Menston Action Group in new bid to halt village housing plans

Members of Menston Action Group at a previous protest Members of Menston Action Group at a previous protest

A determined village group fighting two major housing estates is preparing to launch the next stage of its battle.

Menston Action Group was left reeling by a decision this month that one area they wanted to save from development, Derry Hill fields, should not be registered as a protected village green.

But members say they have more tricks up their sleeve to stop the estates being built and a war chest ready to fund them.

In February, plans for two housing estates were approved by Bradford Council – one for 175 houses at Derry Hill, by Barratt Homes, and another for 135 houses off Bingley Road by Taylor Wimpey.

But these were delayed as villagers launched their unsuccessful village green appeal.

Residents have donated a total of £55,000 for the legal challenges and this “fighting fund” will now be used to launch a judicial review and, if that fails, a civil injunction against the developers to stop them carrying out works they say would damage the village.

The group argues the fields are unsuitable for housing and could leave the village prone to flooding. They have already spent £20,000 on hiring a flood risk assessor to look at the sites and collect evidence.

Today, a newsletter will be sent out to villagers letting them know of the progress, discussing the two avenues of legal action and asking for further contributions to pay for the challenges.

Both housing projects are currently awaiting the final conditions to be signed off by the Council before building work can go ahead. Once they do, Menston Action Group plans to launch a judicial review.

Dr Steve Ellams, a member of the action group, hopes the Council will recognise the flood risks and reverse the planning approvals. If they do not, he is confident they can legally halt the plans. He said: “The village green appeal came and went and it was very disappointing, but it was a means to an end. We knew it would hold things up while we collected irrefutable evidence the land is not suitable for housing.

“I think we would now win a judicial review. I think they just think we’ll go away, but we won’t.”

John Eyles, Bradford Council’s major developments manager, said: “The legal agreements for these sites are in the final stages of completion and consultation with the agreed community groups will take place shortly.”

Comments(6)

yorkshiredude says...
9:22am Wed 31 Oct 12

It saddens me they've found over £50k to throw at something so negative...

allinittogether says...
11:20am Wed 31 Oct 12

yorkshiredude wrote:
It saddens me they've found over £50k to throw at something so negative...
Why is it negative they are fighting to say enough is enough.
Do you know the area? The amount of development in Menston and Guiseley has been resulted in overload of the A65 and overstretching the local amenities.

yorkshiredude says...
12:23pm Wed 31 Oct 12

I know it very well, yes.

They could invest £50k into business there to create jobs etc. Not flogging a dead horse and putting money into a battle they are unlikely to win. Not saying they should lie down and take development without a fight, but that is quite a lot of money that could be put to better use (in my opinion).

Willard says...
12:50pm Wed 31 Oct 12

yorkshiredude wrote:
I know it very well, yes.

They could invest £50k into business there to create jobs etc. Not flogging a dead horse and putting money into a battle they are unlikely to win. Not saying they should lie down and take development without a fight, but that is quite a lot of money that could be put to better use (in my opinion).
I fear you may have a point about the jobs, but as far as I can tell, all the employment land there was grabbed as brown field sites and they built houses on them, The hospital, Silver Cross, Parkinsons and others are now housing estates. From memory there is no emplyment land left. Funny how developers fall over themselves to build on brown land in Menston and Guiseley yet won't touch Bradford. The Bradford city donut effect, just a hole in the middle.
From the stuff I have seen on youtube, they should put that planned water turbine for Saltaire on thosefeilds in Menston, there is enough water flow to make electric and no mistake

yorkshiredude says...
2:16pm Wed 31 Oct 12

Willard wrote:
yorkshiredude wrote:
I know it very well, yes.

They could invest £50k into business there to create jobs etc. Not flogging a dead horse and putting money into a battle they are unlikely to win. Not saying they should lie down and take development without a fight, but that is quite a lot of money that could be put to better use (in my opinion).
I fear you may have a point about the jobs, but as far as I can tell, all the employment land there was grabbed as brown field sites and they built houses on them, The hospital, Silver Cross, Parkinsons and others are now housing estates. From memory there is no emplyment land left. Funny how developers fall over themselves to build on brown land in Menston and Guiseley yet won't touch Bradford. The Bradford city donut effect, just a hole in the middle.
From the stuff I have seen on youtube, they should put that planned water turbine for Saltaire on thosefeilds in Menston, there is enough water flow to make electric and no mistake
Land values in Menston / Guiseley are high enough to justify developers spending money on developing sites and selling them off at a handsome profit.

Something that is not achievable on many sites in the inner city, sadly.

localydocaly says...
10:39pm Sun 4 Nov 12

even more hard earnt cash by earnt by so many is been thrown away by a selfish few !!!!!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree