Local RSS Feed


Governors kicked out as school in Bradford Moor fails again


The governing body of a crisis-hit Bradford primary school has been removed.

An interim executive board (IEB) is being appointed to temporarily take over the running of Feversham Primary, in Bradford Moor.

Urgent action is being taken by Bradford Council, which has powers under the Education Act 2002 to intervene in schools causing concern.

Education Bradford, the private firm responsible for improving school standards in the district, would not comment on suggestions that the school has been put into the failing Special Measures category by school watchdog Ofsted.

A team of inspectors is reported to have visited the school recently although their findings have not yet been made public.

The developments are a worrying turnaround for a school that was judged to be satisfactory and improving when Ofsted last published an inspection report in January 2007.

The report stated that the governors knew the school well and had made sensible decisions that had contributed to the school’s improvement over a two-year period.

Almost all the school’s pupils come from ethnic-minority groups and most speak little English when they start in the Foundation Stage.

The leadership of the school has been called into question since that report.

Rashidah Butt, headteacher since September 2004, returned to the school in January after an unexplained “extended leave of absence”.

Last summer it emerged that Miss Butt, who had been previously accused of bullying staff, was pursuing claims of sex and race discrimination against the Council and the school’s board of governors.

A four-week employment tribunal had been scheduled to start on February 8 but it was postponed. A case management hearing took place in Leeds on Tuesday.

Education Bradford told the Telegraph & Argus it had the backing of the Department for Children, Schools and Families to put the Interim Executive Board in place and said it hoped the move would help the school make rapid improvements.

Education Bradford said the IEB replaces the governing body at the school for the foreseeable future and is being chaired by Margaret Platts, former headteacher at Belle Vue Girls’ School.

Mrs Platts said: “I am delighted to have the opportunity to be the chairman and work with the headteacher, staff, children and parents. My colleagues on the IEB are very committed professionals with a wide experience of working with schools and young people.”

Lesley Hart, Education Bradford’s Director of School Improvement, said: “The IEB will help the school focus on rapid improvements and better outcomes for the children and provide strategic support and challenge to the school to bring this about.

“This will build on the additional support the school is receiving from education professionals, brokered by Education Bradford.

“I am delighted Margaret Platts, whose work was recognised by her receipt of the MBE in 2000, has agreed to chair the IEB.

“Margaret is a well-known and well-respected Bradford educationalist with more than 30 years’ experience in the district’s schools.”

Sue Colman, Bradford Council’s Assistant Director for Learning Services, said: “The local authority is supportive of these measures and we are confident they will assist the school in improving.”

Over the last year the school’s board of governors has been led by three different chairmen.

Newly-ousted chairman Mohammed Saraj said the governing body had failed in an appeal against the implementation of an IEB.

He claims governors were not formally consulted about the move and that the school’s progress was hampered by Education Bradford.

“It’s not sour grapes from my point of view,” he said. “I have no agenda against Education Bradford but we were getting conflicting advice and little support for human resources and financial matters.”

He also questioned the progress of other schools under the direction of IEBs.

Ward councillor Ghazanfer Khaliq (Lab, Bradford Moor) called on the problems to be resolved as soon as possible.

He said: “I have been very concerned about the school for a number of years because it has been having a lot of difficulties.

“My main concern is for the children and the parents. When a school is unstable it has an impact on the education of the children.”

Coun Mohammed Shafiq (Lab, Bradford Moor) said: “I hope the local authority will take the action that is needed to ensure children’s education is not affected in any way.”

Comments(28)

Marco Polio says...
7:07am Mon 22 Mar 10

Three words, 'Ray was Right.'

PHILISAN says...
7:24am Mon 22 Mar 10

Not helpful when the children attending do not have ENGLISH as their first language..one wonders as to what culture preferences apply also.We have made a rod for our own back and it is costing society dearly in the majority of these culturally related issues.

reportmeagain says...
9:14am Mon 22 Mar 10

PHILISAN wrote:
Not helpful when the children attending do not have ENGLISH as their first language..one wonders as to what culture preferences apply also.We have made a rod for our own back and it is costing society dearly in the majority of these culturally related issues.
dead right.

Joedavid says...
10:07am Mon 22 Mar 10

"Almost all the school’s pupils come from ethnic-minority groups and most speak little English"
Start of the problems.

Sue-H says...
12:41pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Since Serco/Education Bradford (aprivate company), took over the education of our pupils, all we have seen in the last 10 years is failure after failure. Those in lofty positions, getting the 5 figure salaries are cleverly diverting the attention away from themselves by blaming the Governing bodies (100 % volunteers, giving up their time, effort and travelling expenses).
Just up the road from Feversham, is a similar story, where the failings of Education Bradford officials were translated into removing the governing body and in their wisdom that an IEB of fantastic professionals to be installed. Lo and behold ! a daming report saying '' it is worst than before''. If it was the previous governing body to blame, then it should have improved with this new IEB with an outstanding head....
Education Bradford officials at the higher ranks hiding behind smaller fish (its the 5 figure salaries that matter to some).

Dave_Smithwell says...
1:33pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Joedavid wrote:
"Almost all the school’s pupils come from ethnic-minority groups and most speak little English"
Start of the problems.
Possibly, but remember, these kids have to work twice as hard; one, to learn English, and the other, to learn their mother tongue.
.
Having said that, why do non-Asian kids fail miserably ? - they have no excuse.

Tollerboy says...
2:13pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Good point Dave!

happy hour says...
6:13pm Mon 22 Mar 10

I believe that teachers at this school have been under acheiving and are to blame for the mess...maybe they should be sacked.

happy hour says...
6:23pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Joe David, I'm originally from Bierely a white council estate, they fail too and your comment simply doesn't cut the mustard. It's nothing to do with Asian kids failing badly, I'm aware of alot of politics going on where lazy teachers are taking their pay packet for granted and not pushing the children or improving their educational potential. If white kids weren't failing, who indeed should be making the majority of the Work force up, why are our hospitals full of non British Born staff? British jobs for British Born workers no matter what their creed or culture is!

monobrow man says...
6:48pm Mon 22 Mar 10

The feversham primary sign with the 4 different types of arabic writing should be enough for everyone to realise what is wrong with the school. English should be everyones first language by now, i do unerstand the first and maybe second generation who where basically brought over as slaves to work in the mills needing the writing but this generation of parents have no excuse.

ali1982 says...
7:33pm Mon 22 Mar 10

dats so racist its got nothing to do with the fact that the children have english as thier second language.i had no problems with my education, i work for the goverment now, i didnt have any issues.......if anyone's to blame then it's defo the teachers because at the end of the day it's the teachers who are meant to teach.......

yezboss says...
7:39pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Sorry I have to ask.

Q.1.Do I understand this correctly?
English is not taught a the first language in this school?
A. English is the FIRST language of communication and the ONLY language of this country.

Q.2. Do I understand it the school sign bears FOUR Arabic writings?
A. Do we wonder why this school fails?
What next?

The T&A in Arabic ?(or has that begun already and I have missed yet another failing)

What a sheer nonsensical situation.
I DON'T

Joedavid says...
7:47pm Mon 22 Mar 10

happy hour wrote:
Joe David, I'm originally from Bierely a white council estate, they fail too and your comment simply doesn't cut the mustard. It's nothing to do with Asian kids failing badly, I'm aware of alot of politics going on where lazy teachers are taking their pay packet for granted and not pushing the children or improving their educational potential. If white kids weren't failing, who indeed should be making the majority of the Work force up, why are our hospitals full of non British Born staff? British jobs for British Born workers no matter what their creed or culture is!
Please read my post, I said Start of the problem.
Your problem at Bierley with staff and methods will apply widely as well as the subject school.
I'm not sure about blaming the company running the education as Bradford Council failed before them.

lazybeat says...
7:56pm Mon 22 Mar 10

There’s no Arabic just Hindi, Urdu, English etc. I don't know if you've been to a gp or hospital, a large proportion of the staff is ASIAN, yes Asian. It’s a fact education is pushed among Asian families no matter how crappy the teacher the LEA provides. It must be embarrassing although the causation areas would have a better start than most Asians some still end up like a bunch of uneducated hillbillies who can't even read or write their own language. By the time we are 10 we can communicate in 2-3 different languages and succeed with a good level of education.

monobrow man says...
8:34pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Lazybeat you mention asian alot. China is the biggest country in asia but I did not see any cantonese or mandarin writing on the school sign. I am from good irish stock and my parents and grandparents have suffered racist abuse not because of the colour of there skin but from been so called thick paddies. My parents went on to be high up in the council and own a very reputable sheetmetal company does that mean all irish people who came over to england are all managing directors and government workers.

Freddy Elliot says...
9:01pm Mon 22 Mar 10

A friend of mine was a teaching assistant at a similar primary school. Story time in the afternoon was read a line at a time in English by the teacher first, followed by 3 more languages by 3 interpreters. The children would learn basic words through the week (spade, sand etc.) only to return the following week having forgotten all they were taught.

happy hour says...
9:19pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Freddy Elliot interesting post, therefore why has Bradford Council stopped races frommixing by stopping pupils from being bussed out? To create apartheid in both White and Asian areas? To promote racial harmoney? Or is it because they're politically inept.

Vaikona says...
10:17pm Mon 22 Mar 10

If we stopped translating for all non English speaking and reading people then they would HAVE to learn English, then when children arrive they will have English as their FIRST language. This would help.
If I went to any other non English speaking country I would not be given any aid from their government so that I didn't have to bother learning the local language.

Freddy Elliot says...
10:28pm Mon 22 Mar 10

Vaikona wrote:
If we stopped translating for all non English speaking and reading people then they would HAVE to learn English, then when children arrive they will have English as their FIRST language. This would help. If I went to any other non English speaking country I would not be given any aid from their government so that I didn't have to bother learning the local language.
Agreed Vaikona. Unfortunately children of even third generation settlers here have trouble grasping English. More needs to be done to break the cycle. How that can be achieved without offending people I do not know.

s.k says...
2:18am Tue 23 Mar 10

Pathetic!...they're children for goodness sake!!going to school and learning is the whole purpose of school!!..and about you not having any aid from any other non speaking country..get over it! at your age you should be able to learn and adapt,this is primary school children were talkin about...the issue isnt about any of you lot,its about the childrens education! grow up you ignorant sods!

theberry says...
7:13am Tue 23 Mar 10

The people to blame are the paper pushers at EB.They are the same people that were there when Bradford Council was supposedly "educating" our children and they are the same people under SERCO. These are the people we must go after and hold accountable. Its election time at present, lets see which councilors have got the guts to stand up for the children in their areas and take the council directors to task as well as those in EB playing games with the childrens education.

Bone_idle18 says...
9:16am Tue 23 Mar 10

Learning starts at home, parents have a responsibility to help educate their children, the fact that they don't even equip them with the basics (English) says a lot.

I read with my daughter every day, we count and we practice writing, making it fun for her so she is very well equipped to start school in September.

english

Sue-H says...
11:42am Tue 23 Mar 10

It's interesting how the local councillors have quickly jumped on the bandwaggon and used wishy washy neutral/political language, just to get their names printed in the papers.
Is that because its election time and they have to show they're interested in childrens' education?
A question that I would have liked to ask the school/ governing body, is how much support/involvement they recieved from the these (so vocal) local councillors before this ?

LeahB says...
12:42pm Tue 23 Mar 10

There is not a necessity to have children 'well equipped BEFORE school'- The purpose of a school is to equip the children academically. Before children go to school, it is the social skills that are important.

If a school has a high percentage of children with English as an additional language then it is up to the school to cater for the needs of those children.

Clearly, at Feversham, the needs of the children are not being met- Why is there the need to blame the children?

Those of you pointing fingers at teachers, please do not generalise and comment that all teachers are rubbish, like all businesses, some are great teachers, some are ok and some are underperforming.

It is interesting to note that the current head at Feversham was accused of bullying tactics and she in return accused Education Bradford of racial and sexual discrimination. The fact that her tribunal was called off suggests that Rashidah Butt and Education Bradford have come to an agreement to save both parties from embarrasment. Surely, if Rashidah Butt was ONLY a victim, she would definitely have gone forward with a case against Education Bradford. Similarily, if Education Bradford did NOT racially/sexually discriminate against Rashidah Butt, they would not have dropped the tribunal against her.

This failure in the education system, where hundreds of children are getting a second rate education, calls for the resignation of the top people in Education Bradford and also the resignation of the current Head.

Bone_idle18 says...
5:29pm Tue 23 Mar 10

Sue-H, Of course it's a parents duty to endure their child is ready for school, this includes social skills, as you say, but also a basic grasp of other skills. Using pencils, COMMUNICATING, using the bathroom, etc.

You mention social skills being important, but surely the inability to communicate in the language of your country is very anti-social?

Before anyone points out that there are English speaking schools in Spain (the usual argument) then they tend to be solely for Ex-Pats and are not part of the general Spanish education system (or so I believe).

PTN says...
2:06pm Sat 27 Mar 10

Joedavid wrote:
"Almost all the school’s pupils come from ethnic-minority groups and most speak little English"
Start of the problems.
Absolute Rubbish.
This has nothing to do with it. As a matter of fact children who learn their mother tongue before going to school are much better equipped in later life and end up being bilingual or even trlingual in some cases.
Children at age 4 and upwards have an amazing capacity for learning and if the teaching is done correctly and efficiently then there is no reason why they should not excel.
As a matter of fact i went to school at the age of 5 and spoke no English at all and by the time i was in middle school i was amongst the top set for English and most other subjects , way ahead of most of my English speaking colleagues who had been brought up with the language as their mother tongue.
Finally its not an option not to learn your mother tongue as many families have strong connections with the Asian sub continent and need these languages to communicate with grand parents , uncles , cousins etc.
Whilst on holiday visiting relatives abroad i have witnessed children from the UK who have not been taught their mother tongue struggling to communicate with grand parents etc thus causing great distress for both parties.
Finally on the subject matter , one word describes whats really going on here , "POLITICS".

PTN says...
2:10pm Sat 27 Mar 10

Any comments?

PTN says...
2:12pm Sat 27 Mar 10

anyone there?


Feversham Primary School, Bradford Moor Margaret Platts who is chairing the new board

Feversham Primary School, Bradford Moor

Margaret Platts who is chairing the new board



Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses