Baildon Tory group secretary says co-opting new councillor would be cheaper alternative

A by-election in Baildon has been criticised as an “expensive and needless” waste of taxpayers’ money and an unwanted move into party politics.

Rob Higgie, secretary of Baildon Conservatives said the election for a parish councillor in the Baildon East ward could cost up to £10,000, money that could be “better spent elsewhere”.

He is calling for a new councillor to be co-opted on to the council to save money, which could be as much as a quarter of the parish council’s £40,000 annual budget.

Mr Higgie, of Cliffe Lane South, said: “Previously when a mid-term parish council vacancy has arisen it has been filled by a process of co-option, which is cost effective and has produced good councillors.

“This expensive and needless election they will leave the residents of Baildon both financially and politically poorer.”

The Baildon East seat is up for election following the resignation of Peter Haley earlier this month.

Now ten residents have petitioned Bradford Council calling for a by-election for his seat, which is likely to be held on October 4. It will be contested between Jen Kilyon, Ian Lyons and Terry Andrew.

However, Mr Higgie has criticised Mr Lyons, a Liberal Democrat, for the “unwelcome politicising” of the parish council, which is supposed to be politically neutral.

He claims Mr Lyons gathered a petition of Liberal Democrat supporters to call for an election – a claim Mr Lyons has denied.

Mr Lyons, who was the first candidate to declare his political allegiance, said: “Even though the parish council is not political, a lot of the members have membership of a political party. He’s quite right the cost could be up to £10,000 but the actual figure is more likely to be £6,000 or £7,000.

“Eleven electors have put in a petition saying they want an election – I certainly have not been walking around with a petition – so I have put my papers in.”

Mr Higgie said the candidates had until tomorrow to withdraw and urged them to do so, so that a member could be co-opted onto the parish council.

Comments(11)

Dragon Saddle says...
10:06am Tue 11 Sep 12

Let the people decide!

vax2002 says...
10:28am Tue 11 Sep 12

I have a better idea, abolish the Parish council and its expenses accounts to councillors.
Bradford has a city council, they can elect it's representative to sit on that.
It's just another level of gravy train handouts that can be done without.
How many councils do you need ?

thoughtout says...
10:48am Tue 11 Sep 12

vax2002 - I think you may find that the Parish Councillors dont get paid - or put in much if ANY expenses

Any yet give vast time and effort to support the local community


It is an important level of democracy

The Parish Council have no say over whether and election is called and therefore no say as to the cost of the event

Some people give alot of time and effort to ensure local community develops - so please do not judge

jackandruthwood@gmail.com says...
12:36pm Tue 11 Sep 12

The Parish council has been a waste of time and money,and undemcratic since
it's inception.

thoughtout says...
2:35pm Tue 11 Sep 12

And your comments are based on ??


Have you any idea about the work it does or the grants it gives out to elderly or vulnerable adults support groups ??

Have you ever been to a meeting >

I suspect the answer is no - to everyone of those

Paul Marfell says...
2:56pm Tue 11 Sep 12

The election is happening because the law says that if 10 electors request an election then it must happen. Baildon having an election is an example of democracy in action.

I personally would not request there to be an election because during a co-option the candidates present their case to the parish council and they then vote. Now, with an election, every elector in Baildon will be asked to vote. They will probably only know the candidates from their political allegiance which should not form part of parish council working. If the candidates were well known to all because of their good works then "yes" have an election - but in this case I am of the opinion that the electorate has forced the parish council into an unwarranted expense.

The parish council have known that these costs could be incurred and I know that in the past they made sure they had a reserve to cover the cost. Hopefully that is still the case.

The only expense that I was aware of being agreed was something like £50 per year to support the chair in exercising his extra duties. Only about £3.00 of that was ever used.

thoughtout says...
3:01pm Tue 11 Sep 12

Thank you for your comments Paul

It highlights the the misunderstanding and false impression people have

Anyone who feels they would like to see local democracy in action - should feel free to come and see a meeting in action

Pleasew dont use soundbites - come and find out for yourselves

Dragon Saddle says...
3:07pm Tue 11 Sep 12

Only people living in Baildon East will be voting. About 2500 electors.

Totally agree that the PC does good work. However, it could be better value for money. A lot is spent on running costs like the Clerk and Warden, in proportion to the precept.

If the precept were set at the national average, it would be far better value for money, and could achieve much more.

thoughtout says...
3:26pm Tue 11 Sep 12

Hi Dragon

Did you know our precept is one of the lowest set ?

Considerably so

The clerk does an excellent job collating all the data / grant applications etc

Did you know that thanks to the work undertaken by one of the Parish Councillors - we have organised a Baildon Farmers Market -?

The time and effort this took was way above the expectations of a Councillor - but she gave her time and the first one takes place on 22nd September.


Come along and see first hand what they help organise

mannyb says...
8:22pm Tue 11 Sep 12

It's a pity that the reporter hasn't got the finer details of his story correct!
One of the candidates is NOT Terry Andrew BUT Graham Terry!

Dragon Saddle says...
8:43pm Tue 11 Sep 12

mannyb wrote:
It's a pity that the reporter hasn't got the finer details of his story correct!
One of the candidates is NOT Terry Andrew BUT Graham Terry!
I'm pretty sure there isn't supposed to be a 'they' in this quote either:

“This expensive and needless election they will leave the residents of Baildon both financially and politically poorer.”

But then again, if you spent an afternoon listening to a Tory supporter whinging about a Parish Council by-election, that they're not even taking part in, you would probably lose your mind a little too! lol

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree