Bishop of Bradford angry at Shipley MP's bid to block lead theft bill

Bishop of Bradford angry at Sipley MP's bid to block lead theft bill Bishop of Bradford angry at Sipley MP's bid to block lead theft bill

The Bishop of Bradford has called on Philip Davies’s Shipley constituents to “question his response” after the MP spoke out against a proposed Parliamentary bill to outlaw selling scrap metal for cash.

The Bishop, the Right Reverend Nick Baines, believes a new bill outlawing cash for scrap will make it harder for thieves get cash for their spoils and has urged MPs across the district to back the bill, which will have its third reading next week.

He wrote to Mr Davies, who opposes the Metal Theft and Scrap Dealers Metal Bill because it does not go far enough. Mr Davies wants tougher sentences for illegal scrap dealers.

However, Mr Davies told the Telegraph & Argus the new private members bill, put forward by his Conservative colleague, Croydon MP Richard Ottaway, “would not make a blind bit of difference” unless it came with stricter sentences.

Mr Baines hit back at Mr Davies in his latest blog. The Bishop wrote: “Shipley MP Philip Davies intends to try to talk the bill out. He opposes it because it doesn't go far enough and doesn’t increase sentences for those found guilty.

“Apparently, he disagrees – which is his right. It is also the right of his constituents to question his response. Vote against the bill – no problem; but, why try to talk it out? The bill does not do everything needed to outlaw this pernicious trade, but it certainly helps.”

Mr Davies also criticised Bradford West MP, George Galloway’s claims that ushering in the bill would be “like trying to ban Harold Steptoe”, in reference to the 1960s and 1970s TV rag and bone man in the sit-com Steptoe & Son. Mr Baines wrote: “George Galloway made me laugh (genuinely) when he said it was like trying to ban Steptoe and Son. Good image. But, Harold Steptoe didn’t strip war memorials, railway lines, communications lines, churches, houses and other buildings to get his scrap metal. Bradford constituents – especially those who have suffered from this business – might like to reflect on it.”

Comments(9)

Albion. says...
10:22am Fri 2 Nov 12

Should the church involve itself in politics, would the Bishop have involved himself to this extent if not directly affected?
I doubt that those who commit these crimes will have much trouble in finding a stooge with a bank account, especially if the yards continue to buy anything no matter how suspicious it looks.

Pity poor Bfd! says...
12:50pm Fri 2 Nov 12

Why shouldn't he have his say - isn't that what living in a democracy is all about - free speech?

Metal theft is an insidious blight on all of our communities, so whatever methods can be put in place to make metal dealing harder and more regulated must be seen as the most sensible way to proceed - it's a 'no brainer'!

Albion. says...
12:57pm Fri 2 Nov 12

Pity poor Bfd! wrote:
Why shouldn't he have his say - isn't that what living in a democracy is all about - free speech?

Metal theft is an insidious blight on all of our communities, so whatever methods can be put in place to make metal dealing harder and more regulated must be seen as the most sensible way to proceed - it's a 'no brainer'!
Yes but you aren't on here as a representative of some institution or other.

Outraged English Subject says...
1:26pm Fri 2 Nov 12

Existing rules and regulations are adequate to deal with this sort of crime, if the police and scrap dealers enforce them; preventing scrap metal for cash shall have no effect on the trade, since the perpetrators can effortlessly circumnavigate any purposed new bills.

Pity poor Bfd! says...
1:35pm Fri 2 Nov 12

Albion. wrote:
Pity poor Bfd! wrote: Why shouldn't he have his say - isn't that what living in a democracy is all about - free speech? Metal theft is an insidious blight on all of our communities, so whatever methods can be put in place to make metal dealing harder and more regulated must be seen as the most sensible way to proceed - it's a 'no brainer'!
Yes but you aren't on here as a representative of some institution or other.
And nor am I - just an ordinary person with a comment to make.

Albion. says...
1:38pm Fri 2 Nov 12

Pity poor Bfd! wrote:
Albion. wrote:
Pity poor Bfd! wrote: Why shouldn't he have his say - isn't that what living in a democracy is all about - free speech? Metal theft is an insidious blight on all of our communities, so whatever methods can be put in place to make metal dealing harder and more regulated must be seen as the most sensible way to proceed - it's a 'no brainer'!
Yes but you aren't on here as a representative of some institution or other.
And nor am I - just an ordinary person with a comment to make.
I said YOU!:-)

Discern says...
7:43pm Fri 2 Nov 12

May I just say that I would have more respect for the Bishop of Bradford if he were to be in the news for preaching the Gospel rather than for interfering in the relationship of a hard working MP and his constituents.

Outraged English Subject says...
2:56pm Sat 3 Nov 12

May I just say that I would have more respect for the Bishop of Bradford if he were to be in the news for preaching the Gospel rather than for interfering in the relationship of a soft working and over paid MP and his constituents.

RollandSmoke says...
5:37pm Sun 4 Nov 12

So Bishop we have foodbanks serving record numbers of people and you remain silent. Youth unemployment rises by over 500%, you remain silent. The govenment releases figures showing that between January 2011 and November 2011 10,600 people died within six weeks of having their employment support allowence removed, you remain silent. Some lead gets stolen from your church and suddenly you find your voice. At least we can now see where your priorities lie.
As for Albion's origional comment asking whether the church should be involved in politics, until such a time that the Bishops are thrown out of the house of lords it already is involved and has been for a very long time.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree