Thornton turbine plan causes concern among Bronte enthusiasts (From Bradford Telegraph and Argus)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting TANEWS to 80360, or email
Thornton turbine plan causes concern among Bronte enthusiasts
9:00am Monday 11th February 2013 in News
By Chris Young, T&A Reporter
Fears that Bronte Country could become over-run with wind turbines have been re-kindled after plans for three turbines a few hundred metres from the sisters’ birthplace were unveiled.
Over a dozen applications for turbines have been submitted to Bradford Council in the past year, while plans to increase the height of a windfarm in Ovenden Moor was approved by neighbouring Calderdale Council in November.
A society for Haworth’s most famous residents have pledged to fight the latest application.
And protest group Thornton Moor Wind Farm Action Group says the application is just a small example of how the area was being targeted for turbines.
The plans for Old Oxenhope Farm would see three 15-metre turbines.
With the Bronte Parsonage Museum having re-opened this weekend, the society hopes visitors will come flooding in. But Christine Went, heritage and conservation officer, worries that tourists expecting to see the moors that inspired the sisters will instead be greeted with turbines. She said: “OK, these turbines are not huge, but they are not a natural feature either. There is an accumulation of them in the area that is becoming worrying. A woman who came to Haworth to write about the Brontes recently said it’s not worth coming here because it’s all turbines.”
Anthea Orchard, a member of Thornton Moor Wind Farm Action Group, said until Bradford Council creates a wind turbine strategy, more turbine applications will appear.
Other applications in the past 12 months include: six approved turbines across Haworth, Denholme, Steeton Oakworth and Laycock, seven refused turbines across the area, and approval to increase the height of some of the masts at Ovenden Moor from 49 metres to 115 metres.
Decisions still pending include a 55-metre high turbine in Eldwick, a 27-metre turbine at Denholme and two separate 15-metre turbines in Oxenhope.
Meanwhilem, Bradford Council approved a 15-metre tall turbine at Green Acres, Fishbeck Lane, Silsden. Planners said the application, by Anthony Hargreaves, was “relatively close to the urban periphery that is less visually sensitive than less developed areas to the north and north east”.
Comments(6)
BigFigure
says...
10:15am Mon 11 Feb 13
Albion.
says...
11:08am Mon 11 Feb 13
BigFigure wrote:Especially at envelope opening time.
Statements such as "it's all turbines round here" are surely not helpful if trying to build a reasoned argument....the planners must have a right laugh sometimes
manfromthehills
says...
12:15pm Mon 11 Feb 13
angry bradfordian
says...
12:28pm Mon 11 Feb 13
manfromthehills wrote:You're right, it does read as though the reporter is suggesting they were born in Haworth. A bit worrying if a local journalist doesn't know the basic Bronte history!
The reporter shows a lack of knowledge of local history and geography. Old Oxenhope Farm isn't a few hundred metres from the Brontes' birthplace (Thornton) but it is that distance from the place where they lived and wrote and where the vast majority of visitors are to be found. These turbines will have a huge impact on local tourism. Many thousands come from all over the world to enjoy walking in this wild but beautiful countryside so it is essential that Bradford Council designate the moorland around Haworth as a turbine free zone as soon as possible if it isn't to be ruined by creeping 'development' of this kind.
I don't see how turbines would ruin tourism. In the Bronte's time the Worth Valley would have been a TB infested industrial nightmare but no-one's expecting that bit of Bronte heritage to return.
And last time I visited California, the place was covered with turbines, yet I've never heard a single person who's been put off visiting there because of them.
Two of my favourite place to go walking are Ogden and Chelker Reservoirs; 2 places that have turbines.
manfromthehills
says...
12:53pm Mon 11 Feb 13
angry bradfordian wrote:Chelker has three turbines grouped together on a single hill. How would you feel about say a dozen scattered over the hills around Bolton Abbey?
manfromthehills wrote:You're right, it does read as though the reporter is suggesting they were born in Haworth. A bit worrying if a local journalist doesn't know the basic Bronte history!
The reporter shows a lack of knowledge of local history and geography. Old Oxenhope Farm isn't a few hundred metres from the Brontes' birthplace (Thornton) but it is that distance from the place where they lived and wrote and where the vast majority of visitors are to be found. These turbines will have a huge impact on local tourism. Many thousands come from all over the world to enjoy walking in this wild but beautiful countryside so it is essential that Bradford Council designate the moorland around Haworth as a turbine free zone as soon as possible if it isn't to be ruined by creeping 'development' of this kind.
I don't see how turbines would ruin tourism. In the Bronte's time the Worth Valley would have been a TB infested industrial nightmare but no-one's expecting that bit of Bronte heritage to return.
And last time I visited California, the place was covered with turbines, yet I've never heard a single person who's been put off visiting there because of them.
Two of my favourite place to go walking are Ogden and Chelker Reservoirs; 2 places that have turbines.
Will you still enjoy your walk around Ogden when instead of the present tiddlers their replacements of more than double the height are looming over the reservoir?
angry bradfordian says...
9:08am Mon 11 Feb 13
Oxenhope is at least 4 miles from the Bronte's birthplace.
There's nothing like a bit of sensationalism!
A woman who came to Haworth to write about the Brontes recently said it’s not worth coming here because it’s all turbines.”
Really? I can't comprehend what is so offensive about turbines that would make it 'not worth coming'
Would she like children working in mills and open sewers in the street so it would be more like it was in the Bronte's day?