Yorkshire Water denies it’s dodging tax payments

Yorkshire Water's HQ Yorkshire Water's HQ

Yorkshire Water bosses have been accused of using a tax dodge to boost profits as consumers’ bills continue to soar.

But the Bradford-based utility company has refuted the accusation, saying it pays all the tax it is liable for and is open and honest about its accounts.

Yorkshire Water had been accused after an investigation by Corporate Watch, a not-for-profit investigative co-operative, into the finances of 19 water and sewerage companies in England and Wales It accused them of using a regulatory loophole to offset the cost of high interest loans from their owners through the Channel Islands stock exchange against tax on their profits.

Corporate Watch said: “The Yorkshire Water group, which is owned by investment funds based in the US, UK and Singapore, and HSBC bank, accrued £66 million in interest payments on £844 million of quoted Eurobonds in 2012.

“This, together with the interest payments on its other debt, helped it pay just £100,000 in corporation tax on an operating profit of £335 million in 2012.”

Corporate Watch said it asked the company for a comment but did not receive a reply.

Looking at the national picture, it claimed nearly a third of the money spent on water bills goes to banks and investors as interest and dividends, meaning consumers were paying £2 billion more a year – about £80 per household – than if the water and sewerage supply was publicly owned.

The body claimed seven water companies were avoiding millions in tax by routing profits through tax havens, while the chief executives of the 19 water companies were paid almost £10m in salaries and other bonuses in 2012.

Corporate Watch said banks and investors were making millions of pounds out of water companies as bills soared to an average of £388 a year. It claimed the latest average rise of 3.5 per cent in water bills would push more people into debt.

Corporate Watch said water companies and related businesses had amassed £49 billion in total borrowings. They paid more than £3 billion in interest payments last year in addition to £884 million in dividends to their owners.

Yorkshire Water said: “As a wholly UK tax resident company, we pay our tax in full and in total compliance with the rules of Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC).

“We make a massive contribution to the regional economy, investing more than £1 million every day to improve drinking water quality, bathing water quality and to help ensure communities are better protected from flooding.

“We also directly employ more than 2,500 people in Yorkshire and, through our investment, we have created hundreds more jobs working with over 1,000 local suppliers.

“We have always been nothing less than completely open and honest around our accounts, which are independently audited by HMRC, and publically available via our website.

“We play by the rules. If people however believe that these rules need to be changed, then that is an issue for Government and we’re very happy to play a part in any future debate.”

Comments(5)

Commonsensefirst says...
10:54am Sat 16 Feb 13

Unfortunately, many companies are run similarly to Yorkshire Water. They are not breaking the law by using tax havens. However, I have concerns about a comment suggesting that Yorkshire Water spend '£1 million every day to improve drinking water quality.' I doubt it. The article goes on to suggest that they are working in communities to protect against flooding - technically correct. They are currently in the process of passing responsibility for flood defenses to a contractor. The contractors are investigating our drainage systems prior to completion. In the future Yorkshire Water are more likely to shirk that responsibility. What a nonsense.

Albion. says...
11:42am Sat 16 Feb 13

If they are faced with more costs because of this investigation, you can rest assured that the customer will have to pay.

Outraged English Subject says...
1:38pm Sat 16 Feb 13

“We play by the rules. If people however believe that these rules need to be changed, then that is an issue for Government and we’re very happy to play a part in any future debate.”
Never in my life have I played a part in any debate with the Government over the amount of tax I pay or when I pay it. These major corporations still do not get it!

MontyLeMar says...
5:27pm Sat 16 Feb 13

They are a bunch of scammers, the lot of them. What is the government doing letting them take out expensive loans from their parent companies and then letting them claim tax relief on the interest? They should only be able to claim interest tax relief at the average minimum lending rate for that financial year. It's wide open to fraud. It's about time they were investigated for rigging prices as well.

Haji says...
6:44pm Sun 17 Feb 13

This is a disgrace and YW should not get away with it. I am going to cancel my direct debit with Y W and give them the ruaround before I pay up anything from now on. Even then I am going to pay by credit card so they dont benefit from the full payment.

It is draconian that they have raised their prices to feather their nests when most people are really struggling to feed their families. Come on people of Yorkshire, lets all fight back and show these greedy tax dodging b****r*s that they can not get way with it.

If YW only paid £100,000 in corporation tax in 2012 then that means they paid approx the same tax as 8 people who earn £34k a year. This can not be justified by any accountant or lawyer on earnings of £335 million.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree