News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Festive market snubbed by shoppers shuts early


A major part of Bradford’s Christmas programme has been cancelled already.

The German Market in Centenary Square was packed up yesterday – a fortnight earlier than planned.

What started out as a 40-stall event was supposed to last for a month, but some traders left last week and other traders shut earlier in the evening due to a lack of trade.

At the weekend the remaining traders returned to Germany, which left organisers having to take down the chalet-style shops yesterday.

Charly Barber, whose company CB Productions, put on the event, said last week that he had signed a contract with Bradford Council to hire Centenary Square until December 21, but could not force traders to stay if they were not making any money.

He had called for the people of Bradford to support the market and said that the bad weather had put some people off.

But the lack of variety and absence of any traditional German gifts at the market had already attracted criticism. One shopper said she was extremely disappointed at the lack of crafts and wooden toys.

And others said many of the items were too expensive.

Mr Barber had said he hoped to sign up some traders selling the more traditional goods as the weeks went on.

The majority of stalls sold food and drinks – some German – but others sold pizza, burgers and sweets. A small number sold gifts, such as candles and photograph frames.

Mary Frame, of Bradford Chamber of Trade, warned that a month-long market such as this on the edge of the main shopping area would need to be more attractive to bring in shoppers.

She said: “Perhaps the Council should insist on more control over the content next time around, although it sounds like these organisers won’t want to come back to Bradford again.

“A month was probably too long for this kind of thing here. Bradford has shot itself in the foot again.”

The Council confirmed that Mr Barber would have to honour the original contract and pay rent on the square until December 21.

Tim Hirst, the Council’s assistant director of commercial and support services, said: “We are very disappointed that things haven’t worked out for them.

“As well as the shortage of customers, the traders did not receive any favours from the horrendous weather during the period they were operating.

“Due to the contract under which the space in Centenary Square was rented, Bradford Council will not lose any money from the market’s premature closure.”

Despite repeated attempts, the T&A was unable to contact Mr Barber yesterday.

Comments(126)

Avro says...
8:11am Tue 8 Dec 09

Ha Ha Ha Ha, anyone for firewood?

Bradford, the laughing stock of the UK!

Apollo says...
8:14am Tue 8 Dec 09

The words p*ss up and brewery come to mind.
As to the Council taking more of a lead - would that be the same Council that has driven Bradford into the ground, quite literally?
Forget it, Bradford as a shopping centre is already dead and the Council built the pyre.

Bantam58 says...
8:32am Tue 8 Dec 09

Went to the market last year when it was not just in centenary square but at the bottom of ivegate and elsewhere, this year it was very disapointing, but then again this is bradford we are talking about, bring back the centenary square beach so the council can put its head back in the sand, anyway at least the city centre park and lake is about to be built !!!

Johsay says...
8:35am Tue 8 Dec 09

Kriss Hopkins, please comment.

Old Peculiar says...
8:55am Tue 8 Dec 09

The market was terrible, a blind man could have seen it was a non starter. The article says that there was critisicm that there weren't enough traditional wooden toys ? Well there was plenty of traditional cr@p being sold - about 5 stalls selling christmas lights, and plenty of others selling pick n mixes at ridiculously inflated prices. There was virtually nothing there that would have kept a family entertained for more than 5 minutes.
Brafud is not like Leeds or Manchester ; Sunday to Thursday, once the 6pm bus has left town, the place is deserted apart from tramps and taxi drivers.
Brafud Council - time for a bit of reflection.
Charly Barber, I suspect these stall holders will have paid you a lot of cash - time to start ducking, cos there's going to be some sh*te heading your way from Germany.

finemess says...
9:19am Tue 8 Dec 09

Bradford council are a laughing stock. Who is this charley barber they took on? Delboy in disguise?
What is more depressing is that nothing will ever change and the clueless morons running the council will just carry on regardless!

Collos says...
9:47am Tue 8 Dec 09

This bore no resemblance to a German market spending much of my time in Germany and seeing the real thing .Who advised the stall holders this would work or advised the council.All successful markets need a thriving city centre to succeed as can be seen in Leeds or Manchester something Bradford is lacking and not to have in the forseeable future.

bunnyson says...
9:50am Tue 8 Dec 09

As Cilla Black would say, surprise surprise. Is it any wonder that people will not support a German Market when there is little left in the City Centre itself? We have a hole, a proposed lake, Wharf Street, Holdsworth Street, Stott Hill and Balme Street turned into major roads because the only way around Bradford is via minor roads or the ring road. Perfectly good roads being narrowed to choke the traffic, see Tong Street and now Wrose Road. No buses apart from the free bus going to Forster Square Station, a lot of buses not going near to the Interchange.

I've lived in the City for the last 28 years and am saddened to see this once proud City being turned into a wasteland.

Bradford Council. you should be ashamed.




Scargutt says...
10:28am Tue 8 Dec 09

Why not sell off the wooden chalets? I'll have one.

Probably already been dumped in the westfield landfill though.

the1bully says...
10:43am Tue 8 Dec 09

who are they kidding?- "gone back to Germany"- none of them are from Germany just local scally traders! what a joke. im 27 and was born in Bradford. Ive lived in Australia from 2003 up until last year and came back here whilst my new visa was processed. Bradford is a joke- only good thing is akbars! Although I have a Bradford postcode I go shopping in Leeds and spent 1hr queuing last saturday for the german market there- just to get in! and had a great night!!

Im happy never to see this city ever again

babafk says...
11:10am Tue 8 Dec 09

Whilst making making a video of the Market last week ,i got talking to one of the Traders . His Boat fare costs him £794 , his Hotel was £40 per night . His best takings per day was £42 - his items were reasonably priced (in fact cheaper than Stalls selling similar items at our Successful European Market!) yet hardly anyone supported his stall or the Market . Firstly people of Bradford must be feeling the Credit crunch Pinch , but with our Citycentre being a nonstarter when it comes to Shopping i am not suprised the traders patience and Pennys ran out

Mercury_Lime says...
11:39am Tue 8 Dec 09

What a joke as always good old Bradford.....
I was over in York 2 weekends ago and they had a Christmas market going on.... and it was amazing. There were coach loads of people of all ages there, every stall was busy and all the normal shops cafes / restaurants were busy.... can York Council run us please....

Storck says...
11:46am Tue 8 Dec 09

I think one of the problems is that it was planned to be on for a month so there was no rush to go down in the first week. They would have done more business if it had been for a shorter period.

Joedavid says...
12:17pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Blaming the weather, that's a joke it is very mild, more like autum than winter.
Council going to charge them for full contract money, believe it when I see it if they pay up.

claytonian says...
12:21pm Tue 8 Dec 09

like the traditional crap comment peculiar,maybe we could do it again next year and re brand it as crapmass,i think its got legs

Up with the partridge says...
12:28pm Tue 8 Dec 09

What is going on here (or not as the case may be) what is Bradford Council and the useless T&A doing about it. Why is Bradford the worst city in the UK, PLEASE can someone tell me. I was born in the place and it is very distressing to see a place that with the possible exception of some places in the West Mids ie Wolverhampton, Dudley and other holes, is the by far the worst town centre anywhere in the UK - no sorry Cumbernauld in Scotland is worse.

FaceUpToIt says...
12:32pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Bradford is a cultural blackhole - full of those who are more interested in cramming their faces with ready meals, watching ITV and breeding dangerous dogs. I'm afraid this is symptomatic of Bradford's lack of ambition. We are reaping what we've sown.

TirNaNog says...
1:08pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Well the Germans have told the Council what the locals have been trying to for years! Now will they listen? I wouldn't bet on it. I feel for the businesses like Max's gaff trying to make a go of it in Bradford only to get shat on by petty officialdom. Do these councillors ever respond to the concerns of their citizens? A march on City Hall might wake the bastards up!

FaceUpToIt says...
1:44pm Tue 8 Dec 09

The concerns of their citizens? Their citizens don't have any concerns other than getting their next dose of "I'm a Celebrity" and a microwave curry. This city is so low-brow it's embarrassing

Macca51 says...
2:04pm Tue 8 Dec 09

For you Fritz, the market is over !

stevewibsey says...
2:36pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Just got back from a long weekend at the Christmas Markets in Brussels. It was brilliant! Sorry Bradford, you have no idea!

Kev-Robinson says...
3:33pm Tue 8 Dec 09

The only time this council will wake up is at the next election also the council in my mind do not ever respond to it's citizens

Winston Black says...
3:39pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Is Bradford Council trying its best to win the numpty of the year competition? A simple market research project would easily have provided the people of Bradford with a decent 'Market shopping experience' - but no Bradford Council chose to apply the numpty method
and waste time and money on a
market no-one wants to buy
anything from.I feel sorry for the Germans who probably will have to set up a little market stall in the airport to pay for the ticket home, what is even a bigger joke -
Is that the council are happy to support the construction of a massive waterfall and park bang in the centre, and seem to have forgotten that massive 'Westfield Quarry' they've dug just a stone - throw from this proposed theme - park - waterfall, that no-one wants. How about putting money into the Westfield Quarry and turning it into shops and businesses
and create jobs for the people of Bradford that you have let down?

Thank you Bradford Metropolitan Council, please make sure you send me my council tax bill next year, I shall pay it with Glee, NOT!



Spanishbob19 says...
3:44pm Tue 8 Dec 09

I went to the Lincoln Christmas Market on Sunday and I have never seen so many people in one town centre in my entire life.

Bradford could only dream of attracting this amount of punters.

claytonian says...
4:00pm Tue 8 Dec 09

had a day there as well spanish then a night out in nottingham - different world

FaceUpToIt says...
4:05pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Why blame the Council for this? The people of Bradford need to broaden their horizons and aspire to something better. Any other city would have seen a decent turn-out.

Old Peculiar says...
4:19pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Macca51 wrote:
For you Fritz, the market is over !
thats funny, i know funny, and thats funny !!

Facuptoit - you have no idea what you are talking about ; the market was cr@p. Attending this market would not have broadened anyones horizons, whether they were from Brafud or Timbucktoo !! And of course Brafud Council are attributable to the mess, they have a responsibilty to ensure that whoever / whatever they book, are suitable. Both parties (stall holders and customers) need to be considered in this equation, but I suspect the only equation that the Councillors will have considered, will be how much extra bonus they will have been able to award themselves from booking the disasterous event.

stiflers mom says...
4:26pm Tue 8 Dec 09

There are still posters around the city
saying welcome to the magical german market,well the only thing magic about it, is that it has now DISAPPEARED just like the decent people of this once proud city.

FaceUpToIt says...
4:29pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Old Peculiar wrote:
Macca51 wrote: For you Fritz, the market is over !
thats funny, i know funny, and thats funny !! Facuptoit - you have no idea what you are talking about ; the market was cr@p. Attending this market would not have broadened anyones horizons, whether they were from Brafud or Timbucktoo !! And of course Brafud Council are attributable to the mess, they have a responsibilty to ensure that whoever / whatever they book, are suitable. Both parties (stall holders and customers) need to be considered in this equation, but I suspect the only equation that the Councillors will have considered, will be how much extra bonus they will have been able to award themselves from booking the disasterous event.
This illustrates my point perfectly. You laugh at a borderline racist joke but do not even concede the point that the same market in any other city would have been a success. Seriously, the only thing that would get the crowds out in Bradford is a public appearance by someone like Jeremy Kyle

mad matt says...
5:03pm Tue 8 Dec 09

I know what would attract good crowds to Centenary Square - put up three of four sets of stocks dump a load of rotting fruit and veg in front of them and fill the stocks with some of our useless councillors!
Let that run for a month :)

TirNaNog says...
5:38pm Tue 8 Dec 09

FaceUpToIt wrote:
Old Peculiar wrote:
Macca51 wrote: For you Fritz, the market is over !
thats funny, i know funny, and thats funny !! Facuptoit - you have no idea what you are talking about ; the market was cr@p. Attending this market would not have broadened anyones horizons, whether they were from Brafud or Timbucktoo !! And of course Brafud Council are attributable to the mess, they have a responsibilty to ensure that whoever / whatever they book, are suitable. Both parties (stall holders and customers) need to be considered in this equation, but I suspect the only equation that the Councillors will have considered, will be how much extra bonus they will have been able to award themselves from booking the disasterous event.
This illustrates my point perfectly. You laugh at a borderline racist joke but do not even concede the point that the same market in any other city would have been a success. Seriously, the only thing that would get the crowds out in Bradford is a public appearance by someone like Jeremy Kyle
Get over yourself! What makes you so special Mr Intellectual? You denegrate ALL the citizens of Bradford. Met them all have you?

webess says...
5:58pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Can't see what all the fuss is about. It was only a few stalls FFS.

More importantly no locals lost their livliehoods. And as for council, aren't they the same people who look after Ilkley?

webess says...
6:01pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Mercury_Lime wrote:
What a joke as always good old Bradford.....
I was over in York 2 weekends ago and they had a Christmas market going on.... and it was amazing. There were coach loads of people of all ages there, every stall was busy and all the normal shops cafes / restaurants were busy.... can York Council run us please....
Is it any wonder there are problems attracting shoppers into City Centre when Bradfordians gloat about taking there business elsewhere?

Moon on a stick says...
6:05pm Tue 8 Dec 09

webess wrote:
Mercury_Lime wrote:
What a joke as always good old Bradford.....
I was over in York 2 weekends ago and they had a Christmas market going on.... and it was amazing. There were coach loads of people of all ages there, every stall was busy and all the normal shops cafes / restaurants were busy.... can York Council run us please....
Is it any wonder there are problems attracting shoppers into City Centre when Bradfordians gloat about taking there business elsewhere?
There is little choice, there's no easy parking, it's necessary and a better experience to often shop elsewhere.

FaceUpToIt says...
6:07pm Tue 8 Dec 09

TirNaNog wrote:
FaceUpToIt wrote:
Old Peculiar wrote:
Macca51 wrote: For you Fritz, the market is over !
thats funny, i know funny, and thats funny !! Facuptoit - you have no idea what you are talking about ; the market was cr@p. Attending this market would not have broadened anyones horizons, whether they were from Brafud or Timbucktoo !! And of course Brafud Council are attributable to the mess, they have a responsibilty to ensure that whoever / whatever they book, are suitable. Both parties (stall holders and customers) need to be considered in this equation, but I suspect the only equation that the Councillors will have considered, will be how much extra bonus they will have been able to award themselves from booking the disasterous event.
This illustrates my point perfectly. You laugh at a borderline racist joke but do not even concede the point that the same market in any other city would have been a success. Seriously, the only thing that would get the crowds out in Bradford is a public appearance by someone like Jeremy Kyle
Get over yourself! What makes you so special Mr Intellectual? You denegrate ALL the citizens of Bradford. Met them all have you?
Nothing makes me special. I am simply saddened that most folk seem to want to blame the council (or some other scapegoat) rather than look at themselves. If people want Bradford to succeed (and I do) they have to get behind such events. Furthermore, this was a chance for people to do something different and they simply couldn't be bothered: it's not the council's fault that 'their citizens' are unmotivated and don't want to try something new.

As for being intellectual, I do not consider myself to be more intellectucal than the next man: however, I do not see why being an intellectual should be a subject for humour. This is something to which we should aspire rather than knock.

mrs white says...
6:24pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Commenting for the first time on this forum. I can only say as I sat at a stall inside the Impressions Gallery on Sunday at the craft & vintage fair,how sad it was looking out at the abandoned alpine chalets.
No festive shoppers in sight.
However the day did not start well when the traders for the Gallery event were having their cars ticketed whilst unpacking cars in the unloading bay! 3 wardens waiting. Is this how visitors coming into the city are treated when they come into the city How can this do anything positive for Bradfords reputation.

Secondly Do not get me started on running an independent shop in Rawson Place. This is why I was in the Gallery to try & promote the area..... We are really trying hard to remain open.(Etherea - pure essential oil shop. It would be great to have received a little more support from the Big important people of the City!

Moon on a stick says...
6:26pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Not any person can set-up on Centenary Square you know, the council let the space and so has a responsibility for making sure an event is suitable and viable. Frankly anyone that says the council don't have any responsibility for the decade plus of retail decline in Bradford is bonkers.

Moon on a stick says...
6:30pm Tue 8 Dec 09

mrs white wrote:
Commenting for the first time on this forum. I can only say as I sat at a stall inside the Impressions Gallery on Sunday at the craft & vintage fair,how sad it was looking out at the abandoned alpine chalets.
No festive shoppers in sight.
However the day did not start well when the traders for the Gallery event were having their cars ticketed whilst unpacking cars in the unloading bay! 3 wardens waiting. Is this how visitors coming into the city are treated when they come into the city How can this do anything positive for Bradfords reputation.

Secondly Do not get me started on running an independent shop in Rawson Place. This is why I was in the Gallery to try & promote the area..... We are really trying hard to remain open.(Etherea - pure essential oil shop. It would be great to have received a little more support from the Big important people of the City!
To Mrs White - Good point again about the Council's attitude about making the City Centre inaccessible to genuine trade in the day time, it's only interested in levy parking charges. I have a feeling my girlfriend is a customer at your shop, if I'm not mistaken the opening hours are a little vague but she's happy with what she buys.

FaceUpToIt says...
6:33pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Moon on a stick wrote:
Not any person can set-up on Centenary Square you know, the council let the space and so has a responsibility for making sure an event is suitable and viable. Frankly anyone that says the council don't have any responsibility for the decade plus of retail decline in Bradford is bonkers.
Don't get me wrong - I hold the Council to blame for a lot of what is wrong with Bradford - but we don't do ourselves any favours either. You say 'suitable and viable' - what's the subtext here? To me it looks like Bradford is a city lacking in culture and ambition.

Moon on a stick says...
6:41pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Viable, anyone that knows Bradford, of which I'd hope would include Bradford Council Members knows as stone cold fact, the city is empty after 6pm, hence Chino Thai is suffering for example. So a market intending to open to 9pm was pointless especially with no retail shops nearby opening the same hours.
.
Suitable, well if the market was an addition to an already busy retail economy even expensive drinks, food and gifts would have sold, without that they would struggle.
.
Having the market made the centre look nicer, more Christmas like but it should have been part of briefer and more organised opening along with existing retailers.
.
Finally if the council want the German's back I suggest getting David Hasslehoff to turn on the lights next year, whilst he's at it he can tear down the Westfield hoardings and reunite the City Centre. ;-)

Dandy Rathtub says...
6:50pm Tue 8 Dec 09

FaceUpToIt wrote:
TirNaNog wrote:
FaceUpToIt wrote:
Old Peculiar wrote:
Macca51 wrote: For you Fritz, the market is over !
thats funny, i know funny, and thats funny !! Facuptoit - you have no idea what you are talking about ; the market was cr@p. Attending this market would not have broadened anyones horizons, whether they were from Brafud or Timbucktoo !! And of course Brafud Council are attributable to the mess, they have a responsibilty to ensure that whoever / whatever they book, are suitable. Both parties (stall holders and customers) need to be considered in this equation, but I suspect the only equation that the Councillors will have considered, will be how much extra bonus they will have been able to award themselves from booking the disasterous event.
This illustrates my point perfectly. You laugh at a borderline racist joke but do not even concede the point that the same market in any other city would have been a success. Seriously, the only thing that would get the crowds out in Bradford is a public appearance by someone like Jeremy Kyle
Get over yourself! What makes you so special Mr Intellectual? You denegrate ALL the citizens of Bradford. Met them all have you?
Nothing makes me special. I am simply saddened that most folk seem to want to blame the council (or some other scapegoat) rather than look at themselves. If people want Bradford to succeed (and I do) they have to get behind such events. Furthermore, this was a chance for people to do something different and they simply couldn't be bothered: it's not the council's fault that 'their citizens' are unmotivated and don't want to try something new. As for being intellectual, I do not consider myself to be more intellectucal than the next man: however, I do not see why being an intellectual should be a subject for humour. This is something to which we should aspire rather than knock.
Faceuptoit, or should that be Putyourheadinthesand
, I think if you read carefully, you will see that these people have actually been to the market in question, therefore they have tried to back their town. But I suppose there aren't many people (other than yourself maybe) who would put any money on a horse once the've realised it has only 3 legs.
ps : your comments about a "borderline racist joke" are pathetic, get a grip.

Mike Strutter says...
7:51pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Funny thing is that when it comes to election time next year most people on this board will vote the same dross in.
I'm a Tory and whilst I might vote for Cameron in the general election there is no way I would vote Conservative at the council elections. I won't vote Labour either.

What we need are strong local candidates to stand as independents on each ward who can come together and listen to the people of Bradford.

Until then, it will be more of the same.


webess says...
8:40pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Johsay wrote:
Kriss Hopkins, please comment.
Why should he? This event wasn't organised by him or the council. They merely rented space to a third party - Council still get the rent for the whole month.

If you wanted you could rent Centenary square and organise a blind watchmakers convention - then blame council if it didn't pan out.

All this is in the article, but you seem to have gone straight into rant mode, but don't worry there are plenty more like you..

ravacity says...
8:53pm Tue 8 Dec 09

the1bully wrote:
who are they kidding?- "gone back to Germany"- none of them are from Germany just local scally traders! what a joke. im 27 and was born in Bradford. Ive lived in Australia from 2003 up until last year and came back here whilst my new visa was processed. Bradford is a joke- only good thing is akbars! Although I have a Bradford postcode I go shopping in Leeds and spent 1hr queuing last saturday for the german market there- just to get in! and had a great night!! Im happy never to see this city ever again
why do you have a bd postcode if you hate your city so much, sooner you f**ckoff back to oz the better yer whinging shiela

finemess says...
9:00pm Tue 8 Dec 09

OK Kriss!

KCAJRETSOF says...
9:11pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Bradford has lost it's 'soul' somewhere along the line. I'n not sure it can ever get it back!

finemess says...
10:18pm Tue 8 Dec 09

webess wrote:
Johsay wrote: Kriss Hopkins, please comment.
Why should he? This event wasn't organised by him or the council. They merely rented space to a third party - Council still get the rent for the whole month. If you wanted you could rent Centenary square and organise a blind watchmakers convention - then blame council if it didn't pan out. All this is in the article, but you seem to have gone straight into rant mode, but don't worry there are plenty more like you..
You are Kriss Hopkins and I claim my £5!

Mekon says...
10:19pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Everyone knows why Bradford Center is crap and won't venture there if possible:

a: Lack of decent shops (actually any)
b: There's a dirt big hole in it
c: Its not safe
d: Leeds is minutes away

There is also a percentage of people who reside in Bradford who do not want anything to do with British owned or run shops.

The first 3 of these things can be resolved by the council and the police, but we see no evidence of it.

twell3@tiscali.co.uk says...
10:37pm Tue 8 Dec 09

Bradfords town centre is just too scary a place for me. The behaviour of young people there and at the interchange and on public transport disturbs me and leaves me petrified. I keep away. Not surprised that business has been so poor for the market traders. Suspect I'm not alone in feeling like this. Bradford just can't get on top of anti social behaviour issues and criminality linked to the drug trade.

Rambo says...
12:07am Wed 9 Dec 09

I was in York all day today, go there every few months for a day out. And not once did i see anyone drunk, or drinking in the street. Last Friday by the morrisons on Westage there were ELEVEN drunks in 3 groups there shouting abuse at people. That morning I saw 2 more steal a bottle of wine from a nearby shop.
.
I've said it so many times. People will not come to Bradford unless there are shops, jobs, nightlife and clearing the filth off the streets. Another time in the centre of York we saw the aftermath of a fight; a teenager must have been set upon by a group, and within minutes 2 police cars appeared. In Bradford city centre theyd probably give him a crime reference number and call him if there are any developments.
.
Also, I noticed in York the First Buses were cheaper - £3.70 a day ticket and £2 cheaper on the weekly one. When bradford is a much poorer, city struggling to get people to come, why more expensive?
I live a few miles outside Bradford city centre, straight road to get there, but its cheaper for me to go to Leeds at £3 that go to bradford. That is pityful.

Dr Evil says...
2:58am Wed 9 Dec 09

The fact is that the general disinterest in an event like this is largely because Bradford City Centre is no longer an inviting place. As a Shopping Experience, Bradford has very little to offer. Moreover, people are frightened to walk through the streets.

Faceuptoit is incorrect saying that the citizens have no pride in their environs; coming from Saltaire he will be aware that, on the whole, People do have pride in their individual areas over whiuch they may have some degree of influence and control.

Please do not think that all Residents of Saltaire possess such ill-founded opinions!

babafk says...
7:51am Wed 9 Dec 09

to the1bully
You are totally wrong - i happen to know four of the traders and they all came from Germany ,but some employed local living labour . the two italian bikers who ran the pizza stall also had connection with Germany . So in FUTURE check your facts before making comments

FaceUpToIt says...
8:04am Wed 9 Dec 09

Dr Evil wrote:
The fact is that the general disinterest in an event like this is largely because Bradford City Centre is no longer an inviting place. As a Shopping Experience, Bradford has very little to offer. Moreover, people are frightened to walk through the streets.

Faceuptoit is incorrect saying that the citizens have no pride in their environs; coming from Saltaire he will be aware that, on the whole, People do have pride in their individual areas over whiuch they may have some degree of influence and control.

Please do not think that all Residents of Saltaire possess such ill-founded opinions!
Oh come now. Do you honestly think that Saltaire is a microcosm of the city as a whole? Nobody stopped the citizens of Bradford from attending other than themselves - fact. Therefore, they have to be willing to accept some of the blame for this debacle. It's all too easy to look for someone else to blame - that's one thing we're all good at: but if we get stuck in the trap of always blaming someone else, this city will never recover. Let's have some honesty here.

thecitygent says...
8:49am Wed 9 Dec 09

I went down to the German market for a sausage at 5pm on Saturday and was surprised to see that many of the stalls were already closed. There were no sausages on offer (only pizza) but more to the point no people. As I walked down Ivegate I asked myself what the German traders would make of Bradford and maybe if the Bradford councillors stood back and asked themselves the same question of what a stranger would make to our city they might be surprised. Bradford is fast becoming unrecognisable to its residents and frankly it is depressing to walk through the city centre - discount stores, countless aliens (yes, let's be blunt about it) and a generally run down feel about the place. The reason that I don't go into the city centre much is that having tried to support Bradford shops until around five years ago I realised that it was futile and I was wasting my time. Like many others I don't go into Bradford because it depresses me and makes me sad to see what has happened to a city that I grew up in. Would I encourage my teenage children to go into town on their own? Am I proud of my city and many of its inhabitants? (Again, let's be blunt about it and start facing the facts.) The German traders have only confirmed what most Bradford people have known for some time - credit to them for staying so long. As for Christmas markets, why don't we acknowledge that the majority muslim population of central Bradford have no interest in such. Bradford has lost it and for too long we have clung to a dream that the city could be regenerated or stand up and be compared as a self-respecting centre. From my experience of other towns and cities in England I would say that Bradford no more than a larger version of Accrington.

Patrick Bateman says...
8:50am Wed 9 Dec 09

Macca51 wrote:
For you Fritz, the market is over !
Very funny gag, sir! This kept me chuckling all day!

dadada says...
8:51am Wed 9 Dec 09

As previous people have commented Bradford HAS lost its soul,the large muslim population has diluted our way of life most of them and by them i mean muslims have no intrest in the british culture or way of life and Bradfords white population have to a large extent given up on there city its now a terrible place to live thanks to mass immigration.

Bantam58 says...
9:02am Wed 9 Dec 09

FaceUpToIt wrote:
Old Peculiar wrote:
Macca51 wrote: For you Fritz, the market is over !
thats funny, i know funny, and thats funny !! Facuptoit - you have no idea what you are talking about ; the market was cr@p. Attending this market would not have broadened anyones horizons, whether they were from Brafud or Timbucktoo !! And of course Brafud Council are attributable to the mess, they have a responsibilty to ensure that whoever / whatever they book, are suitable. Both parties (stall holders and customers) need to be considered in this equation, but I suspect the only equation that the Councillors will have considered, will be how much extra bonus they will have been able to award themselves from booking the disasterous event.
This illustrates my point perfectly. You laugh at a borderline racist joke but do not even concede the point that the same market in any other city would have been a success. Seriously, the only thing that would get the crowds out in Bradford is a public appearance by someone like Jeremy Kyle
CRAP. that market would not have been a success ANYWHERE, if the people of Bradford upset you so much then go live in a model village somewhere else

thecitygent says...
9:07am Wed 9 Dec 09

Economists tell us that mass immigration has brought net gains to the UK. I don't believe that any academic has attempted to demonstrate that the same has applied in Bradford but I would be interested to see if an objective, detailed analysis is able to contradict what I believe based on what I see. No doubt the thought police will tell me otherwise. In terms of our beloved councillors I believe that we are naive to think that they can do much. For a start how many competent people would put themselves forward to serve as a councillor in Bradford? As a consequence many of our councillors are second rate individuals who would probably never make it in a commercial or even public sector organisation. I don't know what the answer is although I am tempted to suggest erecting a massive wall around the centre of the city. I would suggest direct rule from London as the better option - heaven forbid we go down the route of a locally elected mayor for example, the prospect of which is terrifying.

FaceUpToIt says...
9:20am Wed 9 Dec 09

dadada wrote:
As previous people have commented Bradford HAS lost its soul,the large muslim population has diluted our way of life most of them and by them i mean muslims have no intrest in the british culture or way of life and Bradfords white population have to a large extent given up on there city its now a terrible place to live thanks to mass immigration.
Ladies and gentlemen, I rest my case.

Dr Evil says...
9:26am Wed 9 Dec 09

FaceUpToIt wrote:
Dr Evil wrote: The fact is that the general disinterest in an event like this is largely because Bradford City Centre is no longer an inviting place. As a Shopping Experience, Bradford has very little to offer. Moreover, people are frightened to walk through the streets. Faceuptoit is incorrect saying that the citizens have no pride in their environs; coming from Saltaire he will be aware that, on the whole, People do have pride in their individual areas over whiuch they may have some degree of influence and control. Please do not think that all Residents of Saltaire possess such ill-founded opinions!
Oh come now. Do you honestly think that Saltaire is a microcosm of the city as a whole? Nobody stopped the citizens of Bradford from attending other than themselves - fact. Therefore, they have to be willing to accept some of the blame for this debacle. It's all too easy to look for someone else to blame - that's one thing we're all good at: but if we get stuck in the trap of always blaming someone else, this city will never recover. Let's have some honesty here.
Purrely out of interest; did Faceuptoit attend the German Market himself?

silverrain says...
9:26am Wed 9 Dec 09

dadada wrote:
As previous people have commented Bradford HAS lost its soul,the large muslim population has diluted our way of life most of them and by them i mean muslims have no intrest in the british culture or way of life and Bradfords white population have to a large extent given up on there city its now a terrible place to live thanks to mass immigration.
How can you blame the Muslim community for the down fall of the shops in Bradford? I am a Muslim but have to go to Leeds or Manchester to find the shops i am loooking for and they are not the ones that sell asian clothes. Bradford needs more of the high street range..its not a case of people not wanting to spend..its more people not finding what they want..i have to go to leeds to find our closet H&M...maybe our council need to find a way to entice the good shops back to Bradford? When Foster Square opened that took a lot of the attention away from the city centre...it's eaiser to go to the retail park to get Outfit and Next and there is no need to walk in to the centre. It's our Council that brought on the death of the centre...as someone mentioned before we used to have some great shops and i used to look forward to going in to town. I have been to the christmas market in manchester, which by the way is located close to the central shopping area, and they had a very wide range of festive goods available..i went to the market here and most of it was food or things you could buy in the local pound shop. Mass immigration has nothing to dowith what has happened to our town centre and if you get your facts right most of the immigrants that are coming here now are not muslims. Bradford is a terrible place to live because the council have not made the right decisions on where to spend the money and which areas to regenerate...why do we need a lake in the centre? 1inch of rain and the area gets flooded anyway!! this is not a race/religion issue but has more to do with how our city is being run and what is being done to bring business here.

thecitygent says...
9:39am Wed 9 Dec 09

Mass immigration in Bradford has imported poverty. How can decent shops survive without critical volumes of consumers? The economic benefit of immigration is through economic participation and yet in Bradford's case it is entirely the opposite. Bradford's economy has been depressed by immigration - it has hardly boosted consumer spending in the city. Furthermore mass immigration has only served to alienate the indigenous white population who have voted with their feet and deserted the city. Hence Bradford is in a downward spiral of a low-wage economy and a dwindling commercial base. In turn Bradford Council is stuck with a declining revenue base upon which to levy its rates and which have become punitive as a result. Maybe we should twin with Chicago, Bradford is Sink City 2. You can't blame retailers or the German traders for not staying in Bradford. As for our decision makers, the lack of an open, honest debate about what has happened in Bradford and about what people think has been nothing short of criminal. The reason is hasn't happened is that there is fear about what people - myself and no doubt other contributors to this board included - would say.

thecitygent says...
9:45am Wed 9 Dec 09

silverrain wrote:
dadada wrote: As previous people have commented Bradford HAS lost its soul,the large muslim population has diluted our way of life most of them and by them i mean muslims have no intrest in the british culture or way of life and Bradfords white population have to a large extent given up on there city its now a terrible place to live thanks to mass immigration.
How can you blame the Muslim community for the down fall of the shops in Bradford? I am a Muslim but have to go to Leeds or Manchester to find the shops i am loooking for and they are not the ones that sell asian clothes. Bradford needs more of the high street range..its not a case of people not wanting to spend..its more people not finding what they want..i have to go to leeds to find our closet H&M...maybe our council need to find a way to entice the good shops back to Bradford? When Foster Square opened that took a lot of the attention away from the city centre...it's eaiser to go to the retail park to get Outfit and Next and there is no need to walk in to the centre. It's our Council that brought on the death of the centre...as someone mentioned before we used to have some great shops and i used to look forward to going in to town. I have been to the christmas market in manchester, which by the way is located close to the central shopping area, and they had a very wide range of festive goods available..i went to the market here and most of it was food or things you could buy in the local pound shop. Mass immigration has nothing to dowith what has happened to our town centre and if you get your facts right most of the immigrants that are coming here now are not muslims. Bradford is a terrible place to live because the council have not made the right decisions on where to spend the money and which areas to regenerate...why do we need a lake in the centre? 1inch of rain and the area gets flooded anyway!! this is not a race/religion issue but has more to do with how our city is being run and what is being done to bring business here.
I am all for encouraging Poles and other east Europeans to Bradford because they have provided a filip to the economy. If you want to be specific about 'mass immigration' and the benefits thereof I make a clear distinction. It is the Kashmiri Muslims who represent a dead weight on the local economy. As you are aware they have represented the vast majority of mass immigrants to this city and are unlikely to be overtaken by any other ethnic grouping.

silverrain says...
9:50am Wed 9 Dec 09

i would welcome an open debate..but many people especially on here seem to see that as an invitation to attack certain groups/races/religio
ns. The council and the so called 'pc brigade' make things worse for ethnic groups by doing things so that they 'dont hurt feelings'. I and i'm sure many other musllims/immigrants understand that you live by the rules of the country you live in. I love Christmas time as does my daughter..we dont celebrate but we still have a tree so that she doesnt feel left out. Bradford has always had a muslim population but I agree that we have never had such a problem with crime and bad relations between the communities. We need better policing and criminals should get what they deserve no matter what colour they are and the police shouldnt be afraid of challenging these groups. its the small group of narrow minded people that ruin things for the majority, this can be said about muslims and non muslims. Lets start a debate on how immigration of East European peole started more begging on our streets..people knocking on your door and handing a small paper telling you about how they have no money..lets start a debate about how teenagers can leave school/college/unive
rsity and start caiming job seekers straight away...

silverrain says...
9:53am Wed 9 Dec 09

@thecityagent..poles
? and east europeans? what have they brought to our city? please explain...

thecitygent says...
10:09am Wed 9 Dec 09

My observations: (i) local employers have expressed positive feedback over their work ethic, particularly younger people and I have seen this first hand; (ii) there would appear to have been much more of a hunger to learn the language and assimilate (not just economically integrate) as compared to the lumpen mass from Pakistan; and (iii) if mass immigration is inevitable I would prefer people from a Judaeo-Christian western background who have more in common with the indigenous population. A final point is that many of these younger Poles/Baltic state nationals have come here on a short-term basis and are not putting down permanent roots and inviting over their extended families to join them. What kind of immigrants would you encourage???

thecitygent says...
10:12am Wed 9 Dec 09

silverrain wrote:
i would welcome an open debate..but many people especially on here seem to see that as an invitation to attack certain groups/races/religio ns. The council and the so called 'pc brigade' make things worse for ethnic groups by doing things so that they 'dont hurt feelings'. I and i'm sure many other musllims/immigrants understand that you live by the rules of the country you live in. I love Christmas time as does my daughter..we dont celebrate but we still have a tree so that she doesnt feel left out. Bradford has always had a muslim population but I agree that we have never had such a problem with crime and bad relations between the communities. We need better policing and criminals should get what they deserve no matter what colour they are and the police shouldnt be afraid of challenging these groups. its the small group of narrow minded people that ruin things for the majority, this can be said about muslims and non muslims. Lets start a debate on how immigration of East European peole started more begging on our streets..people knocking on your door and handing a small paper telling you about how they have no money..lets start a debate about how teenagers can leave school/college/unive rsity and start caiming job seekers straight away...
Interesting that you 'tolerate' xmas. Having attended my daughter's recent nativity play at her school - at which approx 30% of the pupils are Pakistani origin - it was disappointing that the attendance and participation in the event was relatively poor and that our Muslim neighbours did not feel able to support the event which is a key date on the school calendar.

FaceUpToIt says...
10:43am Wed 9 Dec 09

Dr Evil wrote:
FaceUpToIt wrote:
Dr Evil wrote: The fact is that the general disinterest in an event like this is largely because Bradford City Centre is no longer an inviting place. As a Shopping Experience, Bradford has very little to offer. Moreover, people are frightened to walk through the streets. Faceuptoit is incorrect saying that the citizens have no pride in their environs; coming from Saltaire he will be aware that, on the whole, People do have pride in their individual areas over whiuch they may have some degree of influence and control. Please do not think that all Residents of Saltaire possess such ill-founded opinions!
Oh come now. Do you honestly think that Saltaire is a microcosm of the city as a whole? Nobody stopped the citizens of Bradford from attending other than themselves - fact. Therefore, they have to be willing to accept some of the blame for this debacle. It's all too easy to look for someone else to blame - that's one thing we're all good at: but if we get stuck in the trap of always blaming someone else, this city will never recover. Let's have some honesty here.
Purrely out of interest; did Faceuptoit attend the German Market himself?
Yes, three times. And to Bantam58 who said the Market would have failed anywhere, I would point to the successful German market in Leeds and also to the likes of the Saltaire Festival and the continental market in Ilkley.

Exbradfordian says...
11:07am Wed 9 Dec 09

It's sad that every discussion in this forum descends into the same discussion. It must be the fault of all the non-white residents because we were here first and everything was utopia in the good old days. Let's face it Bradford is in decline - everyone should work together to improve things.

FaceUpToIt says...
11:10am Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
It's sad that every discussion in this forum descends into the same discussion. It must be the fault of all the non-white residents because we were here first and everything was utopia in the good old days. Let's face it Bradford is in decline - everyone should work together to improve things.
100% spot on

thecitygent says...
11:13am Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
It's sad that every discussion in this forum descends into the same discussion. It must be the fault of all the non-white residents because we were here first and everything was utopia in the good old days. Let's face it Bradford is in decline - everyone should work together to improve things.
Pretty easy for exbradfordian to say from afar! When you write the cheque in payment of council tax to BMDC in puts quite a few issues into sharp relief. Have you considered returning to Bradford to help improve things?

Exbradfordian says...
11:25am Wed 9 Dec 09

citygent I come back frequently and always shop locally and use the city centre. Can't return on a permanent basis though as my job won't allow me to. I travel quite a lot for my job accross England and one of the most segragated places I have come accross is Bradford. That is the biggest problem in my opinion.

thecitygent says...
11:31am Wed 9 Dec 09

FaceUpToIt wrote:
Bradford is a cultural blackhole - full of those who are more interested in cramming their faces with ready meals, watching ITV and breeding dangerous dogs. I'm afraid this is symptomatic of Bradford's lack of ambition. We are reaping what we've sown.
Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!

thecitygent says...
11:36am Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
citygent I come back frequently and always shop locally and use the city centre. Can't return on a permanent basis though as my job won't allow me to. I travel quite a lot for my job accross England and one of the most segragated places I have come accross is Bradford. That is the biggest problem in my opinion.
There is physical segregation and mental segregation. How do you propose tackling it? Live in Manningham perhaps and preach on the streets? It would be the acid test whether you would return to Bfd on a permanent basis wouldn't it. Easy to preach from afar.

albion says...
11:37am Wed 9 Dec 09

FaceUpToIt wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote:
It's sad that every discussion in this forum descends into the same discussion. It must be the fault of all the non-white residents because we were here first and everything was utopia in the good old days. Let's face it Bradford is in decline - everyone should work together to improve things.
100% spot on
The riots and the slow but inevitable change to society is in my opinion the main reason why Bradfords decline is beyond recovery, no matter how you alter the structural components the damage has been done and is likely to be repeated as given inches lead to taken miles and more demands.
When you look at other towns and cities it strikes me that any quality retail outlet would be unwise to locate here.

Exbradfordian says...
11:49am Wed 9 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote: citygent I come back frequently and always shop locally and use the city centre. Can't return on a permanent basis though as my job won't allow me to. I travel quite a lot for my job accross England and one of the most segragated places I have come accross is Bradford. That is the biggest problem in my opinion.
There is physical segregation and mental segregation. How do you propose tackling it? Live in Manningham perhaps and preach on the streets? It would be the acid test whether you would return to Bfd on a permanent basis wouldn't it. Easy to preach from afar.
Thankfully not all people living in Bradford think like you. But it is a challenge and unless it is addressed then nothing will change. As to whether I live there or not is irrelevant. You do if you are happy as things are then good luck to you - but from the sound of it you are not. But you are happy to blame others. What do you think should be done - send back all the non-whites to their country of origin. The sooner you accept it ain't gonna happen the sooner you will start accepting the world we live in.

silverrain says...
11:49am Wed 9 Dec 09

@cityagent how can you say these east european immigrants have come here short term and will not base their roots here? the majority of the queues at the job centre are east europeans...the masses in town at lunch time just loitering around are east europeans, people used to complain that muslims had large families...just take a look around at how large east european families are. They bring nothing to bradfords economy...builders who take cash in hand..street sellers...you really think they pay their taxes???...you seem to find it easy to pick on the muslims just remember that it was the mass immigration of muslims/hindus was brought in to help with the huge boom in industry so dont blame them when everything goes in to decline...its just as easy for me to pick on the east europeans...how many of them turned up to your nativity?

thecitygent says...
11:52am Wed 9 Dec 09

albion wrote:
FaceUpToIt wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote: It's sad that every discussion in this forum descends into the same discussion. It must be the fault of all the non-white residents because we were here first and everything was utopia in the good old days. Let's face it Bradford is in decline - everyone should work together to improve things.
100% spot on
The riots and the slow but inevitable change to society is in my opinion the main reason why Bradfords decline is beyond recovery, no matter how you alter the structural components the damage has been done and is likely to be repeated as given inches lead to taken miles and more demands. When you look at other towns and cities it strikes me that any quality retail outlet would be unwise to locate here.
Difficult to disagree and many residents have already come to that conclusion which is why Bradford is the 'cultural backwater' that Professor Faceuptoit describes. Whilst Bradford has never been a utopia its decline has accelerated in the last ten years. The question is how to draw a line in the sand and prevent further decline. In the context of the economic conditions this is a mighty ask and which needs some brave decisions. The future for the district is worrying.

FaceUpToIt says...
11:52am Wed 9 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
FaceUpToIt wrote: Bradford is a cultural blackhole - full of those who are more interested in cramming their faces with ready meals, watching ITV and breeding dangerous dogs. I'm afraid this is symptomatic of Bradford's lack of ambition. We are reaping what we've sown.
Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!
It's not about being loved ;-) But I think you have hit upon the real drain on society in Bradford... 'Carrying' the chavs isn't going to fix Bradford

thecitygent says...
12:00pm Wed 9 Dec 09

silverrain wrote:
@cityagent how can you say these east european immigrants have come here short term and will not base their roots here? the majority of the queues at the job centre are east europeans...the masses in town at lunch time just loitering around are east europeans, people used to complain that muslims had large families...just take a look around at how large east european families are. They bring nothing to bradfords economy...builders who take cash in hand..street sellers...you really think they pay their taxes???...you seem to find it easy to pick on the muslims just remember that it was the mass immigration of muslims/hindus was brought in to help with the huge boom in industry so dont blame them when everything goes in to decline...its just as easy for me to pick on the east europeans...how many of them turned up to your nativity?
The vast majority of mass immigration to this city came subsequent to the textile 'boom' of the late 50s and 60s. Pakistanis represent by far the biggest ethnic minority in the city and will continue to do so but please tell me what contribution the mass of peasants in their tribal gear (and without command of the English language) contribute to the local economy and tell me the secret of those young Pakistanis in their flash cars. What economy do they participate in?

thecitygent says...
12:10pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
thecitygent wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote: citygent I come back frequently and always shop locally and use the city centre. Can't return on a permanent basis though as my job won't allow me to. I travel quite a lot for my job accross England and one of the most segragated places I have come accross is Bradford. That is the biggest problem in my opinion.
There is physical segregation and mental segregation. How do you propose tackling it? Live in Manningham perhaps and preach on the streets? It would be the acid test whether you would return to Bfd on a permanent basis wouldn't it. Easy to preach from afar.
Thankfully not all people living in Bradford think like you. But it is a challenge and unless it is addressed then nothing will change. As to whether I live there or not is irrelevant. You do if you are happy as things are then good luck to you - but from the sound of it you are not. But you are happy to blame others. What do you think should be done - send back all the non-whites to their country of origin. The sooner you accept it ain't gonna happen the sooner you will start accepting the world we live in.
The vast majority of people who think like me have left the city in frustration. I am committed to remain because I have a business here but if you think that my thinking is unique you are mistaken! I am not blaming others I am merely highlighting themes that have exacerbated the problem. I cannot offer an easy fix to Bradford's issues because there isn't one but yes I do know that it is not about giving people a one-way ticket to somewhere else. I like Bradford as home but I won't pretend anything other than despair to see what has become of it and the people who inhabit it. Of course you don't have that on a daily basis and you have the luxury of preaching to others from afar. Try putting your money where your mouth is and become a Bradford ratepayer!

Exbradfordian says...
12:23pm Wed 9 Dec 09

It's sad that every discussion in this forum descends into the same discussion. It must be the fault of all the non-white residents because we were here first and everything was utopia in the good old days. Let's face it Bradford is in decline - everyone should work together to improve things.

Need I say more!

thecitygent says...
12:28pm Wed 9 Dec 09

You are the one with the stuck record. But then, when you don't live here anymore it is easier to offer patronising observations. Come back we need people like you with a commitment to Bradford and superior knowledge of how to get things fixed.

Exbradfordian says...
12:47pm Wed 9 Dec 09

that's not very nice - but i guess the truth hurts. Why take responsibility yourself when you came blame others. And what the heck does it matter what anyone wears. How small minded you must be.

Spanishbob19 says...
12:57pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
citygent I come back frequently and always shop locally and use the city centre. Can't return on a permanent basis though as my job won't allow me to. I travel quite a lot for my job accross England and one of the most segragated places I have come accross is Bradford. That is the biggest problem in my opinion.
I also travel to many other towns and,whilst I slightly agree, segregation in Bradford is not down to the ethnich group that is treated as the minority (white british) it is down to others.

I dont particularly think the failure of the German market is down to a race / cultural issue, it is plain that the town centre is a dump and people are not happy shopping there, because the available shops are rubbish.

As I said earlier I chose to go to Lincoln Christmas market, because I knew it would be good, the town centre was fully open and had many quality named shops to go in, if you wished, and it was a fun day out.

Compare this to the hole that is called Bradford. The council have ensured that the residents of Bradford shop outside of the town centre and whilst they do this for 50 weeks of the year, what is going to draw them into the town for a couple of weeks?

thecitygent says...
12:58pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
that's not very nice - but i guess the truth hurts. Why take responsibility yourself when you came blame others. And what the heck does it matter what anyone wears. How small minded you must be.
Ooooh!!! so you can't be persuaded to come home and provide the leadership that the city needs? Read my posts, I am not blaming others - I am highlighting the unescapable fact that Bradford's social and ethnic mix has only served to exacerbate a spiral of decline and which is probably now impossible to reverse. Too late to turn back the clock. However let's celebrate the multi-cultural heritage of our city!

Exbradfordian says...
1:09pm Wed 9 Dec 09

"Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!"

So this is not blaming others.

I guess I must be mistaken then - had Bradford been left alone without immigration then it would be a little Shangri-La.

thecitygent says...
1:27pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
"Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!" So this is not blaming others. I guess I must be mistaken then - had Bradford been left alone without immigration then it would be a little Shangri-La.
Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you. What I do know from my understanding of the history of Bradford is that one of the reasons for poor educational attainment in Bradford (that Prof Faceuptoit alludes to) is that few people with the means or ability to do something for the city chose to move out at the first opportunity (ie Ilkley, Harrogate et al). The situation we are in now is a direct legacy of that. Equally no-one in power has had the willingness to deal with hard decisions - the Ray Honeyford case being a good example. Whilst Bradford has always been a city of immigrants the more recent wave of mass immigration has not done it any favours and has only served to import poverty into an already impoversihed low wage economy city. Hence we have a city of marginalised people from the ghettoes of Holme Wood to those in Manningham/central Bradford without the skills or abilities to add value to the local economy and give it a chance to reverse decline. But then you know it all.

silverrain says...
1:29pm Wed 9 Dec 09

@cityagent...the secret of the young pakistanis with flash cars is usually their parents money!! and whats wrong with traditional dress...the only part of the pakistani muslim community that dont speak english is the 1st generation, there wasnt an emphasis on education when they arrived in this country. Places like Bombay Stores, Mumtaz, the shopping area on White Abbey Road etc bring in many visitors from outside of Bradford. You cant blame one community for the downfall of Bradford..

silverrain says...
1:29pm Wed 9 Dec 09

@cityagent...the secret of the young pakistanis with flash cars is usually their parents money!! and whats wrong with traditional dress...the only part of the pakistani muslim community that dont speak english is the 1st generation, there wasnt an emphasis on education when they arrived in this country. Places like Bombay Stores, Mumtaz, the shopping area on White Abbey Road etc bring in many visitors from outside of Bradford. You cant blame one community for the downfall of Bradford..

Exbradfordian says...
1:32pm Wed 9 Dec 09

thecitygent - apologies if I have misinterpreted your rants about chavs and peasants in tribal gear as you blaming others for the downfall of Bradford.

I didn't know you were an expert on social and ecomic regeneration to be able to comment on whether there was any hope for Bradford.

Rambo says...
1:44pm Wed 9 Dec 09

"Places like Bombay Stores, Mumtaz, the shopping area on White Abbey Road etc bring in many visitors from outside of Bradford"
.
Many visitors? Really?
I wouldn't really liken the "shopping area on White Abbey Road" to the Trafford Centre.

thecitygent says...
1:52pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Everyone in Bradford is waiting for your return to the city you care so passionately about to provide the leadership and inspiration that it needs. Come and join the lucky club of Bradford council tax payers instead of restricting us to your mutterings from afar.

Exbradfordian says...
1:54pm Wed 9 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote: "Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!" So this is not blaming others. I guess I must be mistaken then - had Bradford been left alone without immigration then it would be a little Shangri-La.
Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you. What I do know from my understanding of the history of Bradford is that one of the reasons for poor educational attainment in Bradford (that Prof Faceuptoit alludes to) is that few people with the means or ability to do something for the city chose to move out at the first opportunity (ie Ilkley, Harrogate et al). The situation we are in now is a direct legacy of that. Equally no-one in power has had the willingness to deal with hard decisions - the Ray Honeyford case being a good example. Whilst Bradford has always been a city of immigrants the more recent wave of mass immigration has not done it any favours and has only served to import poverty into an already impoversihed low wage economy city. Hence we have a city of marginalised people from the ghettoes of Holme Wood to those in Manningham/central Bradford without the skills or abilities to add value to the local economy and give it a chance to reverse decline. But then you know it all.
"Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you."

(Yawn) you have made this point several times now - stop sounding like a stuck record please. Whether I live in Bradford or not is irrelevant - I left because my job moved - full stop.

I think you will find that other factors such as closure of industries has had more of an influence. And actually if individuals weren't mobile and moved to where the jobs were we may well have a worse problem in Bradford.

thecitygent says...
2:08pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
thecitygent wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote: "Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!" So this is not blaming others. I guess I must be mistaken then - had Bradford been left alone without immigration then it would be a little Shangri-La.
Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you. What I do know from my understanding of the history of Bradford is that one of the reasons for poor educational attainment in Bradford (that Prof Faceuptoit alludes to) is that few people with the means or ability to do something for the city chose to move out at the first opportunity (ie Ilkley, Harrogate et al). The situation we are in now is a direct legacy of that. Equally no-one in power has had the willingness to deal with hard decisions - the Ray Honeyford case being a good example. Whilst Bradford has always been a city of immigrants the more recent wave of mass immigration has not done it any favours and has only served to import poverty into an already impoversihed low wage economy city. Hence we have a city of marginalised people from the ghettoes of Holme Wood to those in Manningham/central Bradford without the skills or abilities to add value to the local economy and give it a chance to reverse decline. But then you know it all.
"Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you." (Yawn) you have made this point several times now - stop sounding like a stuck record please. Whether I live in Bradford or not is irrelevant - I left because my job moved - full stop. I think you will find that other factors such as closure of industries has had more of an influence. And actually if individuals weren't mobile and moved to where the jobs were we may well have a worse problem in Bradford.
Most economies renew themselves in some form and those who can rely upon a high level of skills, the availability of capital and strong levels of economic participation normally flourish and in turn generate the most wealth. Bradford's problem was not so much the loss of staple industries as the fact that there were few replacements (combined also with restricted industrial land). Contrast the economy of Leicester with that of Bradford, two cities that had mass immigration and two cities that faced the decline of traditional industries. Why did Leicester succeed in relative terms whilst Bradford failed? Was it the mercantile background of the East African Indians perhaps? Was it the relative skill base of its immigrants? Bradford's recent experience of mass immigration has not done it any favours and has only served to import poverty. Fact. And without local wealth generation what chance does the local retail base stand and what chance the success of its xmas market? Whilst Bradford has been in decline for some time (as you yourself recognise) its socio-ethnic mix has not done it any favours. It wasn't the cause of decline but it has certainly contributed to it and made it more difficult to reverse. But of course if you lived here you might see for yourself ;)

Kevin Costner says...
2:21pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Phew I'm glad I live in Keighley, It's a much better place to live. It's clean, the people are positive and we all live in harmony. Well we will do once we boot Ann Cryer and her little army of pretend political soldiers out next year.

giveover says...
2:57pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Pakistanis are in flash leased cars so when they get busted for drugs and the car is confiscated they have lost nothing.

thecitygent says...
2:59pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Exbradfordian wrote:
thecitygent wrote:
Exbradfordian wrote: "Compulsory education on the cards if you get elected? The chavs in the shell suits and the peasants in the tribal gear are going to love you!" So this is not blaming others. I guess I must be mistaken then - had Bradford been left alone without immigration then it would be a little Shangri-La.
Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you. What I do know from my understanding of the history of Bradford is that one of the reasons for poor educational attainment in Bradford (that Prof Faceuptoit alludes to) is that few people with the means or ability to do something for the city chose to move out at the first opportunity (ie Ilkley, Harrogate et al). The situation we are in now is a direct legacy of that. Equally no-one in power has had the willingness to deal with hard decisions - the Ray Honeyford case being a good example. Whilst Bradford has always been a city of immigrants the more recent wave of mass immigration has not done it any favours and has only served to import poverty into an already impoversihed low wage economy city. Hence we have a city of marginalised people from the ghettoes of Holme Wood to those in Manningham/central Bradford without the skills or abilities to add value to the local economy and give it a chance to reverse decline. But then you know it all.
"Whatever you want to say(yawn) - clearly Bradford wasn't /isn't sufficient of a shangri-la for you." (Yawn) you have made this point several times now - stop sounding like a stuck record please. Whether I live in Bradford or not is irrelevant - I left because my job moved - full stop. I think you will find that other factors such as closure of industries has had more of an influence. And actually if individuals weren't mobile and moved to where the jobs were we may well have a worse problem in Bradford.
Sorry, must go... earn money to pay Bradford rates etc. I hope that your boss hasn't seen you spending all your time on the message board or you'll lose your job and maybe even have to return to Bradford - just when you thought that you'd escaped. Turn the lights on when you drive up the 606 and dust off the shell suit!!

thecitygent says...
3:00pm Wed 9 Dec 09

giveover wrote:
Pakistanis are in flash leased cars so when they get busted for drugs and the car is confiscated they have lost nothing.
No - they are paid for by hard earned graft and supported by their parents. It says so further up this message board so it must be true!!!

albion says...
3:19pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Kevin Costner wrote:
Phew I'm glad I live in Keighley, It's a much better place to live. It's clean, the people are positive and we all live in harmony. Well we will do once we boot Ann Cryer and her little army of pretend political soldiers out next year.
Yes I agree, its very harmonious down Lawkholme Lane of an evening.

moosejaw says...
5:11pm Wed 9 Dec 09

given the volume of contributions and feelings voiced, the so-called 'communities' of the city are evidently annoyed, frustrated and at odds with all, so pessimism stands above all. Down beat apathy is for many the norm and divisions will therefore persist and deepen. Retail attractions are not the solution to endemic poverty, prejudice and underachievment. The political class need to actively listen and take actions, working with us first rather than at arms length via consultative chains of executive 'thinkers'. That said, the hearts and minds of many 'communities' need to abandon selfish and insular minds that take but do not give back or participate. Compromise and fair minded exchange is partly how thriving societies grow, e.g. see toronto, canada, for an interesting example, so City Hall are you prepared to be brave and lead? because the cauldron of despair is already very real and corrosive...

Hockens Hey says...
12:59pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Was in Liverpool last night.

They had pretty much an identical Christmas market to the one we had, selling odds and ends, some decent stuff some tat.

It was packed. And I had a great evening looking round the city centre.

It's not the market, it's the city.

Now, Liverpool have two world famous successful sports clubs, which bring the crowds in - there were loads of Fiorentina fans walking about - something that Bradford hasn't had for most of this decade and probably never will. But they also have a fantastic new shopping centre with high quality shops you actually want to visit - Debenhams, Habitat, Flannels etc and lots of great restaurants with a choice of food.

It's not that long ago that Liverpool centre was a dive, but they have a rich cultural and sporting history to build on. Bradford's cultural heritage has been destroyed by a series of councils, which continues now with the Odeon fiasco. The only sporting club capable of bringing worldwide attention to the city in a mainstream sport - the world's most popular- is on its knees.

I'd love to see a vibrant city centre worth spending the day in, like Manchester, Liverpool or even Leeds but I think we're too far gone. The riots - no sentence is long enough for those that have given our city several life sentences - the decline of our high profile sports clubs and the destruction of our heritage in stone and mortar and the ineptitude of the council with the hole in the heart seems too big a slump to come back from.

I hope someone comes along to prove me wrong.

albion says...
2:49pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Hockens Hey wrote:
Was in Liverpool last night.

They had pretty much an identical Christmas market to the one we had, selling odds and ends, some decent stuff some tat.

It was packed. And I had a great evening looking round the city centre.

It's not the market, it's the city.

Now, Liverpool have two world famous successful sports clubs, which bring the crowds in - there were loads of Fiorentina fans walking about - something that Bradford hasn't had for most of this decade and probably never will. But they also have a fantastic new shopping centre with high quality shops you actually want to visit - Debenhams, Habitat, Flannels etc and lots of great restaurants with a choice of food.

It's not that long ago that Liverpool centre was a dive, but they have a rich cultural and sporting history to build on. Bradford's cultural heritage has been destroyed by a series of councils, which continues now with the Odeon fiasco. The only sporting club capable of bringing worldwide attention to the city in a mainstream sport - the world's most popular- is on its knees.

I'd love to see a vibrant city centre worth spending the day in, like Manchester, Liverpool or even Leeds but I think we're too far gone. The riots - no sentence is long enough for those that have given our city several life sentences - the decline of our high profile sports clubs and the destruction of our heritage in stone and mortar and the ineptitude of the council with the hole in the heart seems too big a slump to come back from.

I hope someone comes along to prove me wrong.
They wont!

Jammy2010 says...
3:25pm Thu 10 Dec 09

I read one comment that said "it would be packed if they sold halal"
which kind of insinuates that only muslims spend money in Bradford. Which in itself is kind of a double slap, on non muslims. They are spending money in a city non muslims refuse to?
I disagree with the comment in its entirety.

The weather does not help but there are more than a couple of reasons the market did not work.

In my opinion the market was shoddy and the people of Bradford dont spend money on c,r,a,p.

And Bradford has the highest 16-24 population in the UK, and they are not into the German Market rubbish.

And lastly riots, im old enough to remember how the police treated asians pre-riots and its a hell of a change. I think people in their frustration of seeing police deal with asians are closet racists because they feel that when johnny foreigner was scared of the hosts and their police force the country was better!
Blame your racism not the riots!
I was racing an asian lad, well i say racing but i just wasnt allowing him to over take, anyway he over took and then slowed down and i was right on his tail, the police car came behind us, looked at me, then over took him and pulled him over.

I was relieved but it just goes to show that no matter how serene the swan looks, his feet are still splashing like mad under neath!

webess says...
3:28pm Thu 10 Dec 09

See nobody's noticed a near identical situation in Wakefield. German market there, also run by CB has packed up.

Main difference seems to be that the people of Wakefield aren't gloating over it..

albion says...
3:31pm Thu 10 Dec 09

"they feel that when johnny foreigner was scared of the hosts and their police force the country was better!"
It was!

Storck says...
4:18pm Thu 10 Dec 09

The Wakefield market was closed on the instructions of the council. Wish we could have a council that made decisions rather than just letting things slide.

webess says...
4:45pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Storck wrote:
The Wakefield market was closed on the instructions of the council. Wish we could have a council that made decisions rather than just letting things slide.
Have you ever heard of pushed before you jump??

Jammy2010 says...
5:14pm Thu 10 Dec 09

albion wrote:
"they feel that when johnny foreigner was scared of the hosts and their police force the country was better!" It was!
It wasnt!

The British arent as hated as much as they were, infact i can probably walk in most european countries without getting set upon.

Unlike you Albion i like to travel, i have overseas investments and businesses, and ill tell you something now WE are the most hated, us Brits, not because we are handsome, not because we smell nice, not because we are good hosts but because we have a repuation as under handed arrogant, pull the rug under ya, hooligans.
Grow up, there are 10% non whites in England, they live in 60k houses earning 9k a year!
One white banker earns 100 million a year!
It shows how stupid the general population is when the economic times are bad they send stories in the press about immigration and terrorism.
DONT YOU GET IT YOU IDIOT?

thecitygent says...
5:23pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Jammy2010 wrote:
albion wrote: "they feel that when johnny foreigner was scared of the hosts and their police force the country was better!" It was!
It wasnt! The British arent as hated as much as they were, infact i can probably walk in most european countries without getting set upon. Unlike you Albion i like to travel, i have overseas investments and businesses, and ill tell you something now WE are the most hated, us Brits, not because we are handsome, not because we smell nice, not because we are good hosts but because we have a repuation as under handed arrogant, pull the rug under ya, hooligans. Grow up, there are 10% non whites in England, they live in 60k houses earning 9k a year! One white banker earns 100 million a year! It shows how stupid the general population is when the economic times are bad they send stories in the press about immigration and terrorism. DONT YOU GET IT YOU IDIOT?
Stick to racing your car (sorry, 'not letting boy racers overtake'). You are evidently a moron. No doubt you will tell us that the 2001 Muslim Riots in Bradford were an act of revolution to be celebrated.

Jammy2010 says...
5:46pm Thu 10 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
Jammy2010 wrote:
albion wrote: "they feel that when johnny foreigner was scared of the hosts and their police force the country was better!" It was!
It wasnt! The British arent as hated as much as they were, infact i can probably walk in most european countries without getting set upon. Unlike you Albion i like to travel, i have overseas investments and businesses, and ill tell you something now WE are the most hated, us Brits, not because we are handsome, not because we smell nice, not because we are good hosts but because we have a repuation as under handed arrogant, pull the rug under ya, hooligans. Grow up, there are 10% non whites in England, they live in 60k houses earning 9k a year! One white banker earns 100 million a year! It shows how stupid the general population is when the economic times are bad they send stories in the press about immigration and terrorism. DONT YOU GET IT YOU IDIOT?
Stick to racing your car (sorry, 'not letting boy racers overtake'). You are evidently a moron. No doubt you will tell us that the 2001 Muslim Riots in Bradford were an act of revolution to be celebrated.
You condescending pillock, ill stick to telling the truth, you can stick to being a “gent” in Shipley (I didn’t know t,w,a,ts are now called “gents”- obviously you get the memo first!)
They are celebrated, just not among the alcoholic, pub crawling, scum that has now since disappeared, obviously they now know that the fire exits aren’t a safe haven from their cave man actions.
I know why there are tensions and its jealousy. Simple. I am wealthy than most Asians so I never have the problem but who knows, what if I was **** head, drinking away my sorrows from the cheap booze at the Tesco (don’t like I don’t see the boxes being loaded onto the conveyor belt) No doubt they will be the same people up in arms blaming riots for pub closures!
Come to mention, I was in Tesco in a queue and this Asian family was in at the checkout, so their bill comes at £160 and there are gasps from the white people behind me, as I turn and look in to their trolley, it’s full of booze and microwave pizza and chips. The worst part? Not the booze but that their children were with them and are probably going to have a bad diet, drink like their parents, drop out of school, and then blame the government and foreigners for their problems.
Honestly England doesn’t do anything to be rich, we steal the wealth of other nations by meddling in their affairs, how long do you think that’s going to last? Eventually it won’t, and these people wishing to immigrate wont wish anymore, then you can have the lovely greens to yourselves.
I won’t be here as I’d rather not go back to the time of Coal mines and fish and chips followed by the evening wasted in the local. But hey before foreigners came along, the town was bustling, Bradford was the richest City in the North. We had opera, we had stage shows, we had big live bands, we had a premier league football team...the past always looks better until you REALLY think about it.

thecitygent says...
6:01pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)

albion says...
6:08pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Jammy2010 wrote:
albion wrote:
"they feel that when johnny foreigner was scared of the hosts and their police force the country was better!" It was!
It wasnt!

The British arent as hated as much as they were, infact i can probably walk in most european countries without getting set upon.

Unlike you Albion i like to travel, i have overseas investments and businesses, and ill tell you something now WE are the most hated, us Brits, not because we are handsome, not because we smell nice, not because we are good hosts but because we have a repuation as under handed arrogant, pull the rug under ya, hooligans.
Grow up, there are 10% non whites in England, they live in 60k houses earning 9k a year!
One white banker earns 100 million a year!
It shows how stupid the general population is when the economic times are bad they send stories in the press about immigration and terrorism.
DONT YOU GET IT YOU IDIOT?
I dont much care for your lack of restraint in the language of some of your replies.
Its very assuming of you to claim that I dont like to travel, you know nothing of my travel habits or my business interests ( before I retired).
Most of the rest of your post isnt relevant, I have lived in and near Bradford since the 1940s and I consider that it was better a few years ago than it is now, and I have my own opinion as to why, which is what I was indicating in my post.
Just because someone else has a different view of things than you do, does NOT make them an idiot.

Jammy2010 says...
6:28pm Thu 10 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)
Sarcasm, lowest form...well i guess you cant get lower than being a "shipley gent"
I dont drive, i find the taxis are now a lot better, and much more reliable ;)
I hope you tie up your dog ;)

As for Albion, what in gods name is an old bum like you doing online spouting rubbish. I guess for oldies its the only forum that will let them have a say. I guess the best thing about knowing your age is there probably isnt long to go now...you are probably anticipating a painful death hence your devilish comments.

thecitygent says...
6:34pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Jammy2010 wrote:
thecitygent wrote: Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)
Sarcasm, lowest form...well i guess you cant get lower than being a "shipley gent" I dont drive, i find the taxis are now a lot better, and much more reliable ;) I hope you tie up your dog ;) As for Albion, what in gods name is an old bum like you doing online spouting rubbish. I guess for oldies its the only forum that will let them have a say. I guess the best thing about knowing your age is there probably isnt long to go now...you are probably anticipating a painful death hence your devilish comments.
I suppose that you have had more attention this evening than you could normally expect. Credit to you for having obviously overcome a lack of education and a major chip on your shoulder to get this far. I suppose that your next objective will be to grow up. Thanks again for your observations - just keep trying. One day someone might just take you seriously!

albion says...
6:40pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Jammy2010 wrote:
thecitygent wrote:
Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)
Sarcasm, lowest form...well i guess you cant get lower than being a "shipley gent"
I dont drive, i find the taxis are now a lot better, and much more reliable ;)
I hope you tie up your dog ;)

As for Albion, what in gods name is an old bum like you doing online spouting rubbish. I guess for oldies its the only forum that will let them have a say. I guess the best thing about knowing your age is there probably isnt long to go now...you are probably anticipating a painful death hence your devilish comments.
More guesses and assumptions.
Your other contemptuous remarks are not worthy of comment.

Jammy2010 says...
6:42pm Thu 10 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
Jammy2010 wrote:
thecitygent wrote: Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)
Sarcasm, lowest form...well i guess you cant get lower than being a "shipley gent" I dont drive, i find the taxis are now a lot better, and much more reliable ;) I hope you tie up your dog ;) As for Albion, what in gods name is an old bum like you doing online spouting rubbish. I guess for oldies its the only forum that will let them have a say. I guess the best thing about knowing your age is there probably isnt long to go now...you are probably anticipating a painful death hence your devilish comments.
I suppose that you have had more attention this evening than you could normally expect. Credit to you for having obviously overcome a lack of education and a major chip on your shoulder to get this far. I suppose that your next objective will be to grow up. Thanks again for your observations - just keep trying. One day someone might just take you seriously!
Aww i guess i touched a nerve!
There is no "lack" in education, unlike yourself, our teachers instilled a strict discipline in each and every student whom passed through the walls of the finest school in Yorkshire. At least in them days it was.
Anyhow education never stops, thats what Mrs Hartley tought me and that will stick with me for the rest of my live. She also told us the world always evolves and NOTHING stays the same so we should anticpate change and go with it with minds fully open.
So anyway, keep your dog tied up Gent(ilia)

Jammy2010 says...
6:46pm Thu 10 Dec 09

albion wrote:
Jammy2010 wrote:
thecitygent wrote: Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)
Sarcasm, lowest form...well i guess you cant get lower than being a "shipley gent" I dont drive, i find the taxis are now a lot better, and much more reliable ;) I hope you tie up your dog ;) As for Albion, what in gods name is an old bum like you doing online spouting rubbish. I guess for oldies its the only forum that will let them have a say. I guess the best thing about knowing your age is there probably isnt long to go now...you are probably anticipating a painful death hence your devilish comments.
More guesses and assumptions. Your other contemptuous remarks are not worthy of comment.
You are elderly, how else were you around the 40s you creep??
No assumptions here, an old man online, i can only guess the kind of "movies" you are into...i just hope the actors are of legal age!

albion says...
7:46pm Thu 10 Dec 09

Jammy2010 wrote:
albion wrote:
Jammy2010 wrote:
thecitygent wrote: Thanks for taking the time to enlighten us. I am sure that we can rely upon you to add value to our local economy and maintain standards. BTW I hope you pay your car insurance ;)
Sarcasm, lowest form...well i guess you cant get lower than being a "shipley gent" I dont drive, i find the taxis are now a lot better, and much more reliable ;) I hope you tie up your dog ;) As for Albion, what in gods name is an old bum like you doing online spouting rubbish. I guess for oldies its the only forum that will let them have a say. I guess the best thing about knowing your age is there probably isnt long to go now...you are probably anticipating a painful death hence your devilish comments.
More guesses and assumptions. Your other contemptuous remarks are not worthy of comment.
You are elderly, how else were you around the 40s you creep??
No assumptions here, an old man online, i can only guess the kind of "movies" you are into...i just hope the actors are of legal age!
Even MORE guesses and assumptions.
Why not try to approach people in a more civil manner? you might just get better responses.

thecitygent says...
10:06am Fri 11 Dec 09

I bet that Mrs Hartley is proud of how you have turned out. Maybe get a refresher with her and ask for some help with English grammar?

Freddy Elliot says...
11:52am Fri 11 Dec 09

Here here Citygent.
"I was racing an asian lad" but "I don't drive" - slight contradiction there maybe.
"I have overseas investments & Businesses" - I see, so wealthy he uses chaffuer driven limos perhaps.
"our teachers instilled strict discipline in each & every student whom passed through the walls of the finest school in Yorkshire. At least in them days it was" - 10 out of 10 for the tutor who instilled his fine grasp of the queens English there.

jimmyblue says...
1:24pm Fri 11 Dec 09

As everyone have mentioned above, why would anyone organise such a thing. Nothing in bradford that would attract shoppers to come here and shop let alone visit the German Market. Even Thursday Late night shopping was like a ghost town yesterday...

I have friends who are taxi drivers in the city centre who have done the job for 15+ years. They have seen business drop nearly 70%.

The council should cut rent to shop owners by 75% until this whole regeneration is complete.

thecitygent says...
4:55pm Fri 11 Dec 09

jimmyblue wrote:
As everyone have mentioned above, why would anyone organise such a thing. Nothing in bradford that would attract shoppers to come here and shop let alone visit the German Market. Even Thursday Late night shopping was like a ghost town yesterday... I have friends who are taxi drivers in the city centre who have done the job for 15+ years. They have seen business drop nearly 70%. The council should cut rent to shop owners by 75% until this whole regeneration is complete.
One of the comments made in relation to the ongoing Bradford fiasco is that people are apathetic. I disagree - the general tone of the majority of the postings above has been that people are angry and frustrated about what has been allowed to happen to our city. In my opinion the city is fast becoming unrecognisable and I find it depressing how things have changed. There is no denying that it was never a utopia but it was always a good place to live and previous generations of my family have been proud to say that they came from the city. It has often been said that the real issue in Bradford is not that of image, but that of identity. The cold reality is that each year more people are turning their back on Bradford and no longer identify with it. This has major implications for what is left of the retail base of the city, its central leisure attractions, local media (ie the T&A) and for that matter its sporting organisations. Given the current economic climate it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that things are more likely to get worse before they get better. A sample of news headlines on this website over the last few days would suggest the same.

denis court says...
7:56pm Fri 11 Dec 09

It doesn't really matter what Bradford puts on now. As far as the rest of the country thinks, Bradford is famous for race riots and the mela. A German market has as much interest to Bradford's 'asian' population as the suggested freedom of the city for the territorial army has. That is none.
the council has been obsessed with promoting Bradford's links with Pakistan and unfortunately, Pakistan has not got a good image.
Okay, the rest of the population didn't support the market, but it was second rate at best. People wanting to buy quality or differant goods, bar some of the ultra-liberal's none-essential oils, (You know the one who loved living in BD7 so much she couldn't wait to move to Bingley) would not dream of shopping in Bradford and it is these types of shoppers that have fled Bradford. Now if they had a market full of the goods sold in the old JJB store, the city would be heaving with locals!

ms walker says...
5:51pm Sat 12 Dec 09

thecitygent wrote:
jimmyblue wrote:
As everyone have mentioned above, why would anyone organise such a thing. Nothing in bradford that would attract shoppers to come here and shop let alone visit the German Market. Even Thursday Late night shopping was like a ghost town yesterday... I have friends who are taxi drivers in the city centre who have done the job for 15+ years. They have seen business drop nearly 70%. The council should cut rent to shop owners by 75% until this whole regeneration is complete.
One of the comments made in relation to the ongoing Bradford fiasco is that people are apathetic. I disagree - the general tone of the majority of the postings above has been that people are angry and frustrated about what has been allowed to happen to our city. In my opinion the city is fast becoming unrecognisable and I find it depressing how things have changed. There is no denying that it was never a utopia but it was always a good place to live and previous generations of my family have been proud to say that they came from the city. It has often been said that the real issue in Bradford is not that of image, but that of identity. The cold reality is that each year more people are turning their back on Bradford and no longer identify with it. This has major implications for what is left of the retail base of the city, its central leisure attractions, local media (ie the T&A) and for that matter its sporting organisations. Given the current economic climate it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that things are more likely to get worse before they get better. A sample of news headlines on this website over the last few days would suggest the same.
"One of the comments made in relation to the ongoing Bradford fiasco is that people are apathetic. I disagree - the general tone of the majority of the postings above has been that people are angry and frustrated about what has been allowed to happen to our city"
Yes, city gent, they whinge and whine but they don't put pen to paper, or even turn out to vote. This city has suffered decades of poor decisions that have destroyed it, and when people see dereliction they blame each other, instead of beheading our bloody awful council on the steps of City Hall. We ARE lethargic, and we accept their shoddy governance, which is why I am so pleased to see that the Odeon/Wastefield saga has actually catalysed some of Bradford's citizens into action (see saveourodeon. com)
On topic: the German Market didn't appeal to me, so I did not make a deliberate journey into town to visit it. I went to the Leeds one because I happened to be in that area of Leeds to see a band. But Bradford Council say we don't need any other attractions, like a venue, to bring people into OUR city centre. Why would we - we've got a hole! And soon we'll have a bloody park. In a city centre! In this climate! I'd love to know which idiot pushed that idea through.
Incidentally, I noticed our shopping centre was actually uncomfortably crowded today. Perhaps we could have another one sometime. There's a great site near Forster Square.....

huxleyp says...
5:12pm Sun 13 Dec 09

It's just too awkward to shop in Bradford. Parking is inconvenient with both large multi story areas within 100 yds of each other and the other large areas unused at weekends due to the distance from shops.
The city is also isolated in terms of rail links when compared to Leeds and local rail travellers can just as easily visit Leeds as Bradford, with Leeds making a change from local scenery.
The town is on hills which makes wandering around difficult for pushchairs, the elderly and heavy bag carriers.
It has also suffered from misdirection of funds for community placation such as housing improvements for sections of the community instead of commercial investment which would have created employment enabling the said sections to pay for their own.


The German market is dismantled in Centenary Square after shoppers stayed away The German market is dismantled in Centenary Square after shoppers stayed away

Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses