- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@Bradford_TandA
All the latest news and views from the T&A
@tandasport
All the latest sport from the T&A
@TandABusiness
Latest business headlines from the T&A
- Find us on Facebook
The Telegraph & Argus
Like us on Facebook
Twice as many drivers abusing disabled blue badges (From Bradford Telegraph and Argus)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting TANEWS to 80360, or email
Twice as many drivers abusing disabled blue badges
7:00am Monday 27th August 2012 in News
Exclusive By Jo Winrow, City Hall Reporter
A legitimate blue badge is checked by officers during the crackdown
The number of people caught while misusing or fraudulently using disabled blue badge permits in Bradford has more than doubled, according to new figures obtained by the Telegraph & Argus.
Reports of blue badge fraud or misuse are also on the rise in the district as the number of prosecutions and cautions issued in the last five months is more than double the figure for the whole of last year.
It comes as drivers who abuse the disabled parking system are being warned Bradford Council is cracking down on those whose misuse the permits, often by continuing to use the badge of a dead relative or of a family member who is not in the vehicle at the time. Examples of fraud include using a stolen badge, outright counterfeit, or altering the expiry date on a badge.
Figures released by the Council under Freedom of Information rules show that so far in 2012/13 the authority has prosecuted 20 people and given 29 cautions. This compares to eight prosecutions and 13 cautions for the whole of 2011-12. Figures for the previous year show only one prosecution and no cautions.
Data on the number of warning letters issued over the same period shows a peak of 126 in 2011-12, after a low of eight the previous year, and so far this year 69 such letters have been issued.
In addition the number of reports of possible blue badge fraud have increased rapidly over the past few years with tip-offs coming often from members of the public who believe they have spotted wrong-doing, or from the Council’s parking officers themselves.
In 2010-11 there were 51 referrals, which increased to 158 the following year. However in the first five months of this year alone, there have already been 113 reports of potential abuse of the system.
Harry Singh, counter fraud manager at the Council, told the T&A: “We work very closely with the Council’s parking wardens on fraud awareness and also going out on patrol with them. We’ve been very proactive, firstly in the city centre, then we extended it out to Keighley and Shipley for example, and to the streets around Bradford City football club on match days.”
He stressed that while there are currently 17,400 valid blue badges in circulation in the district, anyone misusing them could be depriving a disabled person of a parking space close to their destination.
The badges are for drivers or passengers with severe mobility problems, and should only be used when the badge holder is actually travelling in the vehicle. They generally allow parking on single or double yellow lines for up to three hours, unless there is a ban on loading or unloading; at on-street parking meters and pay-and-display machines for free; and in disabled parking bays.
The maximum fine for someone convicted of misusing the badge system is £1,000 and the badge could also be removed.
New style badges were introduced nationally in January in a bid to counter fraud. So far 4,180 have been issued in Bradford, and it is expected to be three years before they have completely replaced the old paper ones, which are considered easier to replicate.
Martin Stubbs, the Council’s assistant director of the revenues and benefits service, warned: “At Bradford Council we are committed to stamping out fraud and misuse of blue badges. These badges are for disabled people who need to be able to park close to shops and amenities. Those who misuse the scheme are depriving genuine blue badge holders of a parking space.
“We are continuing to work proactively with our colleagues in parking services to take a proactive stance to tackle fraud and misuse and will continue to prosecute offenders.”
Members of the public can report suspected blue badge fraud and misuse on 0800 169 7451.
Comments(34)
Correctness
says...
9:26am Mon 27 Aug 12
Al Spade
says...
9:47am Mon 27 Aug 12
vax2002
says...
9:51am Mon 27 Aug 12
Al Spade wrote:Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority.
It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!
So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
thatsnotmyname
says...
10:07am Mon 27 Aug 12
a reasonable sort of chap
says...
10:09am Mon 27 Aug 12
a reasonable sort of chap
says...
10:14am Mon 27 Aug 12
HOW THE HELL IS ANYONE SUPPOSED TO RECOGNIZE THIS MAN ???
http://www.thetelegr
aphandargus.co.uk/ne
ws/9894216.Police_is
sue_photograph_of_ma
n_wanted_over_violen
t_robberies_in_Manni
ngham/
THE PHOTO IS TERRIBLE! HE COULD BE ANYONE !
AM I MEANT TO NOW CALL THE POLICE EVERY TIME I SEE A 6FT TALL BEARDED MUSLIM ????
AND WHY NO COMMENT SECTION ?????
Joedavid
says...
10:20am Mon 27 Aug 12
vax2002 wrote:Morrisons would dissagree with you, just park on Enterprise 5 or Victoria without a Badge in dissabled space and they onto you straight away to move.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Albion.
says...
10:28am Mon 27 Aug 12
a reasonable sort of chap wrote:Yes! Just to be on the safe side.
P.S.
HOW THE HELL IS ANYONE SUPPOSED TO RECOGNIZE THIS MAN ???
http://www.thetelegr
aphandargus.co.uk/ne
ws/9894216.Police_is
sue_photograph_of_ma
n_wanted_over_violen
t_robberies_in_Manni
ngham/
THE PHOTO IS TERRIBLE! HE COULD BE ANYONE !
AM I MEANT TO NOW CALL THE POLICE EVERY TIME I SEE A 6FT TALL BEARDED MUSLIM ????
AND WHY NO COMMENT SECTION ?????
Correctness
says...
10:29am Mon 27 Aug 12
vax2002 wrote:You park in a supermarket car park agreeing to the conditions displayed and in doing so have a contract. You can be prosecuted for using a disabled bay if you or someone using the vehicle is not the holder of such. Little or no knowledge very dangerous.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Correctness
says...
10:32am Mon 27 Aug 12
a reasonable sort of chap wrote:Why is race coming into this and an allegation that the man is a muslim.
P.S. HOW THE HELL IS ANYONE SUPPOSED TO RECOGNIZE THIS MAN ??? http://www.thetelegr aphandargus.co.uk/ne ws/9894216.Police_is sue_photograph_of_ma n_wanted_over_violen t_robberies_in_Manni ngham/ THE PHOTO IS TERRIBLE! HE COULD BE ANYONE ! AM I MEANT TO NOW CALL THE POLICE EVERY TIME I SEE A 6FT TALL BEARDED MUSLIM ???? AND WHY NO COMMENT SECTION ?????
vax2002
says...
10:36am Mon 27 Aug 12
Correctness wrote:Complete and UTTER HOGWASH !
vax2002 wrote:You park in a supermarket car park agreeing to the conditions displayed and in doing so have a contract. You can be prosecuted for using a disabled bay if you or someone using the vehicle is not the holder of such. Little or no knowledge very dangerous.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Please post a link to the legislation that lets a private company "prosecute" someone for not having a blue badge in a disabled bay in a supermarket. I await...
However the disability discrimination act DOES apply in supermarkets and anyone targeted by a supermarket for not displaying a blue badge when they are entitled to reasonable adjustments under that act can prosecute the supermarket under said legislation.
Blue badges DO NOT APPLY on private land or car parks, any "fines or tickets issued in private car parks can be safely ignored.
As the article states, many are abused and even more genuinely disabled people can not get a blue badge at all as they dont pass the "scam" test to get one, the test favours liars who know the "right" answers and genuine applicants get nothing.
modman61
says...
10:39am Mon 27 Aug 12
a reasonable sort of chap
says...
10:39am Mon 27 Aug 12
Correctness wrote:READ THE STORY, IDIOT.
a reasonable sort of chap wrote:Why is race coming into this and an allegation that the man is a muslim.
P.S. HOW THE HELL IS ANYONE SUPPOSED TO RECOGNIZE THIS MAN ??? http://www.thetelegr aphandargus.co.uk/ne ws/9894216.Police_is sue_photograph_of_ma n_wanted_over_violen t_robberies_in_Manni ngham/ THE PHOTO IS TERRIBLE! HE COULD BE ANYONE ! AM I MEANT TO NOW CALL THE POLICE EVERY TIME I SEE A 6FT TALL BEARDED MUSLIM ???? AND WHY NO COMMENT SECTION ?????
wobbley-bob
says...
10:41am Mon 27 Aug 12
Correctness wrote:Because the story in question says so numpty....Jeez!
a reasonable sort of chap wrote:Why is race coming into this and an allegation that the man is a muslim.
P.S. HOW THE HELL IS ANYONE SUPPOSED TO RECOGNIZE THIS MAN ??? http://www.thetelegr aphandargus.co.uk/ne ws/9894216.Police_is sue_photograph_of_ma n_wanted_over_violen t_robberies_in_Manni ngham/ THE PHOTO IS TERRIBLE! HE COULD BE ANYONE ! AM I MEANT TO NOW CALL THE POLICE EVERY TIME I SEE A 6FT TALL BEARDED MUSLIM ???? AND WHY NO COMMENT SECTION ?????
“The suspect is believed to be Asian, about 6ft tall, in his 30s, with a full beard, and of medium build."
"On each occasion the suspect was wearing traditional Muslim dress."
Biker71
says...
11:54am Mon 27 Aug 12
vax2002 wrote:It's idiots like you who make other idiots believe they can park in disabled bays and get away with it, yes on private land a person with a disability can park in a marked bay without a badge and use that as a defence against the parking charge, however that is all they can do, they can't use it as a claim under the DDA as there is sufficient provision for disabled parking under the law, at most they would get the parking charge quashed, and even then they may end up with a substantial legal and medical bill just from trying to prove disability without holding badges.. in this day and age legitimate blue badge holders have a hard enough time due to the current trend for ' disability bashing ' as it is without poorly considered ' expert ' twaddle like you have posted.
Correctness wrote:Complete and UTTER HOGWASH !
vax2002 wrote:You park in a supermarket car park agreeing to the conditions displayed and in doing so have a contract. You can be prosecuted for using a disabled bay if you or someone using the vehicle is not the holder of such. Little or no knowledge very dangerous.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Please post a link to the legislation that lets a private company "prosecute" someone for not having a blue badge in a disabled bay in a supermarket. I await...
However the disability discrimination act DOES apply in supermarkets and anyone targeted by a supermarket for not displaying a blue badge when they are entitled to reasonable adjustments under that act can prosecute the supermarket under said legislation.
Blue badges DO NOT APPLY on private land or car parks, any "fines or tickets issued in private car parks can be safely ignored.
As the article states, many are abused and even more genuinely disabled people can not get a blue badge at all as they dont pass the "scam" test to get one, the test favours liars who know the "right" answers and genuine applicants get nothing.
Biker71
says...
11:56am Mon 27 Aug 12
vax2002 wrote:It's idiots like you who make other idiots believe they can park in disabled bays and get away with it, yes on private land a person with a disability can park in a marked bay without a badge and use that as a defence against the parking charge, however that is all they can do, they can't use it as a claim under the DDA as there is sufficient provision for disabled parking under the law, at most they would get the parking charge quashed, and even then they may end up with a substantial legal and medical bill just from trying to prove disability without holding badges.. in this day and age legitimate blue badge holders have a hard enough time due to the current trend for ' disability bashing ' as it is without poorly considered ' expert ' twaddle like you have posted.
Correctness wrote:Complete and UTTER HOGWASH !
vax2002 wrote:You park in a supermarket car park agreeing to the conditions displayed and in doing so have a contract. You can be prosecuted for using a disabled bay if you or someone using the vehicle is not the holder of such. Little or no knowledge very dangerous.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Please post a link to the legislation that lets a private company "prosecute" someone for not having a blue badge in a disabled bay in a supermarket. I await...
However the disability discrimination act DOES apply in supermarkets and anyone targeted by a supermarket for not displaying a blue badge when they are entitled to reasonable adjustments under that act can prosecute the supermarket under said legislation.
Blue badges DO NOT APPLY on private land or car parks, any "fines or tickets issued in private car parks can be safely ignored.
As the article states, many are abused and even more genuinely disabled people can not get a blue badge at all as they dont pass the "scam" test to get one, the test favours liars who know the "right" answers and genuine applicants get nothing.
mad matt
says...
12:21pm Mon 27 Aug 12
The article highlights the fact that more blue badges are being mis-used.
There is no way this can be tollerated without trying to aprehend the criminals (and they are criminals) who try to avoid paying legitimate parking fees or 'steal' the benefits afforded to genuine blue-badge holders
a reasonable sort of chap
says...
12:43pm Mon 27 Aug 12
mad matt wrote:Hijacked by idiots = commented upon in the usual manner.
So a perfactly good newspaper article gets hi-jacked by idiots as per usual.
The article highlights the fact that more blue badges are being mis-used.
There is no way this can be tollerated without trying to aprehend the criminals (and they are criminals) who try to avoid paying legitimate parking fees or 'steal' the benefits afforded to genuine blue-badge holders
vax2002
says...
1:01pm Mon 27 Aug 12
Biker71 wrote:Prove to who ?
vax2002 wrote:It's idiots like you who make other idiots believe they can park in disabled bays and get away with it, yes on private land a person with a disability can park in a marked bay without a badge and use that as a defence against the parking charge, however that is all they can do, they can't use it as a claim under the DDA as there is sufficient provision for disabled parking under the law, at most they would get the parking charge quashed, and even then they may end up with a substantial legal and medical bill just from trying to prove disability without holding badges.. in this day and age legitimate blue badge holders have a hard enough time due to the current trend for ' disability bashing ' as it is without poorly considered ' expert ' twaddle like you have posted.
Correctness wrote:Complete and UTTER HOGWASH !
vax2002 wrote:You park in a supermarket car park agreeing to the conditions displayed and in doing so have a contract. You can be prosecuted for using a disabled bay if you or someone using the vehicle is not the holder of such. Little or no knowledge very dangerous.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Please post a link to the legislation that lets a private company "prosecute" someone for not having a blue badge in a disabled bay in a supermarket. I await...
However the disability discrimination act DOES apply in supermarkets and anyone targeted by a supermarket for not displaying a blue badge when they are entitled to reasonable adjustments under that act can prosecute the supermarket under said legislation.
Blue badges DO NOT APPLY on private land or car parks, any "fines or tickets issued in private car parks can be safely ignored.
As the article states, many are abused and even more genuinely disabled people can not get a blue badge at all as they dont pass the "scam" test to get one, the test favours liars who know the "right" answers and genuine applicants get nothing.
A parking Charge notice is NOT a penalty charge notice issued by the council, it is a fake impersonation of authority that can be IGNORED, you do not have to prove anything to anyone, the onus would be on the scam parking company to PROVE you had caused them a loss in court, which is virtually impossible.
Private parking charge companies have NO legal authority to issue fines of penalties, what they do issue are mealy speculative invoices.
BLUE BADGES HAVE NO STANDING ON PRIVATELY OWNED CAR PARKS, they are only valid on Council owned car parks and on-street parking.
Private Parking companies target disabled drivers for any minor excuse as they see them as an easy target.
The inability of you to know the difference between a fake scam parking ticket and a real one makes a laughing stock of you.
Biker71
says...
1:19pm Mon 27 Aug 12
Albion.
says...
1:35pm Mon 27 Aug 12
vax2002 wrote:Old Ted up in Haworth would soon put you right.
Biker71 wrote:Prove to who ?
vax2002 wrote:It's idiots like you who make other idiots believe they can park in disabled bays and get away with it, yes on private land a person with a disability can park in a marked bay without a badge and use that as a defence against the parking charge, however that is all they can do, they can't use it as a claim under the DDA as there is sufficient provision for disabled parking under the law, at most they would get the parking charge quashed, and even then they may end up with a substantial legal and medical bill just from trying to prove disability without holding badges.. in this day and age legitimate blue badge holders have a hard enough time due to the current trend for ' disability bashing ' as it is without poorly considered ' expert ' twaddle like you have posted.
Correctness wrote:Complete and UTTER HOGWASH !
vax2002 wrote:You park in a supermarket car park agreeing to the conditions displayed and in doing so have a contract. You can be prosecuted for using a disabled bay if you or someone using the vehicle is not the holder of such. Little or no knowledge very dangerous.
Al Spade wrote: It's amazing the number using blue badgers who park in the disabled bays a supermarkets and then find the energy to run into the store!Blue badges have no authority or power on private land, they are only valid for on street or council car parks, same as any Impersonation of authority fake parking tickets issued in private car parks, they have no authority. So blue badges in supermarkets have the same authority as a beermat.
Please post a link to the legislation that lets a private company "prosecute" someone for not having a blue badge in a disabled bay in a supermarket. I await...
However the disability discrimination act DOES apply in supermarkets and anyone targeted by a supermarket for not displaying a blue badge when they are entitled to reasonable adjustments under that act can prosecute the supermarket under said legislation.
Blue badges DO NOT APPLY on private land or car parks, any "fines or tickets issued in private car parks can be safely ignored.
As the article states, many are abused and even more genuinely disabled people can not get a blue badge at all as they dont pass the "scam" test to get one, the test favours liars who know the "right" answers and genuine applicants get nothing.
A parking Charge notice is NOT a penalty charge notice issued by the council, it is a fake impersonation of authority that can be IGNORED, you do not have to prove anything to anyone, the onus would be on the scam parking company to PROVE you had caused them a loss in court, which is virtually impossible.
Private parking charge companies have NO legal authority to issue fines of penalties, what they do issue are mealy speculative invoices.
BLUE BADGES HAVE NO STANDING ON PRIVATELY OWNED CAR PARKS, they are only valid on Council owned car parks and on-street parking.
Private Parking companies target disabled drivers for any minor excuse as they see them as an easy target.
The inability of you to know the difference between a fake scam parking ticket and a real one makes a laughing stock of you.
vax2002
says...
1:55pm Mon 27 Aug 12
Well ok a can of worms never opens itself, nice one biker 71 so for the record anyone receiving a "parking charge notice" seek further advice from a reputable forum, you may just save yourself a lot of money and crooks like biker71 have enough money scammed from motorists already.
yangyeight
says...
3:35pm Mon 27 Aug 12
a reasonable sort of chap wrote:dic-khead.
Hardly surprising really. Crime is bound to increase due to the Tory spending cuts making everyone poorer whilst simultaneously reducing Police and Council services. Blame Cameron & Osborne.
its all the conservatives fault, blah blah.
get a grip.
labour destroyed this country with its open door policy to cheap immigrant workforce and now we are all suffering.
every immigrant that works brings 4 or 5 family members with him who does not!!
you work out the maths.
back to the real story, misuse of badge should be instant badge removal, end of problem.
Avro
says...
7:36pm Mon 27 Aug 12
wobbley-bob wrote:This is probably done by the exact same people!
So that's 20 'frauds' out of 17,400 users.
Not really epidemic proportions then is it?
Compared to uninsured/untaxed vehicle fraud, it's a non story.
pkenny
says...
8:46pm Mon 27 Aug 12
Correctness
says...
8:54pm Mon 27 Aug 12
still got a pulse
says...
12:35am Tue 28 Aug 12
still got a pulse
says...
12:35am Tue 28 Aug 12
still got a pulse
says...
12:36am Tue 28 Aug 12
Patrick Bateman
says...
8:13am Tue 28 Aug 12
still got a pulse wrote:What a waste of time: like they'd CARE (even IF - by some remote chance - they came across such a pointless and obscure twitter page). You seem to be crediting people who are not entitled to park in disabled bays (but do so anyway) with a level of consideration and decency that the majority of normal folk share. That is a mistake.
Seen healthy pillocks parking in disabled bays? Take a photo and post on twitter with #RSOLE. Join in and shame the pillocks.
I see the blue badge scheme being abused regularly at my local gym. Quite often the cars parked in the disabled spaces don't have the badge or - and this is quite common - the car does seem to have the badge but the car is conspicuously flash. For example the one there yesterday was a 12-plate Range Rover Autobiography with blue badge on the dash (which is typical of the kind of vehicle I'm talking about). Now I'm not suggesting that all disabled aren't well-off and can't afford these 'little luxuries' but let's just say it looks 'a little suss' (either that or there are indeed a lot of disabled folk about that are indeed 'rolling in it').
modman61
says...
8:40am Tue 28 Aug 12
spinnekop
says...
10:24am Tue 28 Aug 12
nevisthecat
says...
4:09pm Tue 28 Aug 12
Of course, the parking firm is not incuring the loss, so it is a moot point anyway as to whether they can levy an invoice. That invoice has to be served on the driver. all they get from DVLA is the keeper's details. Massive, no huuge differance and another reason not to engage with them.
So, if you received a penatly demand or any iteration thereof, usually in a black and yellow wrapper to make it look like a genuine PCN (itself an offence) then bin it.
You will get the usual rubbish from Roxburghe Debt collection and some fud called Michael Sobell, each time inflating the charge but stick to it and ignore them.
The only area I would counsel caution is a charge from a railway carpark. Case law indicates this is a grey area but increasingly it seems the Railway Premises Act is being used to secure payment in the court.
wobbley-bob says...
9:25am Mon 27 Aug 12
Not really epidemic proportions then is it?
Compared to uninsured/untaxed vehicle fraud, it's a non story.