Village society opposes decision to remove trees from historic Saltaire street

Village society opposes decision to remove trees from historic Saltaire street

Vanessa Pilny ,chair of the Saltaire Village Society ,stands with the trees which are about to be removed from Victoria Road.

Vanessa Pilny ,chair of the Saltaire Village Society, stands with the trees which are about to be removed from Victoria Road.

First published in News

Saltaire Village Society is opposing Bradford Council’s decision to remove all trees from historic Victoria Road as part of £700,000 plans to make the area more pedestrian-friendly.

The plan to axe the mature chestnuts, beeches, maples and rowans was confirmed after a public consultation which gave three options: removing all trees and restoring the pavements to a high standard; removing all trees and replacing them with more appropriate species, where underground works allow, and leaving and managing the trees and pavements as they are.

Option One received the most support - with 40 per cent of people who responded, or 79 people, in favour of chopping down 32 trees. However Vanessa Pilny, chair of Saltaire Village Society, said yesterday that this was not a significant verdict as the vote to keep the trees in some form had actually been split in two.

And she has personally set up a petition against the felling, which has collected 268 signatures since Saturday.

She said: “I acknowledge that 40 per cent of those who responded voted for Option 1, but 54.83 per cent voted for the options that kept trees in some form.”

Mrs Pilny said the e-petition asks for the decision to be revisited so the public and councillors can further explore options.

“Yes, there were no trees when it was built but neither were there cars or tarmac. I'm sure the community and council working together can come up with a middle ground that most people will accept."

Saltaire Village Society's committee has suggested a compromise between Option Two and Option Three - large trees kept where they did not cause a serious problem, smaller trees to replace those removed and a parking free area of setts between Victoria Hall and the College with flower planters to create the feeling of a square.

And the three Green Party councillors for Saltaire, Cllrs Kevin Warnes, Hawarun Hussain and Martin Love have written jointly to the Telegraph & Argus against the wholesale removal of the trees.

The clls said the public response sent two important messages to Bradford Council, firstly that a large majority of people want the big trees removed and secondly that most people favour retaining a tree presence on Victoria Road – provided the trees are appropriate for our limited street space.

Julian Jackson, Bradford Council's Assistant Director for Planning, Transportation and Highways, said: "The decision, by councillors and officers, to remove trees was taken after consultation with people who live there, business owners and other interested parties who agreed it was the preferred option from a choice of alternatives.

"We are investigating the possibility of replacing some of the trees with more suitable species but the overall impact of the work will allow damaged pavements to be repaired so people with pushchairs and disabled people can have better access, more light will filter through to people's homes, and it will allow the whole area to be enhanced and developed for the future.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:06am Wed 18 Jun 14

Nabwood says...

Vanessa Pilny is quite right - 79 people (40%) is very far from a mandate. Such small numbers can only be regarded as inconclusive.

I love trees, and never want to see trees removed, but those pavements are in a pretty bad state, with big roots visible. Is it viable to repair the pavements to a high standard and keep them good for the next decade or more? Genuine question.
Vanessa Pilny is quite right - 79 people (40%) is very far from a mandate. Such small numbers can only be regarded as inconclusive. I love trees, and never want to see trees removed, but those pavements are in a pretty bad state, with big roots visible. Is it viable to repair the pavements to a high standard and keep them good for the next decade or more? Genuine question. Nabwood
  • Score: 0

7:06am Wed 18 Jun 14

Albion. says...

Nabwood wrote:
Vanessa Pilny is quite right - 79 people (40%) is very far from a mandate. Such small numbers can only be regarded as inconclusive.

I love trees, and never want to see trees removed, but those pavements are in a pretty bad state, with big roots visible. Is it viable to repair the pavements to a high standard and keep them good for the next decade or more? Genuine question.
That's true and originally there were no trees in Victoria Road.
[quote][p][bold]Nabwood[/bold] wrote: Vanessa Pilny is quite right - 79 people (40%) is very far from a mandate. Such small numbers can only be regarded as inconclusive. I love trees, and never want to see trees removed, but those pavements are in a pretty bad state, with big roots visible. Is it viable to repair the pavements to a high standard and keep them good for the next decade or more? Genuine question.[/p][/quote]That's true and originally there were no trees in Victoria Road. Albion.
  • Score: 1

10:47am Wed 18 Jun 14

MattLondon says...

Trees are not original, are an eye sore and force pedestrians onto the road.
Trees are not original, are an eye sore and force pedestrians onto the road. MattLondon
  • Score: 1

11:04am Wed 18 Jun 14

Tyke69 says...

All these people complaining the trees are "not original" and weren't there in Titus Salt's time, neither were the pubs and bars but I don't see anyone asking for those to be removed (even though they cause more problems for local people than the trees do - The Tramshed springs to mind!). If these trees have to be removed (and I'm not sure all of them do) then I would like to see them replaced with smaller varieties.
All these people complaining the trees are "not original" and weren't there in Titus Salt's time, neither were the pubs and bars but I don't see anyone asking for those to be removed (even though they cause more problems for local people than the trees do - The Tramshed springs to mind!). If these trees have to be removed (and I'm not sure all of them do) then I would like to see them replaced with smaller varieties. Tyke69
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree