English Heritage praised for stance over controversial homes plan in Apperley Bridge

English Heritage praised for stance over controversial homes plan in Apperley Bridge

CONTROVERSY: The photomontage of the proposed development

PROTEST: Campaigners against the development have made their opposition clear

First published in News by

ENGLISH Heritage as been praised for continuing to criticise plans to build modern duplex apartments on a hillside overlooking the canal and conservation area at Simpson Green, Apperley Bridge.

Liberal Democrat leader Councillor Jeanette Sunderland says campaigners are delighted at the stance taken by English Heritage which has consistently objected plans by Miller Homes to build flats as part of development of 267 dwellings.

And members of Bradford Council's planning regulatory and appeals committee are due to decide on the controversial proposal when they meet on Thursday, September 4.

Cllr Sunderland commended English Heritage for not changing its views first expressed in a letter sent to the Council in spring this year.

In a letter about the duplex flats dated March 7 English Heritage stated: "..... the scale, form and detailing of the blocks would be too urban in this sensitive location and would be overly dominant in views of and from the listed buildings as well as along the canal corridor."

And in a further response dated July 2 , following the publication of two photomontages of amended plans submitted by Miller Homes, English Heritage stated: "The amended plans do not appear to address this detrimental impact, in fact the photomontages provided serve to underline our concerns."

The watchdog body then writes that the scheme should be refused or amended to omit or redesign the four storey apartment blocks to reduce the harmful impact on the surrounding heritage assets.

Cllr Sunderland said: "This is a really contentious site. People in Idle and Thackley do not want this development or the one at Cote Farm.

"These flats have limited architectural value in this setting. They have a seriously detrimental impact on the setting of listing buildings and the Conservation area.

"In fact when I first saw the photomontages I thought it looked so bad, someone had made them as a joke.

"I cannot see that any public benefit from this plan could possibly outweigh the the harm being done to the character of the landscape and the Conservation area.

"The photomontages produced by the developer just illustrate the point we and objectors have been making.

"In a conservation area that provides a stunning setting for a number of listed buildings, the canal and the locks the developers are proposing to build what looks like a set of public toilets protruding into the skyline which completely dominate and destroy the landscape.

"The application must be rejected."

No-one from Miller Homes was available for comment, but the firm has previously stated its commitment to high quality and good designs.

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

6:56am Thu 28 Aug 14

Idlesteve says...

Worse still is the council plan to close Hemmingway rd to traffic and force it to use Leeds road and Greengates traffic lights to get to Apperley lane. This will cause massive traffic problems and MUST be stopped. Members if the public can attest the council meeting in 4/9/14 at 10am at city hall to object / protest at this crazy scheme.
Worse still is the council plan to close Hemmingway rd to traffic and force it to use Leeds road and Greengates traffic lights to get to Apperley lane. This will cause massive traffic problems and MUST be stopped. Members if the public can attest the council meeting in 4/9/14 at 10am at city hall to object / protest at this crazy scheme. Idlesteve
  • Score: 4

10:18am Thu 28 Aug 14

Scotyke says...

The homes that are needed are low cost, affordable. I doubt if any that could be built on this green area would be.
The homes that are needed are low cost, affordable. I doubt if any that could be built on this green area would be. Scotyke
  • Score: 1

2:57pm Thu 28 Aug 14

More of the same.. says...

English Heritage: that's that splendid bunch that managed to help shalf the residents of Saltaire; alongside Shipley College, Helen Thornton ( Saltaire officer) and the wonderful Bradford Planning dept. Not to mention the somewhat '21st Century' Doreen Lee.
English Heritage: that's that splendid bunch that managed to help shalf the residents of Saltaire; alongside Shipley College, Helen Thornton ( Saltaire officer) and the wonderful Bradford Planning dept. Not to mention the somewhat '21st Century' Doreen Lee. More of the same..
  • Score: 2

3:06pm Thu 28 Aug 14

BCFC1911 says...

25% for social housing !!

Well thats Apperley Bridge now ruined
25% for social housing !! Well thats Apperley Bridge now ruined BCFC1911
  • Score: 1

3:07pm Thu 28 Aug 14

Joedavid says...

More of the same.. wrote:
English Heritage: that's that splendid bunch that managed to help shalf the residents of Saltaire; alongside Shipley College, Helen Thornton ( Saltaire officer) and the wonderful Bradford Planning dept. Not to mention the somewhat '21st Century' Doreen Lee.
English Heritage were no help in saving the Odeon/New Victoria as they supported it being knocked down.
[quote][p][bold]More of the same..[/bold] wrote: English Heritage: that's that splendid bunch that managed to help shalf the residents of Saltaire; alongside Shipley College, Helen Thornton ( Saltaire officer) and the wonderful Bradford Planning dept. Not to mention the somewhat '21st Century' Doreen Lee.[/p][/quote]English Heritage were no help in saving the Odeon/New Victoria as they supported it being knocked down. Joedavid
  • Score: 3

6:09pm Thu 28 Aug 14

Outraged Of Saltaire says...

No doubt Bradford Council will ignore English Heritages concern and it will be approved by the panel. Bradford Council's departments all recommended for approval the plans to build on the largest garden in the Saltaire Conservation Area, most of which falls within the boundary of the UNESCO World Heritage Site, NO CONSERVATION AREA IN THE BRADFORD DISTRICT IS SAFE FROM BRADFORD COUNCIL, FACT!
No doubt Bradford Council will ignore English Heritages concern and it will be approved by the panel. Bradford Council's departments all recommended for approval the plans to build on the largest garden in the Saltaire Conservation Area, most of which falls within the boundary of the UNESCO World Heritage Site, NO CONSERVATION AREA IN THE BRADFORD DISTRICT IS SAFE FROM BRADFORD COUNCIL, FACT! Outraged Of Saltaire
  • Score: 4

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree