Bierley family’s anger as marine who lost part of his brain in Taliban shooting offered £1,500 payout and told: It’s just a flesh wound

Samantha Brentley with the letter sent by the insurance company to the family Samantha Brentley with the letter sent by the insurance company to the family

The family of a Bradford commando offered a £1,500 insurance payout after he was shot through the head by the Taliban have branded the decision “disgraceful”.

Royal Marine Liam Brentley had to have part of his skull, brain and jaw removed and has been left with deafness and memory loss after he was shot while on patrol in Afghanistan.

Now his dad Gary, 50, has hit out at the father-of-two’s insurer for offering the “disgusting” payment for his injuries which the company has described as a “flesh wound”.

Mr Brentley, of Parkmere Close, Bierley, said: “It is a disgrace. He is so upset and his wife, Samantha, is distraught.

“We received a letter offering him £1,500 for what they call a ‘flesh wound’. We are absolutely disgusted with it.”

Mr Brentley and his wife Yvonne were outraged after receiving the letter from insurance company Chartis.

Their son, a former rugby league professional, is having treatment for his injuries at the Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre at Headley Court, Surrey.

Mr Brentley said: “We were hoping to get him a good payment so that he could crack on with his rehabilitation but this has just hit him for six.”

Related links

Marine Brentley amazingly survived after being shot through the head while on patrol in Afghanistan’s dangerous Helmand province, the Telegraph & Argus exclusively revealed in July. The former Bradford Dudley Hill rugby league player was initially treated in Afghanistan but his injuries were so severe he was flown back to Britain to undergo a life-saving brain operation.

His wife, Samantha, gave birth to their second child, Isabella, at the Queen Elizabeth hospital in Selly Oak, Birmingham, where her husband was recovering from the surgery.

Samantha said: “It’s upset me and Liam. They are saying it’s a flesh wound which it’s not. He has been shot in the brain. He has had brain tissue removed and part of his skull removed. He is totally deaf on his left side with permanent memory loss.

“Liam’s not going to be able to work because he’s got short-term memory loss. He’s going to be disabled for the rest of his life. He has two children and two step-children.”

A spokesman for insurance firm Chartis said £1,500 was an initial offer from the company and apologised if the cover-all term “flesh wound” – which it used for bullet wounds – had caused offence to the family.

Marine Brentley, 25, may be entitled to payments in the future following the advice of medical professionals looking after him. But his dad said: “He has a wife and two children and doesn’t know whether he will have a job. They need it now.”

The Chartis spokesman said: “If there has been a failure in communication with the family, then we apologise.

“This is a complex situation where payments are made within the terms and conditions of the contract and some have already been paid. Whether or not more payments are due is dependent on the long-term outcome of the injury. We are dependent on medical professionals treating an individual to provide that information.”

Comments(13)

Billcliff says...
8:48am Wed 3 Nov 10

Try signing on the dole and tripping over a paving stone next time. Don't sign up to protect your country. Absolute disgrace!

Mekon says...
9:09am Wed 3 Nov 10

Well the figure depends on how much insurance they have been paying and what the agreement was surly?

Is this not separate to the amount of compensation he will / has been awarded by the Government??

Joedavid says...
9:20am Wed 3 Nov 10

First thing is I was surprised to read a member of the Forces in a war zone would be able to get Insurence cover.
Many people can't get Insurence cover just to go away for a week or two on holiday to a peaceful country.
Having said that what sort of cover does his policy offer?

captainKanotaray says...
9:37am Wed 3 Nov 10

Perhaps those who forced this country to go to war with a nation that not so much as gave us a sideways look should give him some of their immense profits for providing guns and ammo (at the taxpayers expense of course).

Billcliff says...
9:58am Wed 3 Nov 10

captainKanotaray wrote:
Perhaps those who forced this country to go to war with a nation that not so much as gave us a sideways look should give him some of their immense profits for providing guns and ammo (at the taxpayers expense of course).
Well said.

mad matt says...
10:02am Wed 3 Nov 10

Typical of a lot of insurance companies these days - they are happy to take your money, but they don't like to pay any out.

Michael Manus says...
10:07am Wed 3 Nov 10

Joedavid wrote:
First thing is I was surprised to read a member of the Forces in a war zone would be able to get Insurence cover. Many people can't get Insurence cover just to go away for a week or two on holiday to a peaceful country. Having said that what sort of cover does his policy offer?
Chartis Insurance specialise in high risk insurance for high risk professionals, this gentleman has to be commended for sorting out additional insurance for his family and not relying on the Government to pay out if anything happened to him. £1,500 is an absolute disgrace especially when the minimum payout for whiplash in an accident is £1,800.

Mekon says...
10:22am Wed 3 Nov 10

Michael Manus wrote:
Joedavid wrote:
First thing is I was surprised to read a member of the Forces in a war zone would be able to get Insurence cover. Many people can't get Insurence cover just to go away for a week or two on holiday to a peaceful country. Having said that what sort of cover does his policy offer?
Chartis Insurance specialise in high risk insurance for high risk professionals, this gentleman has to be commended for sorting out additional insurance for his family and not relying on the Government to pay out if anything happened to him. £1,500 is an absolute disgrace especially when the minimum payout for whiplash in an accident is £1,800.
Well it depends on how much they have been paying doesn't it. If they have been paying £5 pm then the sum isn't going to be big.

Also the insurance company says:

a: Its not a final offer
b: Sums have already been paid.

DCarbz says...
10:56am Wed 3 Nov 10

If I had to guess then I would say that the policy is one for personal injury and has a substantial 'Disablement' benefit.
However the injured person must satisfy the policy definition of 'Disablement' in order for the benefit to be paid out.

jackw says...
1:21pm Wed 3 Nov 10

Go to companies House website pay £1 to find the addresses of the directors & send them pictures & ask them if its a flesh wound.

Collos says...
4:31pm Wed 3 Nov 10

The Blair government took us into an illegal war and then when the soldiers need help the insurance companies and government try everything in their power to weadle out of paying.Blair is making millions now with not a thought for the mess he has made while a brave soldier has to fight for a pittance so his family can put food on the table.

anglosaxon says...
7:09pm Wed 3 Nov 10

Tony Bliars millions to this soldiers £i,500 doesn't bear thinking about. one a Liar one a Hero....and they say crime doesn't pay...

Haji says...
9:51pm Wed 3 Nov 10

Tragedy is the only word I can think of when thinking about any of the outcomes from this war.

Please dont forget the other side of the coin though as you may have noticed through the Wikileaks recently that the coalition forces opened fire on a car with family Mum, Dad & four children) at a checkpoint in an Iraqi City. They did it this for absolutely no reason and then tried to cover it.

Mum & Dad were killed and one 11 year old boy was seriously injured. This was covered up and to suffocate the news the payout offered was £4500. The letter stated this was for the lives taken and the damage to the car.

If you take into account this and other similar stories then it explains why many more soldiers will continue to die in this war which never should have happened. Sadly, I am sure we can expect many more wars in future years as politicians dont understand killing people is wrong

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree