Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting TANEWS to 80360, or email
7:00am Monday 15th March 2010 in
Major damage has been caused by the harsh winter at the construction sites of all four Bradford secondary schools being rebuilt in the latest phase of a multi-million-pound scheme.
Water inside under-floor heating pipes at each partially-built school froze, cracking the pipes and concrete floor slabs laid over them as temperatures repeatedly plunged below zero.
Bradford Council confirmed the situation occurred after contractors had filled the heating systems with water to test for leaks before they were covered in concrete.
The true extent of the damage and the repairs needed is still being assessed.
But it has led councillors to question how the situation was allowed to happen with one saying that it seems someone has missed some very basic ABCs of household maintenance.
Bradford Council has insisted it will not bear any of the additional costs, which are likely to be substantial.
The affected school sites are: Grange Technology College in Bradford Hanson School in Bradford Beckfoot School at Bingley Greenhead High School in Keighley.
The schools are being rebuilt as part of the second phase of the Council’s Building Schools for Future (BSF) programme which is costing £400 million.
The BSF scheme is being delivered by the Local Education Partnership, known as Integrated Bradford.
A company called Educo, a consortium of construction giants Costain and Ferrovial Agroman, is responsible for the design and building work.
Cindy Peek, the Council’s deputy director of services for children and young people, said: “We acknowledge there has been an issue with the four new secondary schools which are being built in this phase. Unfortunately, damage was incurred to the concrete floor slabs during the recent extreme weather conditions.
“We are obviously disappointed that an element of the work carried out on our Building Schools for the Future phase two secondary schools has encountered a problem.
“This will be rectified by the contractor as part of the construction process and will not affect the quality of the completed schools. The cost of any repair will not be borne by the Council.
“Technical solutions are being tested by the contractor, Educo, at the moment as the weather is getting warmer.
“Once this has been done we will be able to discuss the overall impact. In the meantime the contractor is still working on all the sites and work is progressing.”
But councillors involved in education in Bradford have questioned how the situation was allowed to happen.
Councillor Ralph Berry, Labour’s education spokesman, said: “It seems to me that someone has missed some very basic ABCs of household maintenance.
“When temperatures drop water freezes, and ice expands. Any GCSE physics candidate could tell you what’s gone wrong here.
“It raises a question about the oversight of the programme.” Councillor David Ward, education spokesman for the Council’s Liberal Democrat group, said: “The important thing is that the repair work is paid for by those responsible and the project is back on track as soon as possible.”
Mrs Peek said she was otherwise pleased with the progress being made across the school sites. “The primary special schools in this phase have been completed to an extremely high standard and they are officially opening on new sites alongside mainstream schools after Easter.
“We are also delighted that Merlin Top Primary School in Keighley has already opened and is making a real difference for children, parents and staff.”
Comments(8)
bredandbuttered
says...
9:08am Mon 15 Mar 10
outside of politics
says...
10:11am Mon 15 Mar 10
markjoe
says...
3:04pm Mon 15 Mar 10
outside of politics wrote:Good point, Nab Wood is a prime example it doesn't serve the community that it is in but they want to extend it. Most Nab Wood pupils come from the Heaton, Manningham area, the children from the community that Nab Wood school is in go to either Bingley Grammar, Beckfoot even Salts Grammar. Therefore close Nab Wood and expand the other schools.
problem i have with this BSF programme is that we are not building new schools where they are needed.
it seems we are just knocking down current schools and makeing them bigger for more children.
why oh why are we not identifying areas where population growth is anticipated and plan to build schools in communities were they are needed and stop children having to travel longer distances.
Duke of Odsal
says...
3:24pm Mon 15 Mar 10
Joedavid
says...
4:13pm Mon 15 Mar 10
Duke of Odsal wrote:Cowboy, comes to mind.
It's easy to use hindsight to criticise; it would be normal practice to use some kind of additive to prevent freezing when testing in winter, but the extremes were well beyond what would normally be expected. I am pretty sure there will be many who's antifreeze treated windscreen wash froze anyway, and this is no different to that. Anyone with a modicum of understanding of the way the construction industry works will know that the cost of this incident will be borne by the contractor (or most probably the mechanical sub-contractor) that got caught out. Of course, that wouldnt be a scandal though would it!
SteveW56
says...
7:37pm Mon 15 Mar 10
Duke of Odsal
says...
10:21am Tue 16 Mar 10
SteveW56 wrote:As a Property and Architectural consultant I would have thought you would have enough experience not to shoot from the lip! There is nothing in this story to indicate what ACTUALLY happened, the events leading up to the freeze, whether reasonable precautions were taken etc. You would also be experienced wnough to know that building isnt always a precise science and things go wrong on sites - sometimes due to lack of planning or expertise, but sometimes despite it.
As a Property and Architectural Consultant for nearly 30 years I never cease to be amazed at the things that go wrong on large contracts, particularly where simple things get forgotten. If the small details and basic principles are forgotten then disaster strikes as it has here - water freezes and expands - even within concrete slabs! Is this yet another Design and Build Contract where the Architect is relegated to 'plans drawer' and has no power or authority to inspect the works on site? I suspect so as this approach seems to save money - until things like this happen.
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Find your next job now in Bradford and beyond
Search Now »
Make a date in Bradford and surrounding areas now
Search Now »
Homes for sale and to let in Bradford and surrounding areas.
Search Now »
Cars for sale throughout Bradford and surrounding areas
Search Now »
Mike Strutter says...
7:31am Mon 15 Mar 10
Honestly ?