Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting TANEWS to 80360, or email
10:00am Wednesday 15th February 2012 in Bradford By Chris Holland
A veteran Bradford retailer has threatened to close one of his city centre shops a year after investing £30,000 in refurbishing the business, unless trade improves.
Jeff Frankel, former chairman of Bradford Retail Action Group, who has traded in the city for 36 years, said Fowler and Oldfield The Jewellers, in Kirkgate, could follow Goldsmiths, owners of the former Fattorini store, in closing down.
Mr Frankel, who also owns Sydneys The Jewellers in the Oastler Shopping Centre, said he would be forced to consider closing Fowler & Oldfield, which has been trading since 1897, if footfall in the city centre continued to decline.
He said: “We’re taking it a day at a time and hoping that things will improve for ourselves and other traders. It would be a great shame if we were to close a business that opened in Queen Victoria’s diamond jubilee year as we celebrate the Queen's 60 year reign.
“We put our faith in Bradford by refurbishing the Fowler & Oldfield store and restocking with quality goods. It would be tragic if the city centre could not sustain one of the last remaining quality jewellers in town.”
Mr Frankel criticised councillors for agreeing to impose more parking charges, saying the lack of free parking drove people away from Bradford.
He said: “Councillors claim that parking charges are not the issue in damaging city centre shopping, but you’ve only got to look at places where there is free parking, such as Forster Square, to see that it does draw people in.
“For instance, I don’t think the fact that after 2pm, you get two hours’ free parking in the Oastler Centre has been publicised enough.
“The closure of the former Fattorini’s shop, along with Goldsmiths’ other branch last year, are the latest nails in the coffin for Bradford city centre. Rather than taking decisions that will only keep more people away, the powers-that-be should focus on attracting people in and that needs more than a £20 million water pool.”
“The state of Bradford city centre at the moment reminds me of an old person who has a lot of history but not much future. If more people stay away, then more businesses will suffer and the city centre will become a ghost town with pound shops, betting shops and not much else to offer.”
Conways Toymaster is one of the latest businesses to shut up shop in the city centre.
It leaves a red, shuttered exterior with no signage, at its former premises near the Oastler Centre.
The indepenent toyshop has its head office in Keighley.
Comments(52)
Outraged Citizen
says...
11:32am Wed 15 Feb 12
Albion.
says...
11:32am Wed 15 Feb 12
thatsnotmyname
says...
11:50am Wed 15 Feb 12
BD16
says...
11:52am Wed 15 Feb 12
Joedavid
says...
11:55am Wed 15 Feb 12
Clowny
says...
12:01pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Macca51
says...
12:11pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Avro
says...
12:16pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Avro
says...
12:18pm Wed 15 Feb 12
thatsnotmyname wrote:You means like this
One of the main reasons these jewelery shops in the centre are going out of business is because 20% of Bradfords population buy from shops in their own community.
Avro
says...
12:52pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Joedavid
says...
12:54pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Clowny wrote:Plan B is to hide the Odeon.
It looks like we’re seeing shop closures if anything accelerate on previous years, the City Park so far has definitely not resulted in an increase in trade, unless there’s new events it has little hope of stopping the year on year decline in footfall. People will not pay to park just to see a water feature.
.
Having laughed and more often cried at one failure to the next whilst regeneration was under the control of Adrian Naylor I never imagined his failure would be surpassed.
.
It would be nice to hear a plan for turning around this problem from the council rather than hearing them make excuses. Worse still is when other cities try to be brought into the argument, I’ve noticed councillors in other cities have never chosen to cite Bradford’s failure as an excuse for theirs.
.
What’s plan B now the City Park is finished?
yorkshiredude
says...
1:09pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason
says...
1:15pm Wed 15 Feb 12
yorkshiredude wrote:Afternoon councillor green, bought any more parking meters recently?
Now then, suppose I'm looking for some jewellery. Its not something most people buy often, so I'll do a quick google search of Bradford jewellers'... does this shop show up on the first page? No.
He's right that the council don't promote free parking at the Oastler centre after 2 (I never knew that), but what promotion is he doing himself? (other than press articles, which if anything only show that the city centre is struggling and that no one should bother visiting.)
Forster Square has free parking, yay, but where is his jewellery competition there? Argos? Forster Square is a horrible soulless place to walk around.
basil fawlty
says...
1:30pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Joedavid
says...
1:31pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:Do not encourage the Council to touch the Retail Park, the stores must be doing well hard to find a parking space.
yorkshiredude wrote:Afternoon councillor green, bought any more parking meters recently?
Now then, suppose I'm looking for some jewellery. Its not something most people buy often, so I'll do a quick google search of Bradford jewellers'... does this shop show up on the first page? No.
He's right that the council don't promote free parking at the Oastler centre after 2 (I never knew that), but what promotion is he doing himself? (other than press articles, which if anything only show that the city centre is struggling and that no one should bother visiting.)
Forster Square has free parking, yay, but where is his jewellery competition there? Argos? Forster Square is a horrible soulless place to walk around.
yorkshiredude
says...
1:37pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:Yes and I bought them before the decision had been made by the council's executive for my own nefarious reasons. I also bought them from an out of town retailer, because the city centre is lacking in a good parking meter retailer (ironically I parked for free!).
yorkshiredude wrote: Now then, suppose I'm looking for some jewellery. Its not something most people buy often, so I'll do a quick google search of Bradford jewellers'... does this shop show up on the first page? No. He's right that the council don't promote free parking at the Oastler centre after 2 (I never knew that), but what promotion is he doing himself? (other than press articles, which if anything only show that the city centre is struggling and that no one should bother visiting.) Forster Square has free parking, yay, but where is his jewellery competition there? Argos? Forster Square is a horrible soulless place to walk around.Afternoon councillor green, bought any more parking meters recently?
yorkshiredude
says...
1:38pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:Yes and I bought them before the decision had been made by the council's executive for my own nefarious reasons. I also bought them from an out of town retailer, because the city centre is lacking in a good parking meter retailer (ironically I parked for free!).
yorkshiredude wrote: Now then, suppose I'm looking for some jewellery. Its not something most people buy often, so I'll do a quick google search of Bradford jewellers'... does this shop show up on the first page? No. He's right that the council don't promote free parking at the Oastler centre after 2 (I never knew that), but what promotion is he doing himself? (other than press articles, which if anything only show that the city centre is struggling and that no one should bother visiting.) Forster Square has free parking, yay, but where is his jewellery competition there? Argos? Forster Square is a horrible soulless place to walk around.Afternoon councillor green, bought any more parking meters recently?
Lizzydripping
says...
1:39pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Clowny
says...
2:19pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Ludylu
says...
2:26pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason
says...
4:04pm Wed 15 Feb 12
basil fawlty wrote:The park was approved in October 2007 but was delayed due to the lottery turning it down for grant money.
Im sure the park was conceived at a time before Westfield was put on ice, so suggesting that the Council's priority was to put the park before shopping is clearly wrong. interestingly there was a piece on Radio Leeds about the shocking state of shopping in Halifax. People there were clamouring for even a Primark. So we are not alone. The Westfield delay and Leeds' success are the cause of Bradford's downfall. Nothing will improve dramatically until Westfield restart.
dazbot
says...
6:49pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:The Park will. Westfield will never be built. The situation in Wakefield was very different to the one we have here. For one it was half way through development, and two... it was in Wakefield.
basil fawlty wrote:The park was approved in October 2007 but was delayed due to the lottery turning it down for grant money.
Im sure the park was conceived at a time before Westfield was put on ice, so suggesting that the Council's priority was to put the park before shopping is clearly wrong. interestingly there was a piece on Radio Leeds about the shocking state of shopping in Halifax. People there were clamouring for even a Primark. So we are not alone. The Westfield delay and Leeds' success are the cause of Bradford's downfall. Nothing will improve dramatically until Westfield restart.
.
It was actually started in 2009 when the council forked out for it.
.
The site at Westfield was demolished in 2006. Not a brick had been laid in 3 years when the park was started so I would say you can suggest the Park was put before shopping because the Westfield center was clearly mothballed at this stage.
.
Wakefield had the same problems and instead of building a park they help the developers to ensure the shopping center was finished. They now have a new shopping center, but no park.
We have no shopping center but a park. I wonder which will end up being more successful in the coming years.
Patrick Bateman
says...
9:14pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Patrick Bateman
says...
9:27pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Reality001
says...
10:02pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Patrick Bateman wrote:Could someone tell me why the retailers couldn't band together in Bradford and actually set up a website to promote themselves.
It's also worth noting that Mr Frankel was until quite recently head of the local small business consortium and has been very active in trying to promote and improve the retail offer of the city (most recently by highlighting the problem of drunks and beggars hanging around and putting off 'normal' customers). If such a long-standing stalwart of the Bradford retail scene is talking of 'shutting up shop' then the writing really is on the wall... Are you listening Bradford Council? Er, hello.....?
Reality001
says...
10:10pm Wed 15 Feb 12
dazbot wrote:The day Westfield sell the land which they own, is the day you can say it will never be built.
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:The Park will. Westfield will never be built. The situation in Wakefield was very different to the one we have here. For one it was half way through development, and two... it was in Wakefield.basil fawlty wrote: Im sure the park was conceived at a time before Westfield was put on ice, so suggesting that the Council's priority was to put the park before shopping is clearly wrong. interestingly there was a piece on Radio Leeds about the shocking state of shopping in Halifax. People there were clamouring for even a Primark. So we are not alone. The Westfield delay and Leeds' success are the cause of Bradford's downfall. Nothing will improve dramatically until Westfield restart.The park was approved in October 2007 but was delayed due to the lottery turning it down for grant money. . It was actually started in 2009 when the council forked out for it. . The site at Westfield was demolished in 2006. Not a brick had been laid in 3 years when the park was started so I would say you can suggest the Park was put before shopping because the Westfield center was clearly mothballed at this stage. . Wakefield had the same problems and instead of building a park they help the developers to ensure the shopping center was finished. They now have a new shopping center, but no park. We have no shopping center but a park. I wonder which will end up being more successful in the coming years.
Patrick Bateman
says...
10:12pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Avro
says...
10:16pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason
says...
10:55pm Wed 15 Feb 12
Clowny
says...
12:22am Thu 16 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:Almost certainly is. Doing the line of blaming the recession and the retailers themselves. Ignoring the fact Bradford is suffering worse than other cities in Yorkshire and has an established pattern of failure and falling profitability.
Reality001 = Reno
stiflers mom
says...
8:22am Thu 16 Feb 12
ertnec
says...
1:56pm Thu 16 Feb 12
RedCyanNat
says...
2:21pm Thu 16 Feb 12
basil fawlty
says...
2:29pm Thu 16 Feb 12
RedCyanNat wrote:Halifax probably does have a decent number of smaller shops but a lot of people there want the larger stores and have to shop in places like Bradford and Huddersfield to find them.
Some great comments here! I see Halifax mentioned,there are plenty more shops I'd say there, than there are in Bradford. No,not all of them are the larger chains, but I love independent shops, Norwich market comes to mind for example, as this gents jewelers; but at least Halifax looks nice! The pool does look good and fair play for them finishing it to actually look nice and not leaving a half built hole like most places, but it's totally pointless and should have been a finishing touch, which tells us all there is nothing to finish, no more shops, no more plans, no more future, simple and sad. Perhaps the retailers could sue the council, cos they're not spending the money on creating businesses and jobs and supporting the retail in Bradford with their cash, so perhaps shops could at lest get some compensation to set back up elsewhere, or keep on going at least for longer, using a case of neglect?!
basil fawlty
says...
2:40pm Thu 16 Feb 12
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:The fact that Wakefield has got its new shopping center whilst Bradford is still waiting is probably only down to the fact that it was a far more advanced scheme and did not require as much money to complete.
basil fawlty wrote: Im sure the park was conceived at a time before Westfield was put on ice, so suggesting that the Council's priority was to put the park before shopping is clearly wrong. interestingly there was a piece on Radio Leeds about the shocking state of shopping in Halifax. People there were clamouring for even a Primark. So we are not alone. The Westfield delay and Leeds' success are the cause of Bradford's downfall. Nothing will improve dramatically until Westfield restart.The park was approved in October 2007 but was delayed due to the lottery turning it down for grant money. . It was actually started in 2009 when the council forked out for it. . The site at Westfield was demolished in 2006. Not a brick had been laid in 3 years when the park was started so I would say you can suggest the Park was put before shopping because the Westfield center was clearly mothballed at this stage. . Wakefield had the same problems and instead of building a park they help the developers to ensure the shopping center was finished. They now have a new shopping center, but no park. We have no shopping center but a park. I wonder which will end up being more successful in the coming years.
Patrick Bateman
says...
6:02pm Thu 16 Feb 12
Outraged Citizen
says...
12:03am Fri 17 Feb 12
Patrick Bateman wrote:Cut-backs at the T & A.
basil fawlty said:
'Lets hope we dont get anything similar eventually with the Broadway development'.
I suspect your hopes will come true: indeed we won't be getting 'anything' similar at least not for a loooooooong time. In fact, in the interests of accuracy, make that 'nothing'.
Off topic but is it my imagination or are there far fewer stories these days that are allowed comment on?
Outraged Citizen
says...
12:06am Fri 17 Feb 12
Joedavid wrote:No, they're just not situated in the city centre so pay cheaper rents.
Asian run shops seem to abound selling gold jewellery to Asian people probably they buy and sell to their own culture thus adding to the lack of unity in Bradford.
Outraged Citizen
says...
12:12am Fri 17 Feb 12
ertnec wrote:LOLOLOLOL how stupid are you?
I like many others feel sick of the way the city centre is and looks, closed, drunks and beggers why would people want to go into BRADFORD neither mind the expence of getting there. Is it not time we stoped blameing Bradford Council and the government and started looking at our own beleaves. Why r more and more people on the DOLE get them of their backsides and set up a business in the community getting them to work for there benefit or stop it once and for all.
Bradfordneverbouncedback
says...
8:37am Fri 17 Feb 12
Outraged Citizen wrote:I can give an example of the high rates and rents in bradford as I was going to open and rent a shop at the top near darley street
ertnec wrote:LOLOLOLOL how stupid are you?
I like many others feel sick of the way the city centre is and looks, closed, drunks and beggers why would people want to go into BRADFORD neither mind the expence of getting there. Is it not time we stoped blameing Bradford Council and the government and started looking at our own beleaves. Why r more and more people on the DOLE get them of their backsides and set up a business in the community getting them to work for there benefit or stop it once and for all.
How are 20,000 unemployed people in Bradford going to start new businesses? Who is going to fund it? Who will provide training and capital? What businesses might succeed?
More and more people are on the Dole because we are in a recession, Capitalism has failed, the Industrial Revolution is over, there is no industry and there are no jobs, plus the Tories, in their ideological drive to dismantle the State, have put thousands of Public Sector workers on the Dole too. What part of that do you not understand?
Reality001
says...
1:30am Sat 18 Feb 12
Patrick Bateman wrote:No I don't work for the Council. I'm someone who has been in business for over 25 years and actually understands how business works.
Time to come clean Reality001: you work for the council, right?
Reality001
says...
1:43am Sat 18 Feb 12
Clowny wrote:I am not Reno and i'm happy for the T&A to confirm that on here if they wish.
Thee Voice of Reason wrote:Almost certainly is. Doing the line of blaming the recession and the retailers themselves. Ignoring the fact Bradford is suffering worse than other cities in Yorkshire and has an established pattern of failure and falling profitability.
Reality001 = Reno
Reality001
says...
1:51am Sat 18 Feb 12
Avro wrote:Check out the facts - Major chains are closing up to 14 of their stores every month around the UK - So no major shopping centres are going to be built when even Boots, Marks & Spencer are closing stores.
What Reality001 is saying is that Westfield won't be built any time soon!
Outraged Citizen
says...
5:03pm Sat 18 Feb 12
Reality001 wrote:Yes and they (ASDA, TESCO and many more) are also profiting from exploiting the never-ending source of free labour:
Avro wrote:Check out the facts - Major chains are closing up to 14 of their stores every month around the UK - So no major shopping centres are going to be built when even Boots, Marks & Spencer are closing stores.
What Reality001 is saying is that Westfield won't be built any time soon!
To keep major supermarkets in profit, there not building large stores, they are now investing in smaller convenience stores even ASDA set up Asda Supermarkets by taking over Nettos.
MisterBD
says...
7:52pm Sat 18 Feb 12
thatsnotmyname wrote:only 20% and only jewelrey?
One of the main reasons these jewelery shops in the centre are going out of business is because 20% of Bradfords population buy from shops in their own community.
MisterBD
says...
7:53pm Sat 18 Feb 12
Albion. wrote:nail on head
Not enough class customers to support class shops.
Reality001
says...
12:05am Sun 19 Feb 12
Outraged Citizen wrote:No the Government is exploiting people on benefit.
Reality001 wrote:Yes and they (ASDA, TESCO and many more) are also profiting from exploiting the never-ending source of free labour: http://www.abovetops ecret.com/forum/thre ad809995/pg1 http://watchinga4e.b logspot.com/2012/02/ free-labour-for-tesc o.html http://www.guardian. co.uk/commentisfree/ 2012/feb/16/work-fre e-tesco-job-advert?c ommentpage=1#start-o f-comments http://www.guardian. co.uk/commentisfree/ 2011/aug/23/voluntee red-work-cameron-bla irAvro wrote: What Reality001 is saying is that Westfield won't be built any time soon!Check out the facts - Major chains are closing up to 14 of their stores every month around the UK - So no major shopping centres are going to be built when even Boots, Marks & Spencer are closing stores. To keep major supermarkets in profit, there not building large stores, they are now investing in smaller convenience stores even ASDA set up Asda Supermarkets by taking over Nettos.
Outraged Citizen
says...
7:54pm Sun 19 Feb 12
Reality001 wrote:There is also the "Mandatory Work Activity" for unemployed adults on the so-called 'Work Programme', and that certainly IS compulsory!
Outraged Citizen wrote:No the Government is exploiting people on benefit.
Reality001 wrote:Yes and they (ASDA, TESCO and many more) are also profiting from exploiting the never-ending source of free labour: http://www.abovetops ecret.com/forum/thre ad809995/pg1 http://watchinga4e.b logspot.com/2012/02/ free-labour-for-tesc o.html http://www.guardian. co.uk/commentisfree/ 2012/feb/16/work-fre e-tesco-job-advert?c ommentpage=1#start-o f-comments http://www.guardian. co.uk/commentisfree/ 2011/aug/23/voluntee red-work-cameron-bla irAvro wrote: What Reality001 is saying is that Westfield won't be built any time soon!Check out the facts - Major chains are closing up to 14 of their stores every month around the UK - So no major shopping centres are going to be built when even Boots, Marks & Spencer are closing stores. To keep major supermarkets in profit, there not building large stores, they are now investing in smaller convenience stores even ASDA set up Asda Supermarkets by taking over Nettos.
Your talking about the Youth Job Experience scheme where they can go on an eight week course at a business that have signed up to the scheme.
It's not compulsory, but if they go on the scheme their benefit can be stopped if they don't complete it.
Matalan and Sainsbury's have pulled out of the scheme, and after the Job Centre Plus made an error on a Tesco ad, Tesco's look set to pull out as well.
Ladyshrew
says...
8:59pm Sun 19 Feb 12
MisterBD wrote:Totally agree.
Albion. wrote:nail on head
Not enough class customers to support class shops.
Outraged Citizen
says...
10:57pm Sun 19 Feb 12
Ladyshrew wrote:I don't see why we need any more shops, there are plenty as it is. I can buy whatever I want/need in Bradford, and anything more out of the ordinary can be obtained via the internet, so why do we need more shops? If anything, we need fewer shops!
MisterBD wrote:Totally agree.
Albion. wrote:nail on head
Not enough class customers to support class shops.
H8E US
says...
4:32pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Find your next job now in Bradford and beyond
Search Now »
Make a date in Bradford and surrounding areas now
Search Now »
Homes for sale and to let in Bradford and surrounding areas.
Search Now »
Cars for sale throughout Bradford and surrounding areas
Search Now »
Rambo says...
11:30am Wed 15 Feb 12
The city is really in dire straits when so many long-time independent and historic traders are calling time.
Don't worry though, the city park will save everything.