connell excepted) nothing works - seems like we could be playing until Saturday before we score.
Thought attacking team but just no goals from anywhere.
Wait till Saturday - I would play 3-5-2 - McArdle, Davies, McHugh - Hines, Atkinson, Jones, Doyle, Reid - Connell, Thompson
Need the promise of midfield tracking back.
Teams must love playing us as we are no goal threat at all.
As for Gray I would not even have him on the bench but will parky do that?
No! As it will prove him wrong that he is a total waste of good money.
I would rather have an up and coming youth player that him.
Gray your career is over and thanks for picking us to rip off every week u get paid when at start of the season you messed us about for weeks and then did not sign.
ALEXIMO.56.
says...
8:25am Wed 13 Mar 13
Bradford Ranger wrote:I'll have a drink of whatever you have been on lol.
Can't be serious calling for Parky to go? Surely?
The cup run we had was out of this world, and the harsh reality is that it has come at the cost of a serious promotion push.
We had this at the end of last season where Syers couldn't get a start, and Parky was right... Now Syers is banished into non-league football and doing sh1te... Oh hang on...
Wells should have started tonight. He'd have a field day against Branston for pace, even if he is having a bad spell. Keep Parky in, more class signings over the summer and automatic if not champions next year. Premier League in 4 seasons time. Champions league winners in 6.
ALEXIMO.56.
says...
8:29am Wed 13 Mar 13
tingleyb wrote:If you are a loyal supporter and stick with the team through thick and thin, then YES buy a s/t. I bought mine on the 19th Nov.
they think its all over . . . . it is now ! . . . .. roll on 2013/14 . . . do i get a season ticket?
dannbradfc
says...
8:48am Wed 13 Mar 13
KnightMcCall wrote:don't you be criticising now......;-)
Nelson in the starting line-up and on the bench! Come on Simon. No Wells, Hanson or Connell? Bizarre! I hope that this works PP 'cos we need points right now. Really thought Connell would get a start tonight alongside Thompson or Hanson. There is rotation and their is madness!! Hines and Reid need stormers for this to work. Come on City!!
but your right. Nullify our wingers and you stop city.
dannbradfc
says...
8:54am Wed 13 Mar 13
Cyprus Bantam wrote:Normally Parky is a great speaker but for the first time it sounded like he was losing it. He as also in recent weeks looked for excuses where before he never mentioned injuries etc which would have been justified to some extent.
Just listened to the Parkinson interview on Pulse. It was great for the commentator to suggest it was a below par performance! Only for the manager to suggest the opposite saying his team played well! It suggests to me that Mr Parkinson cannot judge a good performance from a bad one. So I look forward to more srewball team selection.
Think that he still doesn't know how to get us scoring goals. He carries the illusion of an attcking side with wingers when in reality the wingers are very focused on their defensive duties at the expense of attacking.
he plays two defensive mids whatever the opposition and we have very little scoring options.
Our goals created in open play must be shockingly low......

shoatsy says...
7:01pm Tue 12 Mar 13