Campaigners against Menston homes record dramatic evidence of heavy rain

Flooding on the A65 Flooding on the A65

Campaigners say they have video evidence proving why drainage and flooding issues should stop nearly 300 homes being built in a village.

Before the 175 homes in Derry Hill and 135 homes in Bingley Road have even been built, objectors to the schemes have said the village’s sewer and drainage system is already struggling to cope.

Now campaigners, led by Menston Action Group (Mag), Menston Community Association and the parish council, have published videos and photographs showing the effects of rain on village infrastructure – months after planning applications for the schemes were backed by Bradford Council.

Some of their videos also highlight recent flooding in fields in Derry Hill and Bingley Road, where the homes could be constructed by Barratt Homes and Taylor Wimpey respectively.

Ahead of a meeting in Menston tonight to discuss the homes battle, Mag have released the videos and photographs to show how bad things are.

Solicitors for the campaigners have also written to the Council, which has given permission for the homes with several conditions, and Yorkshire Water to highlight the problems they say have been affecting the village for years.

A spokesman for Mag says the group is “95 per cent confident” it can stop the developments going ahead because of the flooding and drainage issues.

The Menston Forum meeting is at 7.30pm in the Kirklands Community Centre, in Main Street, and letters have gone around the village highlighting the objectors’ campaign.

“There has been serious flooding in the village and along the A65 during this summer, with flood water and sewage forced up manholes onto village streets,” it says.

“It has, admittedly, been a poor summer, but the long-term weather forecasts indicate that the UK must expect greater extremes of weather in years to come.

“We have commissioned, at significant expense, a professional report from the UK’s leading flood and drainage consultants which shows that if volume housing is built in Menston, our drainage system is simply inadequate and will be overwhelmed in areas from the moor top to the Wharfe.”

Meanwhile, campaigners are still waiting to hear the results of the village green application for Derry Hill more than seven weeks after a public inquiry ended. If the application is successful it could stop any potential construction on the site.

Comments(12)

localydocaly says...
12:11pm Tue 9 Oct 12

lucky for some we already know the outcome.call yr self a reporter !!!!!

johnhem says...
12:40pm Tue 9 Oct 12

if the developers want to build on a flood plane then let them. houses won't sell (well only to idiots) and insurers won't insure them, so it would make developers think twice when they are left with unsold houses which would shortly be under water anyway.

Prisoner Cell Block A says...
12:55pm Tue 9 Oct 12

I hope the residents are showing the footage and pictures to all the insurance companies which cover the existing properties in this area. If the data is going to be used as an argument against building properties it is only rightful that it is also used to raise premiums for the houses which are obviously at risk from being flooded.

One woman in Goole recently quoted 20k to insure her property as it was close to a flood plain, only close to one, not in the midst.

Well done honest residents, your insurance companies will love you for doing their jobs for them.

FiT1958 says...
3:33pm Tue 9 Oct 12

Prisoner Cell Block A wrote:
I hope the residents are showing the footage and pictures to all the insurance companies which cover the existing properties in this area. If the data is going to be used as an argument against building properties it is only rightful that it is also used to raise premiums for the houses which are obviously at risk from being flooded.

One woman in Goole recently quoted 20k to insure her property as it was close to a flood plain, only close to one, not in the midst.

Well done honest residents, your insurance companies will love you for doing their jobs for them.
The activists also said they had photographic evidence of the village green scam they applied for.

localydocaly says...
6:18pm Tue 9 Oct 12

so wen are you going report on the village green thats not a village green,all quite on that 1, it would appear.£50k of the villaigers money blown ,just think what that could have done for the folk wi kids looking for local child care !!!!! scout hut the list is endless,what a waste .@ least mag have somthing to be proud off !!

FiT1958 says...
6:58pm Tue 9 Oct 12

localydocaly wrote:
so wen are you going report on the village green thats not a village green,all quite on that 1, it would appear.£50k of the villaigers money blown ,just think what that could have done for the folk wi kids looking for local child care !!!!! scout hut the list is endless,what a waste .@ least mag have somthing to be proud off !!
Maybe The activists should have put the money into "our village" infrastructure or is that just pouring money down the drain!

Colin Allcars says...
7:08pm Tue 9 Oct 12

according to the Libdem newsletter, council idiots have given permission for another of those cloth shops to open at Bolton Junction lights. Haven't they seen the disgraceful and illegal parking scenes outside the one opposite Bradford Moor Park? Bolton junction will be even worse. What's up with this country, does everything have to get worse, do locals have any say over outsiders?
Will Bolton junction be better for a cloth shop?

FiT1958 says...
8:24pm Tue 9 Oct 12

Colin Allcars wrote:
according to the Libdem newsletter, council idiots have given permission for another of those cloth shops to open at Bolton Junction lights. Haven't they seen the disgraceful and illegal parking scenes outside the one opposite Bradford Moor Park? Bolton junction will be even worse. What's up with this country, does everything have to get worse, do locals have any say over outsiders?
Will Bolton junction be better for a cloth shop?
Wouldn't believe anything you read in a Lib Dem newsletter!!

johnhem says...
11:03pm Tue 9 Oct 12

it will be all tweed and leather elbow patches anyway ;-)

Frances Lincoln says...
10:25am Wed 10 Oct 12

Looking forward to sledging and kite flying on the 'Menston Village Green'!!!!!!

What the residents need to appreciate is:-

1) the land floods already and if left will continue to do so.

2) the developers are required to address any issues associated with flooding by incorporating suitable drainage systems and in some cases attenuation tanks - this will ultimately improve the situation.

Menston Residents need to stop ploughing money into the play thing of a few 'retired folk' who have nothng better to do.

localydocaly says...
7:30pm Wed 10 Oct 12

Frances Lincoln wrote:
Looking forward to sledging and kite flying on the 'Menston Village Green'!!!!!!

What the residents need to appreciate is:-

1) the land floods already and if left will continue to do so.

2) the developers are required to address any issues associated with flooding by incorporating suitable drainage systems and in some cases attenuation tanks - this will ultimately improve the situation.

Menston Residents need to stop ploughing money into the play thing of a few 'retired folk' who have nothng better to do.
here,here. jog on mag ,saw a couple of jcb,s in the village today,looking for derry hill !!!!!!

localydocaly says...
9:54pm Wed 10 Oct 12

http://www.menston-a
ction.org/

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree