News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Politicians say changes will have to be made in ‘underused’ service

Bradford Central Library Bradford Central Library

Bradford’s political leaders are refusing to rule out cuts to the district’s “underused” library services.

More than 400 libraries face being axed across the UK as councils react to the Government’s public spending cuts, according to some reports.

Budget proposals are being drawn up by Bradford Council’s political parties before its spending plans for 2011/12 are agreed next month. The libraries service cost the Council almost £6 million to run in 2009/10.

Council leader Councillor Ian Greenwood said: “Obviously the Council has got to make a huge number of reductions and we are looking at every part of the service.

“We are in consultation with staff and until those discussions are over I’m unable to say where those cuts will be.”

Bradford’s libraries have a total membership of 206,125. The Council employs 125 people to run them with wages costing £3.6 million. In the past financial year, 1.6 million books, 39,052 DVDs and 7,136 CDs were loaned.

Councillor Jeanette Sunderland, leader of the Council’s Liberal Democrat group, said: “What the numbers say is that we spend a lot of money on a service that less than a third of people are using and there has got to be questions to ask to get more value for our money.

“People usually have hugely fond memories of libraries but actually some are underused. The future for libraries is to find new uses for them so they are not just places where we borrow books.

“We have a view as Liberal Democrats that libraries have to become the heart of wherever they are placed and as ward councillor for Idle and Thackley I’m working very hard to secure a future for the library there.”

Libraries should be places where people can get business advice, search for jobs and they should be open all day on Saturdays and Sundays, she said.

Councillor Anne Hawkesworth, leader of the Conservative group, said the Council had tough decisions to make.

She said: “Clearly if residents were asked to rank services that are provided, libraries and other leisure or cultural facilities would not be deemed as important as child protection or services to the elderly, but that does not mean that people would be indifferent to their closure.

“Conservative colleagues and I are hopeful that the local library service will survive largely intact and we will be expecting officers to carefully examine the internal service re-design options and also the provisions of the new Localism Bill to determine whether communities or voluntary groups within them have the capacity and the will to manage the service for themselves.”

In a House of Commons debate this week, Libraries Minister Ed Vaizey said: “No MP can say with all honesty that no library should ever close in any local authority area. We need a strategic vision.

“It is up to local communities, working with local councillors, to keep our libraries open, with volunteers supplementing and working with librarians, rather than replacing them.”

Comments(14)

Leighann says...
8:03am Fri 28 Jan 11

I'm not surprised they are underused, I took my 6 year old to the central library and there was a poor selection of books, the majority of the books were old and tatty and very outdated. Some of the books there were the same ones that I have taken out when I was his age. The adult sections faired not much better.

Thee Voice of Reason says...
8:44am Fri 28 Jan 11

I'm sure in the past libraries were a good source of information and research but time has moved on and now most people have access to the internet for what they would have used to go to the library for.
.
The average wage of £29k per employee at the library appears to be a little on the steep side too. There probably is a little scope to cut back a little.

Dizziemare says...
8:45am Fri 28 Jan 11

My local seems to double up as a toddler group venue - hardly conducive to making use of it.

I also have concerns re the council's usage figures. My local is usually full of people making use of internet resources and newspapers etc - they are library users too, even if they don't borrow material.

I can understand though why any politian would want to restrict access to libraries - it's an age old tactic - keep the populous thick, and you've a better chance of staying in power.

Mekon says...
9:35am Fri 28 Jan 11

3.6 mill on 125 people? That can't be right. I know that people working at the Library don't get much, so someone/s at the top (as usual) is getting a **** healthy wage.

And if the whole system costs 6 in total than they have a pretty bad business going on. Wages should not take up over a half of a businesses turnover.

Start at the top with the redundancy process.

John Phillips says...
11:56am Fri 28 Jan 11

Thee Voice of Reason wrote:
I'm sure in the past libraries were a good source of information and research but time has moved on and now most people have access to the internet for what they would have used to go to the library for.
.
The average wage of £29k per employee at the library appears to be a little on the steep side too. There probably is a little scope to cut back a little.
Agree with this. We've moved on from books (sadly); the internet's the future now.
.
And also quite shocked at that £29k salary.

Yeah Bilker Girly says...
12:23pm Fri 28 Jan 11

The article only mentions figures for books dvd and cd loans, the library service provides much more than this, like free access to computer facilities.
It moved into the 21st century long ago! The free computer course I attended at my local library was excellent, this is not reflected in these figures, if it was not for my Local Library at Keighley i would not be here e-mailing this! I am now using my new found skills at the local studies library to trace my family history. Its not just about figures and books, move with the times, when did these spouting councillors last visit a public library, it is so much more than just books.

albion says...
12:37pm Fri 28 Jan 11

Yeah Bilker Girly wrote:
The article only mentions figures for books dvd and cd loans, the library service provides much more than this, like free access to computer facilities.
It moved into the 21st century long ago! The free computer course I attended at my local library was excellent, this is not reflected in these figures, if it was not for my Local Library at Keighley i would not be here e-mailing this! I am now using my new found skills at the local studies library to trace my family history. Its not just about figures and books, move with the times, when did these spouting councillors last visit a public library, it is so much more than just books.
To be fair the latter stages of the report do contain suggestions from councillors on how to make libraries more usable to people.

Herbal Nation says...
12:38pm Fri 28 Jan 11

Libraries are NOT the place to get business advice nor are they a place to search for jobs. They are a place for BOOKS. There should be no multi-media suites, only wooden shelves, books, and silence. The trouble with Bradford library is the lack of organization. I have been unable to locate books on several occasions that are listed as being in stock but have mysteriously vanished, including some that were reference books not for loan. I also encountered a librarian who had never heard of J.G. Ballard!

Yeah Bilker Girly says...
1:03pm Fri 28 Jan 11

''To be fair the latter stages of the report do contain suggestions from councillors on how to make libraries more usable to people.''



You are missing my point Albion, what i am trying to say is that my local Library (Keighley) already provides much more than is suggested in the article.

albion says...
1:23pm Fri 28 Jan 11

Yeah Bilker Girly wrote:
''To be fair the latter stages of the report do contain suggestions from councillors on how to make libraries more usable to people.''



You are missing my point Albion, what i am trying to say is that my local Library (Keighley) already provides much more than is suggested in the article.
I thought all the larger one's provided the things you describe.

pensight says...
3:19pm Fri 28 Jan 11

John Phillips wrote:
Thee Voice of Reason wrote: I'm sure in the past libraries were a good source of information and research but time has moved on and now most people have access to the internet for what they would have used to go to the library for. . The average wage of £29k per employee at the library appears to be a little on the steep side too. There probably is a little scope to cut back a little.
Agree with this. We've moved on from books (sadly); the internet's the future now. . And also quite shocked at that £29k salary.
I think you will find most library ie 3/4 staff do not get paid anywhere near £29k . Having worked as library casual staff, to my knowledge front line staff get paid around £14,000 to £17,000pa hardly a kings ransom. And i bet this 125 staff figure does not take into account all 50 odd casual staff used to prop up the library service who will also get paid out of the 3.6 million.

"Lies, damned lies, and statistics"

pensight says...
3:54pm Fri 28 Jan 11

Poor old libraries - they are often the focus of negative media attention and an easy target. What about all the money that the council wastes on ephemeral publicity campaigns, meaningless branding and promotions - all froth with nothing beneath. Libraries are already under staffed, but still offer a good solid service with low-paid frontline staff working under difficult conditions.

ilivehereok says...
10:28am Sat 29 Jan 11

“We have a view as Liberal Democrats that libraries have to become the heart of wherever they are placed and as ward councillor for Idle and Thackley I’m working very hard to secure a future for the library there.”
That's nice - oh, hang on, I thought your job was to work hard for everyone the council 'represents'.
Also,
"What the numbers say is that we spend a lot of money on a service that less than a third of people are using and there has got to be questions to ask to get more value for our money."
Does that mean that other minority usage services should be axed?
If so, start with the town hall subsidised canteen (can't be used by more than a few hundred folk out of half a million people), then move onto counsillor transport services, Bradford Tourism Department (after all, a few visitors to this hell hole can't be prioritised), Bradford Forward and Business Forum which only represent a few counsillor private business cronies etc etc.
Hypocritical posturings from over paid halfwits purporting to support, represent and protect a real world they know absolutely nothing about the realities of.
The only people capable of sorting this mess out are Guy Fawkes and Oliver Cromwell......

Thee Voice of Reason says...
11:07am Sat 29 Jan 11

After the Yorkshire post yet again uncovers what the T&A just ignores you have to ask why stories like this are coming out about cuts when you can see blatent spending by the council it obviously wants to keep quiet.
.
Take a look at this.
.
http://www.yorkshire
post.co.uk/news/Excl
usive-Taxpayers-pay-
a-high.6705766.jp
.
"the Yorkshire Post today reveals how one local authority, Bradford Council, has, on average, been spending nearly £9,000-a-month on flights and hotels since 2008.
.
A list of nearly 800 hotel bookings made by the council over the past two years includes well over 100 nights at establishments costing at least £150 per night.
.
Flights taken by Bradford Council staff included an £8,000 trip to Dubai and £5,000 club class flight to Hong Kong."

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree