Trees in historic village to be chopped down in controversial move

Trees in historic village to be chopped down in controversial move

Victoria Road, Saltaire, post second world war, before the trees were planted.

Pavements damaged by tree roots along Victoria Road, Saltaire.

Some of the damage the Council hopes to repair as part of its £700,000 plan.

Victoria Road in Saltaire, where there is a proposed move to cut down the trees that line the street.

Shipley MP Philip Davies

Councillor Val Slater

First published in News

TREES which line an historic street in the village of Saltaire are to be cut down as part of £700,000 plans to make the area safer and more attractive to visitors by creating a centrepiece.

But the idea has been slammed by Shipley MP Philip Davies, who said it was drastic and their axing would be a "massive loss" to the World Heritage Site.

People living and working in Saltaire were told about the Council's plans for Victoria Road earlier this year. They were asked to consider three options - removing all of the trees on Victoria Road and restoring the pavements to a high standard; removing all of the trees and replacing them with more appropriate species, where underground works allow, and leaving and managing the trees and pavements as they are.

Now the results have been crunched and Councillor Val Slater, the Council's portfolio holder for housing, planning and transport, said option one received the most support - with 40 per cent of people who responded, or 79 people, backing it.

Council officers are currently looking at how many of the 30-plus trees will come down and how feasible it might be to replace some with other species which would not damage the pavement.

"Residents felt the trees were too big for the street and made it difficult for people with pushchairs or wheelchairs to pass," Cllr Slater said.

Other people said the trees blocked light to their homes.

The plan is to repair pavements, recycling existing stone where possible, along with new Yorkshire stone.

The trees, a mixture of Horse Chestnut, Copper Beech, Norway Maple and Rowan, were planted in the 1950s and Coun Slater hopes their removal will open up the street, as it used to be.

"It's a bit like taking it back to how it was, but with a contemporary twist because it's not a museum - we've got to think about the future," Cllr Slater said.

The work will be phased over two years, starting near Victoria Hall, to create a centrepiece for the village by working with creative groups.

"For me, the exciting bit is around how we can do something quite creative and innovative with the lighting," Cllr Slater said.

In 2009 plans to cut down trees in Saltaire met with a 307 name petition and the condemnation of Lord Wallace of Saltaire and Mr Davies.

Last year four trees were removed at Victoria Road and Saltaire Road following the death of a motorcyclist at the junction whose view was thought to have been obscured by them.

Mr Davies said the latest suggestion to cut the trees down was a bad one.

"I disagree with it," he said.

"Saltaire is a World Heritage Site and Victoria Road is the gateway really for that World Heritage Site. It seems to me that taking the trees down would be a massive loss for the look of the area - they're an incredibly attractive feature and I just think it's a rather drastic option."

The Tory MP said there was no perfect solution to the damage the trees caused to pavements, but said their benefit outweighed the "down side".

"I think removing the trees from Victoria Road will have a negative impact on the look and feel of the village," he added.

Cllr Slater said she was aware that some people would not be happy with the loss of trees.

"But sometimes we've got to make unpopular decisions," she added.

"These things are very emotive and people need to look at the reasons for it, rather than just make a knee-jerk reaction."

The scheme forms part of a new management plan currently being developed for Saltaire, which is required every ten years as part of the UNESCO World Heritage status.

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:47pm Fri 13 Jun 14

Janet78 says...

The trees are only 70 years old max - its not as if Titus Salt had them in his grand plan.
The trees are only 70 years old max - its not as if Titus Salt had them in his grand plan. Janet78
  • Score: 0

8:18pm Fri 13 Jun 14

Scouse bantam says...

What a waste. This will spoil the look of the village. Repair the pavements but leave the greenery alone.
What a waste. This will spoil the look of the village. Repair the pavements but leave the greenery alone. Scouse bantam
  • Score: 6

11:16pm Fri 13 Jun 14

Tollerboy says...

Who is Phillip Davis speaking on behalf of?
Just himself, I think.
Who is Phillip Davis speaking on behalf of? Just himself, I think. Tollerboy
  • Score: -9

12:57pm Sat 14 Jun 14

lovesaltaire says...

While it is true that the consultation showed that 40% wanted no trees, it is not mentioned that 54.83% wanted to either retain the existing trees or replace them with smaller trees. Only comments in support of removing all of the trees have been quoted in this article, what about the many who made comments about the positive aspects of retaining trees? What about a balanced article. There is a petition on change.org requesting the council to scrutinise the decision before any action is taken. http://www.change.or
g/en-GB/petitions/br
adford-metropolitan-
district-council-cal
l-in-the-decision-to
-remove-all-the-tree
s-on-victoria-road-s
altaire-for-further-
scrutiny-by-the-publ
ic-and-council?utm_c
ampaign=new_signatur
e&utm_medium=email&u
tm_source=signature_
receipt#
While it is true that the consultation showed that 40% wanted no trees, it is not mentioned that 54.83% wanted to either retain the existing trees or replace them with smaller trees. Only comments in support of removing all of the trees have been quoted in this article, what about the many who made comments about the positive aspects of retaining trees? What about a balanced article. There is a petition on change.org requesting the council to scrutinise the decision before any action is taken. http://www.change.or g/en-GB/petitions/br adford-metropolitan- district-council-cal l-in-the-decision-to -remove-all-the-tree s-on-victoria-road-s altaire-for-further- scrutiny-by-the-publ ic-and-council?utm_c ampaign=new_signatur e&utm_medium=email&u tm_source=signature_ receipt# lovesaltaire
  • Score: 14

5:45pm Sun 15 Jun 14

Class_War says...

Ok so long as other trees are planted elsewhere to compensate.
Ok so long as other trees are planted elsewhere to compensate. Class_War
  • Score: 2

6:43pm Sun 15 Jun 14

Colin Allcars says...

there weren't many cars in Saltaire when they were planted either, so maybe they should go to?
there weren't many cars in Saltaire when they were planted either, so maybe they should go to? Colin Allcars
  • Score: 24

8:50pm Sun 15 Jun 14

No Shipley College expansion in Saltaire says...

Also: Saltaire will suffer greatly if that horrid Shipley College new Building Plan is allowed to proceed. Both remain an active campaign to destroy a very unique place.

The development at the roundabout has increased rat running through the village, especially Caroline street. Will 'they' install speed bumps? No chance. Rather spend the money destroying the character of the area.
Also: Saltaire will suffer greatly if that horrid Shipley College new Building Plan is allowed to proceed. Both remain an active campaign to destroy a very unique place. The development at the roundabout has increased rat running through the village, especially Caroline street. Will 'they' install speed bumps? No chance. Rather spend the money destroying the character of the area. No Shipley College expansion in Saltaire
  • Score: 9

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree